Investigating the underlying motives, thought processes, and behavioral patterns
that lead to criminal activity is a complex and multidimensional field of study
known as "psychological understanding of criminal behavior." This abstract
offers a summary of important ideas and methods in the discipline of forensic
psychology, emphasizing how social influences, environmental circumstances, and
individual characteristics interact to shape criminal behavior.
Fundamentally,
psychological theories of criminal conduct highlight how different psychological
constructs such as personality traits, cognitive functions, and emotional states
affect a person's propensity to commit crimes. For example, across age groups
and cultural backgrounds, personality traits including impulsivity,
sensation-seeking, and low empathy have been related to an elevated risk for
criminal behavior.
Introduction:
Psychological studies of criminal behaviour examine the complex interplay of
human thoughts, emotions, and behaviours in criminal activities. This approach
aims to understand the psychological mechanisms driving individuals to engage in
criminal activities and the factors contributing to their development and
persistence.
This understanding is crucial for law enforcement, legal
professionals, policymakers, and mental health practitioners to develop
effective strategies for rehabilitation, intervention, and prevention within the
criminal justice system. Psychological theories emphasize individual
differences, cognitive processes, environmental factors, and social influences
in shaping human conduct.
They provide insights into why certain individuals are
more prone to commit crimes, how criminal thinking patterns evolve, and what
interventions can be employed to address and mitigate criminal behaviour. A
holistic approach that integrates psychological insights with sociological,
criminological, and neuroscientific perspectives is essential for a deeper
understanding of the root causes and contributing factors behind criminal acts.
Psychological Theories
Psychodynamic theory: This theory was originated by Sigmund Freud who is the
founder of psychoanalysis. An individuals' mental strength starts from the
childhood, from where he starts to learn and his growth for good or bad things
start from there only. Person's personality is controlled by unconscious mental
process that is grounded in early process. An individual's drive something is
present at birth for instance food and other necessities. When someone develops
moral standards and values of the family, friends, community, good or bad behaviour is developed is super ego.
Somethings happened in the childhood is constantly drawn in the person's mind,
anger, depression, anxiety of childhood shows up in future. Childhood worst
experiences will affect the future by way of anxiety, stress and depression that
is the main reason most of the youth or teenagers indulge themselves in crimes.
Most of the youth in nowadays are drug addict because of theirr family issues or
issues relating to relationships or if there is doing drugs, they also get
influenced for the mere sake of popularity amongst their friends or group or in
school or later part of their life which is the college or work.
Also, a child whose mother faced domestic violence from his father or his
paternal side the child will develop criminal intent towards his relatives. An
individual's behaviour reflects his maturity level, what is his thought about
crime.
Behavioural theory: Behavioural theories in psychological theories focus on how
learned behaviours and environmental factors contribute to criminal behaviour.
These theories include classical conditioning, operant conditioning, social
learning, and reinforcement and punishment. Classical conditioning, developed by
Ivan Pavlov, suggests that behaviours are learned through associations between
stimuli. Operant conditioning developed by B.F. Skinner, focuses on how
behaviour is influenced by its consequences. Social learning, influenced by
Albert Bandura, suggests that individuals learn behaviours by observing others
and imitating them. Reinforcement and punishment are also key in shaping
behaviour. These theories have practical implications for interventions aimed at
reducing criminality, such as behaviour modification programs, cognitive
behavioural therapy, and social skills training. This is based on early age of
teenagers where a child needs proper attention, love, and care from their
parents. Parents need to protect the children not to indulge in the world of
alcohol, drugs, and smoking. It also associates with the surrounding and
environment of the children living which can also influence them to indulge in
criminal behaviours. So, the parents of the children need to monitor them
regularly at their early stage and show them the love and care they need.
Cognitive theory: Cognitive is defined as an ability to process information.
Cognitive theory is based on how we think, how we perceive the world around us
and the factors that influence our mental development(i.e.) family upbringing,
parental modelling, and personality intelligence. This theory is based on how
behaviour is influenced by the process of individual reasoning. It mainly
focuses on how a person solve the problem and perceive social environment. It is
said that a person who indulges in violence is very less in moral standard.
According to cognitive theory, criminal behaviour is explained in terms of the
mental processes of an individual. Under cognitive theory, moral thinking and
information processing are the two important aspects. Moral development is the
process by which people develop the distinction between what is right and what
is wrong and engage in reasoning between the two. Moral knowledge is to
understand how individuals morally represent the world and how do people reason
about that world. In information processing, the focus is to study how people
acquire, retrieve, and retain information.
