The spread of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19), the breathing sickness from
the most recent known variation of Coronavirus, [1] has in the previous months
been determined and its effects dramatic. The infection, which is thought to
have initially contaminated individuals close to live creature commercial
centers in Wuhan city in Hubei territory in China, has today extended all
throughout the planet.
Health systems are under severe strain, resulting in
disturbing numbers of deaths and serious infection.[2] Despite the fact that we
have an antibody there are still questions on its viability and productivity,
additionally just lavish nations have a predominant situation in the
immunization world.
Most business analysts accept the worldwide economy will shrivel significantly
this year and keep on doing as such for quite a while to come..[3] Equity
arcades have tumbled, trade has collapsed, planes are stranded, and in many
countries, factories have closed. Vacation industry has declined across the
world, with celebrated destinations and clamoring urban communities giving a
creepy, abandoned look. Significant occasions including the Tokyo Olympics,
planned for Summer 2020, have been delayed by at any rate a year.
Other
significant business conversations, data innovation gatherings, [4] the hajj
journey to Mecca,[5] music festivities, and competitions have been put off or
canceled as a result of the infection. The planet is on stop. A huge number of
laborers face dubious prospects, as organizations where they work may not get
by."
With conflicting requests from governments and offices, organizations are
following up on their own, finding a way ways to monitor their laborers, and at
times their stock chains, with no sureness about when the emergency will end.
"The outburst of COVID-19 pandemic has threatened the whole of humanity. It has
proved to be a lockdown on the basic human right of the citizens.[6] This
commentary will help you to discern various human rights put at stake due
to the cruel obstructive measures imposed by the administration due to
the outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic. Human Rights can be considered as a socially
shown standard and process that demands socially grounded humanoid activities,
both at the national and international levels.
This eruption of COVID-19 pandemic has increased the global and nationwide
responses and had shown a rapidly instable need for the protection and promotion
of the well-being and human rights of all. On the outset this article will help
you to appreciate human rights and its relation with the COVID-19 pandemic. In
the successive section, this article will tell you the people who are affected
and assaulted due to the coronavirus."
Additionally, this editorial will discuss the importance of global cooperation
and building trust as a means to overcome this virus. It will also help you to
appreciate various different human rights that are being disturbed due
to the harsh preventive measure implemented throughout the nation.
"Practices that can alleviate the undesirable impacts of this pandemic, and the
future standpoint that the government must adopt are also deliberated
in this article.
The biggest juncture in such critical situation is valuing the human rights as a
source of harmony and not as a source of separation and this can only be
achieved when the government is patent and open to the general public. Moreover
there is a need for strengthening awareness regarding the safeguards which need
to be taken in the current situation, intermittent growth of nongovernmental
actors as facilitator of rights. The article[7] also tells the steps that the
government could take when we recuperate from this pandemic. Everything in this
article is discussed with practical illustrations."
Research Methodology
Statement of Problem:
The prime focus of this project is to human rights and its relation with the
COVID-19 pandemic. The article also discusses about the people who are
distressed and maltreated due to the coronavirus. It will also help you to
understand various different human rights that are being affected due to the
harsh restrictive measure employed throughout the nation.
Objectives:
- To analyze the current situation of COVID and how it has
affected the human rights of different communities.
- To understand the concept of quarantines and restrictions.
- To study the issues relating to the types of human rights being affected
during the crisis.
- To look into the effects of COVID 19 and lockdown on women,
migrant workers and the poor.
Hypothesis:
The COVID-19 pandemic has mostly affected the marginalized communities such as
women, migrant workers and the poor. The effects have been severe on low income
countries particularly.
Research Questions:
- How has COVID-19 affected the human rights disgrace and discrimination?
- Who all are maltreated due to the COVID crisis and how are they
affected?
- How has the UNHRC and other international bodies reacted to the
COVID-19 Pandemic?
- Which is the most vulnerable among the all in the COVID pandemic time?
Research Methodology:
The present research work is a Descriptive and Analytical Research; and
- It is Doctrinal in nature and;
- It is a Mono-disciplinary Legal Research.
- The research design is Exploratory and Descriptive.
- The sources of information are both Secondary (Articles, Books,
Journals, Websites etc.) and Primary (Statutes, International Instruments,
and Government Statistics and reports etc.)
Review of Literature:
Here are some literature reviews that will illustrate that what is the approach
in this research and what are the materials which have been searched for
carrying on this project work.
- International Migration Law by Vincent Chetail:
This book provides a
comprehensive and accessible overview of the many different elements of
international law that govern the movement of persons across borders)
- Tax, Inequality, and Human Rights by Philip Alston and Nikki Reisch:
This book showcases interdisciplinary perspectives on tax policy and
human rights and provides topical analysis of recent international tax reforms
and their implications for human rights
Human Rights and COVID-19
The most recent variation of Coronavirus, known as Coronavirus Disease 2019
(COVID19) is a type of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Virus 2 (SARS-CoV-2).
[8] "Specialists all throughout the planet responded to the episode in an
awkward manner despite admonitions from the World Health Organization to treat
the danger appropriately, [9] ultimately announcing the infection as a
pandemic.
