Gender neutrality is a notion that seeks to do away with distinctions between
the sexes in the drafting and application of laws. This idea assumes to
guarantee equal legal protection without any gender-based discrimination. This
idea assumes to guarantee equal legal protection without any gender-based
discrimination. According to section 376 of the Indian Penal Code of 1860[i],
only males may be found guilty of committing rape with a female victim as the
sole possible victim. The issue of sexual assault has been an issue of concern
in society for a very long period of time. Almost all nations have recognized it
and recorded it in history, India being one of them.
The word rape originated
from the Latin term "repere" which means to seize or to take by force. So what
is rape? Rape is a form of sexual assault involving sexual intercourse or any
other form of sexual penetration against the will of the person. According to
Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code[ii], "sexual intercourse with a woman
against her will, without her consent, by coercion, misrepresentation, or fraud;
or at a time when she has been intoxicated or duped; or is of unsound mental
health; and in any case, if she is under the age of 18" is defined as rape.
Looking at the definition of it one can clearly see that it focuses on women and
sees them as the victim and not the men or the transgender community.
To
increase the scope of the statute certain recommendations were made by The Law
Commission of India, which has suggested amendments to Section 375 of the Indian
Penal Code to broaden the offense's definition and make it gender-neutral in its
172nd Report on Review of Rape Laws[iii].
Sections 376, 376A through 376D offer
additional recommendations for modifications. The Commission has also proposed
the elimination of Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, the addition of a new
Section 376E dealing with unlawful sexual intercourse, and an increase in the
severity of the punishment under Section 509 of the Indian Penal Code. To close
the gaps in procedural rules, the Commission has suggested several 1973. The
Commission has suggested changing the term "rape" to "sexual assault."
One of
the 172nd Law Commission's suggestions from 2000 was for rape legislation to be
gender-neutral. After the Nirbhaya gangrape, a commission headed by Justice
Verma made several recommendations for changes to rape/sexual assault
legislation to make them gender neutral. Based on the committee's report, the
Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2013 was passed, although these proposals were not
included
Need For Gender Neutrality:
Gender neutrality is something that is desperately needed in society. It should
not just exist in the minds of people or books but in real life. Everyone
deserves and should be treated equally no matter where they are regardless of
their gender. Whenever we think about sexual abuse it has become the mindset of
people that women or girls are the victim and men are assumed to be the
preparators which is not the case all the time.
This is against justice and
equality. The main goal of gender neutrality is to make sure that all genders
have equal access to opportunities and have a fair share when it comes to rights
and restrictions in all areas of life.
There are two major perspectives on gender neutrality in rape laws: [iv].
Neutrality In Case Of Victim:
Whenever we look at any case that deals with sexual
abuse the thought which comes to our mind is abuse towards girls or women. They
are only considered to be the sufferers of the abuse. However, one can not
forget the opportunity for fellows or transgender groups to be abused. Male rape[v] sufferers are typically waved off beneath numerous dangerous dialogues -
"But you are a guy! You ought to have loved all of the domination and the sex!"
Raised into the lifestyle of poisonous masculinity, maximum guys do not even
carry up the reality that they've been raped due to the fact they would not be
taken severely or they could be emasculated.
Neutrality In Case Of Preparator [Vi]-
Men completely are dealt with as perpetrators of Sexual abuse. It presumes that
guys are stronger, consequently, they could dedicate rape and girls can not
dedicate rape due to the fact it's miles bodily and biologically not possible
for a female to dedicate rape. According to a Victim survey of British and
American adult males have proven that three to eight percent of adult males
pronounced at least one sexual abuse in their lifetimes with at least five to
ten percent of all sufferers being male.
Contemporary Rape Laws In India:
Laws In India:
Historically rape as an offense has always been seen as a crime
primarily committed on women, especially in India. The definition of rape in
Indian law, found in section 375, only refers to men as the perpetrators. Sexual
offenses as well such as voyeurism, sexual harassment, and stalking only affect
men as perpetrators. The aggregate term "gender neutrality" has been made fun of
for being a phrase that hides more than it reveals. Even while all types of
gender have the ability to commit the same types of crimes, it means equality
under some gender-specific laws.
Pocso Act:
The 2012 Protections of Children from Sexual Offenses Act (the POCSO Act) [vii]
is a piece of legislation designed to ensure that children are protected from
crimes like sexual assault, pornography, and harassment. Offenses against
children under the age of 18 are covered under this law. The main objective of
this act was to guarantee that the victims would be treated with respect both
during and after the legal process.
POCSO Act makes sexual assaults against male children illegal, but not against
adult males. Male child sexual abuse is dealt with entirely differently than
male adult sexual assault. There is no explanation for this prejudice. India
should allow for the rape of adult males if it can allow for the rape of a male
toddler. However, the guys are at risk due to the conservative belief that only
men utilize their position of authority to oppress women. The feeling of
equality promised by Article 14[vii] of the Indian Constitution also appears to
be absent in light of all these legal provisions for sexual assault and crimes
against women and children. All legislation ought to be gender-neutral.