Psychopathology And Criminal Behaviour
According to the DSM-5, neuro developmental disorders are a critical link
between psychopathology and criminal behavior because they impair social,
educational, vocational, and personal functioning. Diseases such as certain
learning disorders, ADHD, and autism spectrum disorders may adversely impact the
development of empathy. Issues with anger control and a lack of empathy are
underlying causes of violent behavior, indicating a positive correlation between
empathy deficits and criminal activity.
"Schizophrenia, Schizotypal, and Delusional Disorders" is the umbrella term for
schizophrenia, a psychiatric illness characterized by delusions, hallucinations,
and social dysfunction. Schizophrenia and related disorders, such as bipolar and
depressive disorders, have been linked to criminal activity due to their
explosive and exuberant affect. Manic episodes can result in grandiosity,
extreme confidence, and violent outbursts. Additionally, fraud, sexual
harassment, and mania can lead to theft offenses. Perceived shame, humiliation,
or narcissistic injury are among the causes of criminality in depression.
Suicide following homicide is often linked to psychosis or acute depression.
Anxiety disorders are emotional states that can follow criminal activity, often
characterized by significant concern and unease with a subjective scenario. The
fear of being taken into custody, losing one's freedom, and becoming known as an
"ex-convict" in the community is presumed to be the root cause of these
disorders. Obsessive-compulsive disorder and similar illnesses are characterized
by repressed impulses and fixation traits during the anal phase. According to
Freud, to cope with anxiety, individuals with these disorders regress to the
anal stage of psychosexual development.
To manage aggressive and sexual impulses, three defense strategies are employed:
reaction formation, undoing, and isolation. These techniques involve separating
an impulse from its emotional content, negating an action with its opposite, and
establishing patterns of behavior that contradict one's primary inclinations.
However, there is a lack of research on the connection between criminal behavior
and obsessive-compulsive disorder.
Individuals with trauma-related disorders experience terror, powerlessness, or
horror-related emotions that result in hyperarousal symptoms, re-experiencing
traumatic events, and avoiding trauma-related stimuli. Trauma survivors often
turn to drugs and alcohol as coping mechanisms for their feelings of guilt and
hyperarousal, which can increase their likelihood of committing crimes. Intense
rage behavior can lead to acts of violence and an increase in criminal activity
due to the pharmacological effects of alcohol and other substances.
Dissociative disorders are mental illnesses that affect memory, identity,
emotion, perception, behavior, and sense of self, causing impairments in mental
functioning. Amnesia, fugue, and multiple personalities are common symptoms.
When an individual has multiple personalities, different personas can dominate
their attitudes and actions, potentially increasing criminal activity.
Excessive and exaggerated worry about physical symptoms is a feature of somatic
symptom disorders. This is frequently a mood state that follows criminal action
rather than contributing to it. Anxiety disorders stem from extreme anxiety
brought on by the fear of being arrested, of having to eat, drink, and sleep
with strangers, and of being labelled as an "ex-convict" by the public.
Two
types of sleep disorders include behavioural and physiological abnormalities
during sleep and initiation or continuation disorders, which include dyssomnia
and parasomnia. In criminal trials, these diseases are frequently invoked as
defences. Sleepwalking is a common symptom of several disorders that can lead to
criminal action. The diseases classified as paraphilias, sexual identity
disorders, and sexual dysfunctions involve physiological reactions to sexual
stimuli and are associated with gender complaints, sexual dysfunctions, and
sexual perversion disorders.
Sexual autonomy violations, aggressive acts toward
children, invasions of privacy, and even the murder of a deceased person's body
are all consequences of these diseases. Behavioural issues including hostility
and rule breaking, as well as a persistent incapacity to carry out destructive
behaviours, are characteristics of disruptive disorders, including impulse
control and conduct disorders. There are two types of these diseases:
childhood-onset and adolescent-onset. Physical aggression and trouble forming
peer relationships are hallmarks of childhood-onset disorders. Conversely,
illnesses that manifest throughout adolescence have a lower effect on violent
behaviour and peer interactions and are less severe.
Psychopath And Attributes
Relation between psychopathy and gender: antisocial personality disorder,
another name for psychopathy, is a disorder marked by harmful and maladaptive
behaviours like lying, impulsivity, and crime-committing without regret. These
people do not feel guilty or are impacted by the penalty they get. Research has
indicated a connection between functional brain variations in psychopathic
behaviour and gender, especially in offenders. Compared to male criminals,
female offenders typically attempt fewer crimes, are less cunning, and inflict
more self-harm.