A few governments were delayed to communicate the earnestness of the
circumstance, forced oversight, and compromised writers. Some governments were
slow to broadcast the seriousness of the situation,[10] imposed censorship,[11]
and threatened journalists.[12] Some governments[13] denied the impact of the
disease, views echoed by media outlets,[14] and their delay has cost thousands
of lives. [15]
A couple of governments, shockingly, have made appropriate
strides. Some acted early and showed momentous adaptability, however in an
interlaced world, many couldn't remain insusceptible for long and have expected
to cause further limitations." While the dithering goes on in some countries,
propaganda [16] has proliferated, and complicated efforts to combat.
The right to health is a globally acclaimed human right. As early as 1946, the
World Health Organization acknowledged the enjoyment of the highest attainable
standard of health as a fundamental right. The International Covenant on
Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, which 170 countries have supported,
incorporates the right to wellbeing as a global lawful commitment that ought to
be acknowledged continuously.
As the UN Committee on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights has pushed, the right to health is an "comprehensive right
covering not exclusively to convenient and proper medical services yet in
addition to the basic variables of wellbeing, like admittance to protected and
consumable water and decent disinfection, an adequate inventory of safe food,
sustenance and lodging, sound proficient and natural conditions, and admittance
to health related learning and data, remembering for sexual and regenerative
wellbeing." A further significant perspective is the commitment of the populace
in all wellbeing related dynamic at the local area, public and global
levels.[17]
Talking at the UN Human Rights Council as of late, UN High Commissioner for
Human Rights, Michelle Bachelet, depicted the COVID-19 flare-up as "a genuine
danger to the rights to life and to soundness of individuals all over," and
added that the worldwide human rights system can bring "crucial guideposts that
can strengthen the effectiveness" of global collective response.
What might that framework look like?
On 24 March 2020, the heads of ten UN human rights bodies required a human
rights strategy in battling COVID-19. In approaching global pioneers to
guarantee that human rights are esteemed when governments plan measures to
handle the public health threat presented by the pestilence, [18] the experts
said that the designs to battle the infection should incorporate everybody and
stressed the importance for governments to secure the rights to life and
wellbeing and guarantee admittance to medical services to all who needs it,
without separation.
Explicit consideration ought to be paid to the helpless,
including more seasoned individuals, individuals with handicaps, minorities,
native people groups, exiles, haven searchers and transients, people denied of
their freedom, vagrants, and those living in destitution. They added that
females are at an unnecessarily high danger on the grounds that in numerous
human advancements they are the primary parental figures for the debilitated
inside families. [19]
The experts emphasized that organizations should offer proceeded with
instruction through distance learning and defend admittance to the impaired.
Arrangement of essential labor and products is likewise a state obligation. They
additionally advised that feelings of trepidation and uncertainty that the
pandemic stances can prompt scapegoating and bias, and states should forcefully
uncover bigotry and xenophobia. Numerous states have authorized limitations on
developments and helped observation, which should be done inside a lawful
structure, and such measures ought to be excellent and brief, rigorously vital
and advocated because of a danger to the existence of a country, and not be a
pardon to suppress contradict. ."[20]
The following succinctly recapitulates the experts' key human rights worries
that must be addressed in facing the the test presented by the pandemic,
including a harmony between the certifiable utilization of state forces to
secure general wellbeing, and cutoff points on those forces to guarantee human
rights are regarded: [21]
- Respect rights
- Include everyone
- Guarantee access
- Protect the vulnerable
- Focus on females
- Eliminate racism and xenophobia
- Employ technology
- Limit restrictions and surveillance
- Permit dissent
Thus, 60 UN human rights specialists published a joint call accentuating that
everybody has the privilege to life saving intercessions, and that the COVID-19
emergency can't be settled distinctly with public health and crisis methods,
[22] but must address all other human rights too.. The call expressed that the
ways of thinking of non-segregation, commitment, strengthening, and
responsibility should be spread to all wellbeing related strategies.
In handling
the emergency, states should take extra friendly guard gauges so their help
arrives at the individuals who are all things considered danger of being
unnecessarily influenced by the emergency. That incorporates females, who are as
of now at a distraught financial position, bear an in any event, requesting care
trouble, and live with an expanded danger of gender-based violence.
They lauded
health workers all throughout the planet who face gigantic responsibilities and
hazard their own lives and face pitiful issues when assets are insufficient.
Calling COVID-19 a grave worldwide test, "the business sector in particular
continues to have human rights responsibilities in this crisis. Only with
concerted multilateral efforts, solidarity and mutual trust, will we defeat the
pandemic while becoming more resilient, mature, and united."[23]
All governments bear the main duty to regard, secure, and satisfy human rights.
International human rights law permits governments to check certain rights while
guaranteeing satisfaction of different rights, given the suspension follows
certain particular standards.
For instance, the Siracusa Principles[24] set
out where rights can be suspended to ensure general wellbeing, so that a "state
can take estimates managing a genuine danger to the strength of the populace… .