Section 375:
Rape is defined as "sexual intercourse with a woman against her will, without
her consent, by coercion, misrepresentation, or fraud, or at a time when she has
been intoxicated or duped, or is of unsound mental health, and in any case, if
she is under the age of 18," according to Section 375 of the Indian Penal
Code[viii]. The exception to this rule is marital rape, which does not include
any sexual activity between a man and his adult wife.
According to India's
definition of rape, no one who does not identify as a woman has the ability to
file a lawsuit on behalf of a rape victim. It is shocking that the
aforementioned rule completely disregards any possible rape victim who does not
identify as a woman in a time when the discussion has transcended gender binary
thinking and gender fluidity is a social norm. It reflects the long-held
patriarchal belief that "women" are the weaker sex and are therefore vulnerable
to abuse and manipulation at the hands of "men" in that regard[ix]
Critical Analysis:
Gender is a critical part of human existence[x]. Our gender will have an effect
on our existence duties, rights, and responsibilities, in addition to our
decisions. These alternatives and movements are then constrained via way of
means of the legal guidelines that govern us, and legal guidelines play an
extensive position in pursuing our gender identity.
Today, we stay in a society
wherein gender equality and civil rights are promoted via way of means of
diverse cultures. To realize gender-associated rights and legislation, however,
one has to first dismantle the gender idea. It is a socially and culturally
built period that separates distinctive traits among women and men, in addition
to boys and girls, in keeping with the United Nations. This has something to do
with a person's female and masculine traits.
While figuring out the gender, one has to be aware of the variations in gender
and intercourse definitions. Gender has a social dimension, however, intercourse
is an organic trait of a person generated via way of means of the affiliation of
its chromosomes and hormones, as formerly stated. Margaret Mead defined the
pioneering idea of isolating intercourse and gender all through historic
intervals in her e-book Gender and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies.
Gender equality is plenty greater than simply women and men.
Gender-impartial
rules are described as legal guidelines and tasks that haven't any unequal
effect on a couple of businesses, whether or not bad or positive. However, if
variations withinside the social and cultural settings of the businesses aren't
considered while designing policy, gender equality is probably decreased to
gender discrimination.
This ought to cause a gadget this is vain and fruitless.
In reality, the significance of gender equality is related to civil rights. The
United Nations helps a comparable theory, pointing out that equality between
women and men is needed to uphold human rights.
Conclusion
The whole definition of rape in the Indian Penal Code revolves around
victimizing women and ignoring the other genders. There has been no specific
legislation made in India to provide relief to men or other genders in cases of
sexual assault. Gender neutral rape laws are something that is desperately
needed in society. All types of gender have the ability to commit the same types
of crime.
There is a POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Crimes) for
sexual assaults against boys, but there is no similar provision for adult men.
Such cases go unreported for a number of reasons contrary to social stigma. It
becomes physically impossible for a man to be raped by a woman, as the "man" is
believed to be stronger than the woman.
Since the definition of rape in India is
limited to the insertion of a penis or an object into the vagina, the number of
rapes and sexual assaults against men has steadily increased. There have been
several instances of men being subjected to such crimes, but nothing has been
done due to lack of legal protection.
End-Notes:
- https://doij.org/10.10000/IJLMH.111604 Author- Anushka Yadav
International Journal of Law Management and Humanities
- https://www.business-standard.com/about/what-is-section-375 - Business
Standard Section 375
- https://theamikusqriae.com/gender-neutralisation-of-rape-laws-in-india/
TITLE- GENDER Neutralisation Of Rape Laws In India.
Writer- P.Poojitha
- https://ijirl.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/gender-neutrality-in-the-definition-of-sexual-offences-under-ipc-.pdf
Title- Gender Neutrality In The Definition Of Sexual Offences Under Ipc By:
Anoushka Coutto
- https://ilsijlm.indianlegalsolution.com/a-critical-analysis-on-gender-biased-rape-laws-in-india/
Author- Shruti Gupta - Published On- October 17,2020 - A critical analysis
on gender biased rape laws in India
- https://www.reddyandreddy.org/pocso-is-applicable-to-all-children-irrespective-of-their-gender-delhi-high-court/
- https://www.business-standard.com/about/what-is-section-375
Site Name- Business Standard
- https://www.thecitizen.in/life/the-case-for-gender-neutrality-in-rape-laws-333857
Title - The Case For Gender Neutrality In Rape Laws, Author- Rishabh Chopra
- https://lexpeeps.in/critical-analysis-on-the-need-for-gender-neutral-laws-in-india/
Writer- Vidushi Joshi, Title- Critical Analysis On The Need For Gender
Neutral Laws In India
Please Drop Your Comments