They frequently display high degrees of physical aggression,
commit more violent crimes, and commit acts that draw attention. High levels of
EEG abnormalities, with slow waves being the most common abnormality, were found
in the brains of male and female psychopathic criminals. The bilateral frontal
and centroparietal regions showed higher levels of beta energy in the male
group; the paralimbic cortex, parieto-occipital regions, and basal ganglia were
also found to be affected.
The sense and identification of fear, which informs choices in unpredictable
circumstances, is impaired in male psychopaths. There is a chance that this lack
of fear and empathy are related. Emotional, judgmental, and ethical conduct
issues can result from abnormalities in specific brain regions that make up the
ethical circuit.
A diminished functional connection between the ventromedial
prefrontal cortex and parietal cortex in men, as well as a weakness in the
connectivity between brain regions that are part of the default mode network,
are linked to psychopathic traits. The gender-based synchronization
discrepancies could suggest that male offenders suffer from impairment in brain
connections associated to decision-making and emotional regulation.
Relation between psychopathy and juvenile: The use of psychopathic personality
traits to detect children with behavioural issues has been investigated in
recent research. Studies have indicated that children who exhibit
callous-unemotional features in addition to conduct difficulties are more likely
to engage in severe and chronic antisocial behaviour. As a result, the
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders now lists
callous-unemotional features as a specifier for a severe subgroup of conduct
disorders. However, these investigations have generally ignored the whole
spectrum of psychopathic personality.
According to community-based research,
conduct issues alone or in conjunction with callous-unemotional qualities are
not as closely linked to antisocial consequences as conduct difficulties with
psychopathic personality traits. This indicates that additional research on the multicomponent model of psychopathic personality is necessary to better
understand the behaviour difficulties of children who belong to specific
subgroups.
Although there has been a lot of discussion regarding the link between
antisocial and criminal behaviour and psychopathic personality features, little
is known about the other consequences, such as mental and drug use illnesses.
Prior research has indicated that psychopathic personality traits in childhood
and adolescence are linked to a higher risk of substance abuse; however, these
connections are frequently driven by the traits' comorbidity with conduct issues
in childhood. Attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is linked to a
higher risk of substance abuse and criminality, and it frequently coexists with
both internalizing and externalizing illnesses.
Big Five And Criminal Behaviour
Research has indicated that certain characteristics, such conscientiousness, and
agreeableness, are strongly linked to a variety of criminal activities. For
example, conscientiousness and agreeableness predict adult criminal activity,
but delinquent behaviour is predicted by agreeableness and conscientiousness.
Drug-dealing, burglary, and strong-arming behaviour are characteristics of
12�13-year-old delinquents who score higher on extraversion and lower on
agreeableness, conscientiousness, and openness. Along with conscientiousness and
agreeableness, neuroticism is also a predictor of delinquent behaviour.
Self-reported vandalism has a positive correlation with neuroticism and a
negative correlation with agreeableness and conscientiousness.
When compared to
adolescents who are not delinquent, the antisocial under controllers have
moderate scores on extraversion, openness, and neuroticism and extremely low
scores on agreeableness and conscientiousness. This makes them the most
delinquent subtype. In both men and women, physical violence is linked to high
neuroticism, poor conscientiousness, and low agreeableness. Partner violence and
neuroticism are closely related personality types.
Pen Factors And Criminality
Psychoticism, extraversion, and neuroticism are three crucial personality traits
associated with criminal conduct, according to Eysenck's PEN Model. In
comparison to non-delinquents, delinquents frequently score higher on PEN
dimensions. While psychoticism is characterized by lack of empathy, brutality,
hostility, psychopathy, aggressiveness, and socialization deficit, high
neuroticism scores point to emotional instability, impulsivity, and antisocial
behaviour. The psychoticism and neuroticism scores of adult offenders are
frequently high.
The traits of psychoticism include impulsivity, limited
empathy, hostility, and aggression. Because they are more likely to be exposed
to dangerous and socially unacceptable activities, people with high Imps scores
are also more prone to commit crimes. Research has indicated a favourable
correlation between the pursuit of sensations and reckless and illegal
activities, including but not limited to alcohol and illicit drug misuse,
smoking, and unsafe sexual conduct.