(these) actions should be explicitly pointed toward forestalling sickness… (and)
due respect will be hard to the global health guidelines of the World Health
Organization.
International law specialists say such delay should be properly
approved, time-bound, and adjusted, and the Principles list tyrannical
standards, or certain rights which can't be banished under any conditions. In
reality, human rights restrictions frustrate, as opposed to help reactions to
general wellbeing crisis and debilitate their productivity.
"Undoubtedly, governments should utilize every one of the resources at their
order to put resources into general wellbeing foundation and shield lives. In
any case, the COVID-19 commonality likewise shows that going ahead, governments
should be clear, genuine and perfectly clear; not limit free flow of data; not
arraign or punish the individuals who moot questions or disputes about public
health. Governments declaring lockdowns will likewise have a commitment to
guarantee that the lockdowns are benevolent not deteriorate the circumstances of
the helpless, specifically traveler work.
Under-revealing isn't an alternative,
nor is it a choice to minimalize danger." Governments should anticipate most
pessimistic scenario circumstances with the goal that they are not
under-arranged. Unambiguousness is a successful weapon during emergency, as the
Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen's way breaking research looking at starvations in
India and China has appeared. [25]
Quarantines, Lockdowns, and Restrictions
Quarantining huge gatherings of individuals or separating them must be done
according to the law, be rigorously fundamental to accomplish a particular and
certified goal, depend on specialized proof, and ought not be discretionary or
biased. Law and order and lawful cycles do put constraints on a state's
activities in such circumstances, which means force should be used only where
severely necessary, and the actions should be transparent and fair.
The
judgment to quarantine should be time-bound, respect human dignity, and be
subject to review. Isolated people ought to approach simple necessities of life,
including food, water, asylum, and medical care. Human rights experts likewise
suggest that isolates where needed ought to be viable with human rights
standards and laws, which means power ought to be utilized just where seriously
essential, and the activities ought to be straightforward and reasonable. These
decisions are resource-dependent.[26]
The isolation of patients and suspected carriers of COVID-19 has gotten
fundamental and setting up devoted clinics and wards also is basic. In any case,
such isolate periods ought to be controlled, should regard the dignity of those
being isolated, and give way to deal with facilities that they need to lead
their everyday lives. Indeed, even where isolating territories or urban areas
may turn out to be quickly essential, it ought to be noticed that mass
constraints hit the denied more than the individuals who are in an ideal
situation.[27]
"Human rights law permits states to force transient limitations on specific
rights in the midst of crisis. These rights can contain the right of free
articulation (to forestall scattering of tales, for instance), the right to free
get together (to forestall the spread of the infection), and the right of free
development (to forestall the scattering of the infection in unaffected zones).
As the risk of spread of the infection is genuine, it is veritable for states to
force restricted constraints on those rights.
Yet, as noted prior, such
discrediting ought to be restricted, time-bound, explicit because of the
emergency and not wide-running, and be directed by fitting specialists. There
are not kidding human rights dangers of organization assuming control over more
powers nd building up an observation foundation that may get ceaseless."[28]
Surveillance Risks
Technology can give valuable insights to governments attempting to follow the
spread of the infection by examining telecom traffic, and telecom partnerships
can give valuable bits of knowledge that can help in perceiving territories and
people that require exceptional attention. Corporations have provided[29]
authorities with 'heat maps' that can help regulate movements of people during
the coverage of the disease.
"Simultaneously, such observation is a certified danger to regard for human
rights. A few governments have apparently utilized facial acknowledgment
innovation to perceive tainted people in the event that they challenge
limitations on their exercises. In different pieces of the world,
machine-intelligible codes are being utilized. Other reconnaissance
techniques[30] have included discourse empowered robots worked by police to
screen secured roads. Uber drivers in certain towns are being alarmed about
potential infection conveying travelers. [31] More simple however meddlesome
structures incorporate stepping people with permanent ink." [32]
Technological advances have huge long haul implications. For instance, experts
accept future airplane travelers may need to agreement to permit carriers to
follow their developments following flights. [33] "While not yet executed, it
is workable for travellers to be observed through their phone and imparted
should it become important, for instance, for a situation where different
commuters on their past flight were subsequently found to have a transmittable
illness.
Such innovation may even send alerts to travelers in the event that
others in their area has been tainted. Similar requirements may turn out to be
essential for the future when approaching enormous incoming large venues and
arenas, such as sports stadia, halls, political rallies, performance halls, with
ubiquitous temperature scanners assessing individuals. Similarly, work
environment gadgets which can permit partners to discover where their
counterparts are in huge workplaces can be inserted with innovation that can
permit allow employers to track their activities."[34]
The genuine expenses of such invasive surveillance will be borne by the
marginalized and economically weak segments of the society. "They are likely to
have insufficient access to healthcare or may live in choked localities such as
urban slums, and where illnesses may break out more easily. They are less likely
to travel easily, and their jobs will become more precarious. Immigrants, asylum
seekers, undocumented workers, and those who may have a prison record may find
another constraint in their attempt to belong and prosper."[35]
Organizations that make gadgets and programming that permit observation on a
mass scale should remember the conceivable abuse of such technology and decide
protections against such abuse through legally binding duties and make different
moves to minimalize the potential for abuse.
Migrant Workers
Migrant Laborers worldwide just as inside India have been overwhelmingly
powerless during this emergency. Sometimes, migrant labors have either been
isolated in where they work, or have confronted restrictions in the places where
they grew up, as they are currently unable to get back to work. Now and again,
migrant labors are caused to feel undesirable back home, [36] out of dread that
they may be infection ridden or have needed to walk many kilometers to get back
to their countries, as public conveyance had been conceded because of the spike.
Some feel stuck in a choice between starvation or Covid, and have sometimes been
gathering in enormous numbers, which makes them considerably more helpless to
contracting to the infection. [37]
Migrant labors typically despise similar rights as nationals of the host
country, which leaves them in an unsafe circumstance during a calamity like the
one as of now. Many have lost their positions heedlessly, their wages not being
paid to them; they have been compelled to abandon the places where they reside;
and they need reasonable wellbeing inclusion or different advantages, including
joblessness protection, should they lose work.
Their admittance to wellbeing
conveniences accessible to residents is restricted. They also lack access to
technology, such as high-speed internet, to do their jobs, and often they are
hired to perform jobs that can only be performed at the site itself, e.g. farms,
mines, oilfields, and construction projects. During the current Covid disaster,
migrant workers getting back to Myanmar from China introduced a horrendous
problem. [38]
As per reports, [39] a considerable lot of the large numbers
level intersection the boundary into China since late January had relinquished
their positions working in stew and eggplant ranches without their compensation
or reserve funds on the grounds that their bosses didn't need them to leave.
Numerous migrant laborers in India were constrained to walk many kilometers to
get back to their homes when their supervisors left them without housing or
wages when the government abruptly announced a three-month cross country
lockdown. [40]
Women
The effect of COVID-19 on females is significant. Women may not find it easy to
work from home because in many cultures, they are expected to bear a
unreasonably large workload at home. This contains focusing on kids and the old,
cooking, and performing other family errands, which their male accomplices might
be reluctant to perform.
Ladies in discourteous, fierce, or manipulative
relations with their companions or inside their families might be at escalated
hazard when they are compelled to remain at home for longer hours, expanding
their weakness. [41] There has been a alarming surge in abusive behavior at home
against ladies during the current COVID-19 flare-up.
Moreover, being principle
parental figures, they are more inclined to be presented to the infection and
fall debilitated. There is likewise different issue, including their admittance
to medical care and administrations. [42]
"The fact that 70% of the world's
health and social workers worldwide are women means they are more imperiled to
the virus at hospitals. "Traditional hierarchy roles where menfolk enjoy more
privileges means that even if a household has access to a personal computer, the
woman working from home may get access to it for fewer hours than her male
partner or youngsters.[43]"
Misgivings have been raised that the factual information of COVID19-influenced
patients doesn't recognize people, making it harder to plan strategy reactions
that influence ladies. A few illnesses, for instance, are more serious for
pregnant ladies. [44]
Marginalized and Poor
The infection is undiscriminating and influences everybody. Wealth, religion,
dietary propensities, sex, actual wellness, or societal position offer no
protection from people or gatherings. In any case, it is at this point clear
that COVID-19 nonsensically impacts poor people, to some extent since they do
not have the assets to take sufficient safeguards.
In A World At Risk, [45] the WHO's Global Preparedness Monitoring Board has
shown how the denied endure the most during a tremendous Disease outbreaks. "
Disease outbreaks disturb the whole wellbeing framework, decreasing admittance
to wellbeing administrations for all infections and conditions, which prompts
significantly more prominent mortality and further financial downturn.
Adverse
consequences are especially significant in delicate and weak settings, where
neediness, helpless administration, frail wellbeing frameworks, absence of trust
in wellbeing administrations, explicit social and strict perspectives and here
and there continuous outfitted clash enormously confuse episode readiness and
reaction," the WHO report said. ."[46]
Importance of rights
All in all, it merits recalling that human rights are general, associated,
unavoidable, interrelated and resolute. "The COVID-19 emergency has uncovered
that notwithstanding the right to wellbeing and life, other significant rights,
including the rights to fairness, vocation, security, security, lodging and
food, are additionally in question. As a portion of these rights are not
effectively enforceable, and statute on monetary, social, and social rights
relies upon liberal acknowledgment, there is the danger of disaggregating the
rights, inferring that certain are a higher priority than others. In such
conditions, human rights bunches must choose the option to engage the state to
offer more bighearted advantages and help bundles, or urge organizations and
well off people to make altruistic commitments." What are in common sense rights
are time and again found regarding needs, and the state concedes them as
advantages. [47]
"Not all authorities have similar reserves and not all societies are at a
similar stage of progress. Hence, partnerships which have the ability to act (on
account of their resources or the assets at their order)[48] are regularly
expected to assume a bigger part in aiding the state meet its destinations to
shield human rights, regardless of whether they might not have any lawful
commitment to do as such." It is likewise obvious that organizations sometimes
are truth be told incapable to meet their commitments (because of absence of
assets or the idea of the emergency) while in others they are basically
reluctant to do as such, which also raises openings among some that
organizations should accomplish more.[49]
Personal views and suggestions
"There are many individuals going through sorrow due to the rapid spread of
COVID-19. The situation is worsening throughout the world and the governments
throughout the world are taking quick and variety of steps to save the populace.