Cognitive Distortion
In criminology and social psychology, the term "cognitive distortion" (CD)
refers to erroneous or biased interpretations of social events. CD is frequently
linked to antisocial behaviour or a poor ability to understand social
situations. Frequently classified as antisocial and criminogenic, it shields
people from responsibility or a poor self-image. CDs have a role in the negative
emotional and behavioural reactions that can finally result in criminal and
abnormal behaviour.
According to studies, CDs can trigger a variety of
aggressive and antisocial behaviours. Juvenile delinquency and child sexual
abuse are very closely linked to CDs. Research has indicated that CDs are more
common among the population of offenders, including young people who have
engaged in sexual offenses. Additionally, CDs are commonly linked to sexual
murderers, who are characterized by offensive and supporting views.
Rather than
being the result of autonomous beliefs, CDs among sexual offenders arose from
underlying causal theories. Delinquents had higher CDs than non-delinquents,
according to earlier validation research. CDs can take many different forms,
including denial, reduction, justification, and rationalization of offending behaviour, and they are frequently associated with externalizing behaviour
problems.
Psychopath And Recidivism
One psychological risk factor that can be used to predict recidivism in a
variety of clinical settings and samples is the Hare PCL-R. It is a key tool for
directing clinical assessments of criminal recidivism and dangerousness since it
reliably predicts recidivism. The average correlation between the PCL-R scores
and recidivism was 0.27 for general recidivism, 0.27 for violent recidivism, and
0.23 for sexual recidivism.
These relationships hold true with other recognized
findings from biological and behavioural studies. Psychopaths have greater
overall recidivism rates than non-psychopaths, according to relative risk data.
Though they were more equally correlated with violent recidivism, PCL-R Factors
2 and 1 were stronger than PCL-R Factor 1 and general recidivism. Scholars have
repeatedly observed that PCL-R scores provide distinct information to the
recidivism prediction beyond that provided by important criminal history,
demographic factors, and personality disorder diagnoses.
Since this review, more
recidivism studies that use The Hare PCL-R as a predictor variable have been
published, extending the validity and reliability of the PCL-R. The claim put
forth by Salekin in their separately carried out meta-analyses, which the PCL-R
predicts recidivism in samples of juvenile offenders, female offenders, male
federal criminals, forensic offenders, and sex offenders, is directly addressed
by this research. The size of the results has been comparable to what the
current review reports.
Conclusion
Criminal behaviour is greatly impacted by psychopathy, an illness marked by
impulsivity, manipulation, and a lack of empathy. Recidivism is more likely as a
result, particularly for severe and violent crimes. Due to resistance to
standard therapy and limitations in tools such as the Hare Psychopathy
Checklist, diagnosing and treating psychopathy can be difficult. Interventions
designed to lower the recidivism rate among psychopathic offenders are crucial
despite these obstacles. Targeted rehabilitation programs and
cognitive-behavioural therapy seem promising, but additional study is required
to create efficient therapies.
It is essential to comprehend the fundamental
causes of psychopathy and how it affects criminal behaviour. Policymakers,
mental health providers, and criminal justice practitioners need to work
together to create thorough methods for diagnosing, treating, and managing risk
for people who exhibit psychopathic tendencies. To address the issues raised by
psychopathy in the context of criminal behaviour, a multidisciplinary and
evidence-based strategy is required.
Reference:
- https://www.intechopen.com/chapters/1155720
- https://www.kemalarikan.com/en/psychopathy-and-gender.html
- https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0047235220302555
- Joh OP, Caspi A, Robins RW, Moffit TE, Stouthamer-Loeber M. The Little Five: Exploring the nomological network of the Five-Factor model of personality in adolescent boys. Child Development 1994; 65: 160-178.
- Eysenck HJ. The biological basis of personality. Springfield, IL: CC Thomas; 1967.
- Romero E, Luengo M, Sobral J. Angeles Personality and antisocial behaviour. Study of temperamental dimensions. Personality and Individual Differences 2001; 31: 329-348.
- Gendreau P, Little T, Goggin C.A meta analysis of the predictors of adult offender recidivism: What works! Criminilogy 1996; 34(4): 575-608.
- Carson, R.C. (1991). Dilemmas in the pathway of DSM-IV. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 100, 302-307.
- Joseph E Jacoby, Classics of criminology (2004), http://catalog.hathitrust.org/api/volumes/oclc/54341835.html
- Robert M Bohm & Brenda L Vogel, A primer on crime and delinquency theory (2011)
Award Winning Article Is Written By: Mr.Keerthi Kumar.R
Authentication No: AP447255600340-14-0424 |
Please Drop Your Comments