In such a situation it is vital that the government takes sufficient measures
which are not prejudiced, arbitrary, and must be proportionate. Access to health
must be made available to all." Special extents must be taken to meet the need
of people who are at a higher health risk like aged people.
Further the
government must take immediate steps against the people disgrace, stigma,
discrimination, and must, make plans to spread adequate information to all in an
unbiased manner.[50] "Moreover the government must enhance spreading positive
information through Social Media platform. Transparency and Accessibility is the
key to achieve public confidence at national level.[51]
At worldwide level World
Health Organization plays an important role by supporting its member state to
address these challenges of Human Rights and it provides support in developing a
comprehensive approach to tackle the spread of COVID-19. Focusing on Human
Rights as an integral part of public health and is not only an moral requirement
but a set of foundation on how the country responds. At such a interval the
biggest key to defeat this critical situation is by valuing the Human Rights,
and these human rights must be a source of unity not division." And this harmony
can only be achieved when the government is transparent and open to the general
public.
Few of the steps that the government could take after we recover are
mention below:[52]
- The retrieval plans must identify and include special measures for all
the susceptible groups that that are excessively impacted due to this
pandemic like migrants, homeless people, refugees, people without adequate
sanitization facilities, people with disabilities etc. Ensure nourishment,
water, accommodation and other basic facilities to all those highly impacted
due to this virus, income security must also be given
- Mitigate the impact of the crisis on women and girls, including on their
access to sexual and reproductive health/rights, and protection from
domestic and other forms of gender-based violence and ensure their full and
equal representation in all decision-making on short-term mitigation and
long-term recovery [53]
- Increase the universal cooperation with other advanced nations, and work
cooperatively to discover defeat this pandemic.
- All the political leaders, spiritual leaders, actors, entrepreneurs, and
all other stars must encourage unity and must take strict actions against
discriminatory policies.
- The administration must ensure that every person is well informed about
the assistances given to them by the government, more importantly the
government must try to stop rumors that are spread on Social Media.
- Ensure that proportional funds are provided to all the states regardless
of the party ruling there.[54
- Take the lessons learned from this pandemic to refocus action on ending
poverty and inequalities and addressing the underlying human rights concerns
that have left us vulnerable to the pandemic and greatly exacerbated its
effects with a view to building a more inclusive and sustainable world
including for future generations.[55]
- Ensure right to privacy on the newly introduced apps which are used for
surveillance in the COVID-19 response.
- Guarantee participation of all in any decision relating this matter.
- Ensure protection of Human Rights without discrimination, specially the
Right to Life must be protected throughout.
How to improve the current situation?[56]
There are many ways in which the undesirable impacts of COVID-19 can be
mitigated. Numerous countries have adopted certain practice to lessen the evil
impact of harsh steps taken to decrease the spread of virus and protect the
human rights.
Some of such practices are:
- Suspension of house eviction on non-payment of monthly rent for some
months
- Providing special preventive measures to essential service workers.
- Ensuring proper water, sanitization, and health facility to all the slum
area peoples.
- Preserving jobs through economic measures, and providing economic
support to
laborers in this tough time.[57]
- Providing emergency shelter to homeless people.
- Expanding knowledge regarding women's rights to protect them from
domestic
violence.[58]
- Announcing huge economic package to revive the economy, and help every
sector to
start the work more efficiently.[59]
Conclusion
On denouement, it can be said that regarding Human Rights in this pandemic
situation is one of the principal key to defeat this virus. This pandemic has
threatened the whole of Humanity, and now it's the time when the world must
fight back against it. "This virus has evidenced to be a lockdown on the basic
Human Rights. It is very vital to respond to the unprecedented challenge that we
are facing currently.
There is a necessity for an effective structure that can
strengthen the global efforts to bring the world out of this pandemic situation,
and the Human Rights Framework is one such structure that may help the world
coming out of the present situation. International Collaboration is the
requirement of the time, building trust among the countries will help us to beat
this virus.
As we saw that there are several human rights which are being
curtailed due to the harsh restrictive measures adopted by the government in
order to curb the increasing number of cases." And thus there is an immediate
need for introducing such measures which may protect the basic human rights of
all. Pleasure of highest standard of health is the biggest human right which
deserves safeguard in the current situation.
Bibliography and References
Books:
- 2019 International Migration Law. Oxford University Press, Oxford
- Veizis, A. 2020 "Leave no one behind" and access to protection in the
Greek Islands in the COVID-19 era. International Migration, 58(3):264–266
Blogs and Articles:
- Gagnon, J., 2020 COVID-19: Consequences for international migration and
development [blog]. Organisation for Economic Co-ordination and Development.
Development Matters,
- 2 April. Available at
https://oecd-development-matters.org/2020/04/02/covid-19-consequences-for-internationalmigration-and-development/.
- Guadagno, L., 2020 Migrants and the COVID-19 pandemic: An
initial analysis. International Organization for Migration. Migration Research
Series No. 60, Geneva. Available at
https://publications.iom.int/books/mrs-no-60-migrants-and-covid-19-pandemic-initial-analysis.
- International Labour Organization (ILO)\, 2020 Policy brief:
Protecting migrant workers during the COVID-19 pandemic: Recommendations for
policy-makers and constituents. 30 April. Available at
www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/
public/---ed_protect/---protrav/---migrant/documents/publication/wcms_743268.pdf.
- International Organization for Migration (IOM), 2020a COVID-19
identification and monitoring of emerging immigration, consular and visa
needs. Issue brief, 30 April. Available at www.iom.int/sites/default/files/issue_brief_-_ibm_042020. pdf. 2020b COVID-19
Emerging immigration, consular and visa needs and recommendations: Brief II –
managing limited mobility pathways. 15 May. Available at
www.iom.int/sites/default/files/ defaul/issue_brief_2_-_ibm_052020r.pdf.
- International Organization for Migration (IOM) and United Nations High
Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) , 2020 COVID-19: Access
challenges and the implications of border restrictions. 9 May. Available at
https://reliefweb.int/report/world/covid-19-access-challenges-and-implications-borderrestrictions.
- McAuliffe, M. and C. Bauloz, 2020 The coronavirus pandemic
could be devastating for the world's migrants. World Economic Forum, 6 April.
Available at
www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/04/the-coronavirus-pandemiccould-be-devastating-for-the-worlds-refugees/.
Web links:
- World Health Organization: "Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) Pandemic" at
https://www.who. int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019
- International Labour Organization: "COVID-19 and the world of work" at
https://www.ilo.org/ global/topics/coronavirus/lang--en/index.htm
- United Nations Human Rights Office: "COVID-19 and its human rights
dimensions" at https:// www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/COVID-19.aspx
- International Trade Union Confederation: "COVID-19 Pandemic: News From
Unions" at https:// www.ituc-csi.org/covid-19-responses
- International Chamber of Commerce: "COVID-19 Business Continuity Guide"
at https://iccwbo.
org/media-wall/news-speeches/icc-publishes-covid-19-business-continuity-guide/
- International Organization of Employers: "COVID Platform" at https://www.ioe-emp.org/en/ policy-priorities/covid-19/
- Business and Human Rights Resource Centre: "COVID-19 Outbreak Portal" at
https://www. business-humanrights.org/en/covid-19-coronavirus-outbreak
End-Notes:
- Epidemic Data for COVID-19 (China). At https://www.wolframcloud.com/obj/examples/COVID-19China
- For the latest statistics see https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/#countries. For visual representation
see https:// medgic.co/virus/
- GILES Chris, ARNOLD Martin, GREELEY Brendan, 'OECD Warns coronavirus could
halve global growth' Financial Times 2 March 2020. At
https://www.ft.com/content/1356af8c-5c6c-11ea-8033-fa40a0d65a98
- GHAFFARY, Shireen 'Facebook canceled a 5,000-person conference in San
Francisco because of coronavirus' Vox Recode 14 February 2020.
https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/2/14/21138181/facebook-Coronavirus-conference-CoVid-19-san-
francisco-google-china-silicon-valley-tech-san-francisco
- ASSOCIATED PRESS 'Saudi Arabia bans Citizens From Mecca Pilgrimage Over
Virus Fears. 3 March 2020. https://www. huffpost.com/entry/saudi-arabia-bans-citizens-from-mecca-pilgrimage_n_5e5fa89ac5b6732f50eb67fd
- The fatality rate in Hubei, whose population is 59 million, is 2.9%; in the
rest of the country it is 0.4%
- PDF) Esteeming Human Rights in the Time of COVID-19 Pandemic. Available
from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/343139746_Esteeming_Human_Rights_in_the_Time_of_COVID-19_Pandemic
[accessed March 05 2021].
- NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF ALLERGY AND INFECTITIOUS DISEASES 'SARS-COV-
https://www.viprbrc.org/brc/home. spg?decorator=corona_ncov
- WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION 'WHO announces COVID-19 outbreak a pandemic'
12 March 2020 http://www.euro.who.
int/en/health-topics/health-emergencies/coronavirus-CoVid-19/news/news/2020/3/who-announces-CoVid-19-outbreak-a-
pandemic
- WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION 'Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV) SITUATION REPORT –
1' 21 January 2020. https://www.
who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/situation-reports/20200121-sitrep-1-2019-ncov.pdf
The first patient with symptoms was identified in Wuhan on December 1,
2019. Nearly a month later, on December 31, Wuhan authorities announced that
there were 27 of an unknown type of pneumonia and alerted the World Health
Organization; they identified the new virus, 2019- nCov, a week later. The first
death was announced onJanuary 11. By January 29, 2019-nCov cases had been
reported in 15 countries.
- AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL 'Coronavirus: Stop censorship in China' https://www.amnesty.org/en/get-involved/take-action/
Coronavirus-end-censorship-in-china/
- PEN DELHI 'PEN Delhi on the importance of press freedom in India in the
time of Coronavirus 2 April 2020. https://
pendelhistatements.wordpress.com/2020/04/02/pen-delhi-on-the-importance-of-press-freedom-in-india-during-
coronavirus/
- ABUTALEB Yasmeen, DAWSEY Josh, NAKASHIMA Ellen, MILLER Greg 'The U.S. was
beset by denial and dysfunction as the coronavirus raged' Washington Post 4
April 2020. https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2020/04/04/
coronavirus-government-dysfunction/?arc404=true
- ABUTALEB Yasmeen, DAWSEY Josh, NAKASHIMA Ellen, MILLER Greg 'The U.S. was
beset by denial and dysfunction as the coronavirus raged' Washington Post 4
April 2020. https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2020/04/04/
coronavirus-government-dysfunction/?arc404=true
- DE VYNCK Gerrit, GRIFFIN Riley and SEBENIUS Alyza. Bloomberg. 'Coronavirus
Misinformation Is Spreading All Over Social Media' 1 February 2020.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-01-29/Coronavirus-misinformation-is-incubating-
all-over-social-media
- Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. 'UN Human Rights
Treaty Bodies call for human rights approach in fighting COVID-19' 24 March
2020. https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.
aspx?NewsID=25742&LangID=E
- Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. 'UN Human Rights
Treaty Bodies call for human rights approach in fighting COVID-19' 24 March
2020. https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.
aspx?NewsID=25742&LangID=E
- HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH 'China's Censorship Fuels Distrust On Coronavirus' 30
January 2020. https://www.hrw.org/the-day- in-human-rights/2020/01/30. China
initially attempted to suppress the news, which made the problem more acute.
Later
it imposed draconian curbs (such as imposing severe restrictions on movement)
which had probably become necessary because they helped halt the spread of the
virus.
- GABBATT Adam Guardian 'Mike Pence 'not up to task' of leading US
coronavirus response, say experts' 27 February 2020.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/feb/27/mike-pence-Coronavirus-response-experts
- JOLLEY D and LAMBERTY 'From "deep state" leaks to drinking bleach, research
shows these coronavirus conspiracy theories could be as dangerous as the disease
itself' Prospect 2 March 2020. https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/science-and-
technology/Coronavirus-conspiracy-reddit-theories-alcohol-mask-pope-positive
- Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. "COVID-19 and Special
Procedures. https://www.ohchr.org/EN/
HRBodies/SP/Pages/COVID-19-and-Special-Procedures.aspx
- Office of the High Commissioner for Human rights. "No exceptions with
COVID-19: "Everyone has the right to life- saving interventions" – UN
experts say" 26 March, 2020. https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.
aspx?NewsID=25746&LangID=E
- United Nations, Economic and Social Council, Siracusa Principles on the
Limitation and Derogation Provisions in the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights, U.N. Doc. E/CN.4/1985/4, Annex (1985).
http://hrlibrary.umn.edu/instree/ siracusaprinciples.html. See also MILLER, Alan
How a human rights-based approach can help us together get through the COVID-19
crisis:
https://www.strath.ac.uk/humanities/lawschool/blog/CoVid-19andhumanrightsleadership/
- SEN Amartya Development as Freedom (Oxford University Press 1999). Sen
wrote: No famine has ever taken place in the history of the world in a
functioning democracy.
- https://www.epi.org/blog/employer-tax-credits-can-be-part-of-the-economic-response-to-covid-19-if-they-finance-direct-benefits-for-workers/
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4822557/
- HARARI Yuval Noah "The World After Coronavirus" Financial Times 20 March
2020. https://www.ft.com/content/19d90308- 6858-11ea-a3c9-1fe6fedcca75 and
APPLEBAUM Anne "The People in Charge see an Opportunity" The Atlantic 23 March
2020.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/03/when-disease-comes-leaders-grab-more-power/608560/
- REITER Joakim 'Correct use of telecom data can help in this crisis'
Politico 27 March 2020. https://www.politico.eu/
sponsored-content/correct-use-of-telecom-data-can-help-in-this-crisis/
- Known as QR Codes, these codes consist of an array of black and white
squares, typically used for storing URLs or other information which a camera or
smart phone can read, to identify people or objects.
- FRY Erika 'In business vs. coronavirus, coronavirus is winning' Fortune 13
February 2020. https://fortune.com/2020/02/13/
Coronavirus-business-impact-supply-chains/
- TÉTRAULT-FARBER Gabrielle 'Moscow deploys facial recognition technology for
coronavirus quarantine' Reuters 21 February 2020
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-health-moscow-technology/moscow-deploys-facial-recognition-technology-
for-coronavirus-quarantine-idUSKBN20F1RZ
- PRIVACY INTERNATIONAL 'United States: Proposed CDC rules would force
airlines to collect contact tracing information' 12 February 2020. https://privacyinternational.org/examples/3457/united-states-proposed-cdc-rules-would-force-airlines-
collect-contact-tracing
- Singapore has an app that enables such tracking. See HOLMES Aaron
'Singapore is using a high-tech surveillance app to track the coronavirus,
keeping schools and businesses open. Here's how it works.' Business Insider 24
March 2020. https://www.
businessinsider.com/singapore-coronavirus-app-tracking-testing-no-shutdown-how-it-works-2020-3
- TÉTRAULT-FARBER Gabrielle 'Moscow deploys facial recognition technology for
coronavirus quarantine' Reuters 21 February 2020
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-health-moscow-technology/moscow-deploys-facial-recognition-technology-
for-coronavirus-quarantine-idUSKBN20F1RZ
- LALWANI Vijayta 'Why has Modi done this?' Rajasthan workers walk back home
from Gujarat. Scroll. 26 March 2020. https://
scroll.in/article/957245/coronavirus-after-lockdown-migrant-workers-take-a-long-walk-home-from-gujarat-to-rajasthan?fbcli
d=IwAR3vzwor0eKgwQajop64XfD8lKKASEEhg8iXoo2qcDzWHLaD9o4cOgTIHnE
- EUROPEAN WEBSITE ON INTEGRATION 'Overcrowded reception centres and informal
settlements make migrants vulnerable to COVID-19' 17 March 2020
https://ec.europa.eu/migrant-integration/news/overcrowded-reception-centres-and-
informal-settlements-make-migrants-vulnerable-to-covid-19
- RADIO FREE ASIA 'Myanmar Workers Leave China Without Pay, Fearing Virus'
5 February 2020 https://www.rfa.org/english/
news/myanmar/workers-02052020164000.html
- IDLE Tom 'What the Coronavirus Outbreak reveals about the current corporate
response to human rights' Sustainable Brands
https://sustainablebrands.com/read/organizational-change/what-the-Coronavirus-outbreak-reveals-about-the-current-
corporate-response-to-human-rights
- FRAYER Lauren 'Coronavirus Lockdown Sends Migrant Workers On A Long And
Risky Trip Home' National Public Radio 31 March 2020
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/03/31/822642382/coronavirus-lockdown-sends-migrant-
workers-on-a-long-and-risky-trip-home
- HARIDASANI GUPTA Alisha and STAHL Aviva 'For Abused Women, a Pandemic
Lockdown Holds Dangers of Its Own' New York Times 24 March 2020
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/24/us/coronavirus-lockdown-domestic-violence.html
- NEUMAN Scott 'Global Lockdowns Resulting In 'Horrifying Surge' In Domestic
Violence, U.N. Warns' National Public Radio 6 April 2020
https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/04/06/827908402/global-lockdowns-resulting-in-
horrifying-surge-in-domestic-violence-u-n-warns
- MORROW Amanda 'Not just a health issue': How Covid-19 is quietly eroding
women's rights' National Public Radio 26 March 2020 http://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20200326-coronavirus-domestic-violence-gender-perspectives
- HARIDASANI GUPTA Alisha Does Covid-19 Hit Women and Men Differently? U.S.
Isn't Keeping Track New York Times 3 April 2020.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/03/us/coronavirus-male-female-data-bias.html
- Global Preparedness Monitoring Board A World At Risk Sept 2019. https://apps.who.int/gpmb/assets/annual_report/GPMB_ annualreport_2019.pdf
- Id.
- Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights 'What Are Human
Rights?' https://www.ohchr.org/en/issues/pages/ whatarehumanrights.aspx
- https://www.unv.org/Success-stories/Protecting-human-rights-time-COVID-19
- https://www.coe.int/en/web/human-rights-rule-of-law/covid19
- https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/01/upshot/coronavirus-sick-days-service-workers.html?utm_campaign=KHN%3A%20First%20Edition&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=84115304&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-80JKS-RPcDNplQT6IMHAX9mo10VUPT3AeJnMVpoJp30XdOfHUJIbJhOX3ikWrE1olgnmVHlfMTUl616pN-KiOjc5AmGS9VX1NOUmMPe175fgoo34A&_hsmi=84115304
- Supra note 10 at 52.
- 132 In India, Amazon's website offered some questionable products such
as Nirogmaya Nocorona drops, Prasadhak Coronavirus Essential Oils, Kridha
Anticoronavirus potli (bag) with three types of oils, and Ambrosial anti-corona
oil. None of those were scientifically proven, but they were on sale on Amazon's
site in India. After these were exposed in the following tweet, the company
moved promptly to remove the products from its site.
https://twitter.com/threader_app/ status/1243003377036013568?s=20.
- United Nations Report on COVID-19 and Human Right
- WHO COVID-19 and Violence against women
- COVID-19 and Human Rights: We all are in this together, United Nation's
Report
- Addressing Human Rights as the key to the COVID-19 response: WHO's
Report
- https://www.hrw.org/tag/coronavirus.
- Id.
- CDC, Reducing Stigma
Please Drop Your Comments