The Indian Constitution is an excellent document for the protection of citizens’
rights and their interests, and the children are no exception. Our Constitution
has always tried its best to protect children's interests right from the
Preamble, Fundamental Rights, and the current judicial activism, but the rights
of children are infringed in India despite all the constitutional, legal and
institutional provisions. Child labour, child marriage, child abuse, and
exploitation are some problems that violates children's rights on a large scale.
Justice, equal rights, freedom, and fundamental rights are constitutional
provisions that have ended in failure to protect the interests and rights of
children. This paper will analyse the status of the children and their rights in
relation to the Indian Constitution. The paper will also try to get a deeper
insight into the problems and various acts and constitutional measures to
protect the children's right. Children are innocent and need guidance and
assistance.
They are oblivious to life's complexities. Citizens like us must
take their hand in ours and guide them in the right direction, but this can only
happen through international cooperation and proper implementations, so that we
will we be able to achieve our goal of creating a safe environment for children
to prosper. The framers of the constitution expressed their concern about
provisions on the protection of children and made arrangements for the safety of
children that includes to protect their intellectuality, body, honour, their
rights etc.
Umpteen provisions concerning the lives of children were included in
the Constitution. Furthermore, in order to strengthen and safeguard the
constitutional provisions, many laws, policies, and schemes have also been
enacted.
Introduction
In India, there are 472 million children below the age of 18, accounting for 39
percent of the total population. Children aged 0 to 6 years make up a
significant portion of this figure, accounting for 29% of the total.
Furthermore, 73 percent of Indian children live in rural areas, where they have
limited access to basic needs including nutrition, free health care, education,
and protection. Because of the greater percentage of children residing in rural
areas, negative repressions of children's fundamental rights are common.
In
India, the commission for the protection of children's rights (act 2005) has had
some success in promoting children's rights. Notable examples include the
elimination of child labor and the protection of children and young people. The
commission’s purpose is to "ensure that all laws, policy decisions, programs,
and implementation methods are in accordance with the Child Rights perspectives
as exemplified in the Indian constitution and the UN Convention on the Rights of
the Child," which was adopted in 1989.
Promoting children's rights is clearly a
government priority in India, as it is enshrined in the constitution and
protected by legislation. Even after this, children in India continue to suffer
obstacles in obtaining these rights, especially those related to education,
forced labor, and child marriage. As children account for 39 percent of India's
1.21 billion population, it is critical that their rights should be respected.
In 1992, India joined the United Nations on the Rights of the Children to become
an ethical labor market for international corporations.
The Convention arose
from Jebb's desire to alleviate children's suffering by providing them with a
healthy, pleasant, and safe environment in which they could be nourished
physically, intellectually, and psychologically. The Convention resonates
strongly with these aspects. Human rights exist to ensure that people are
treated fairly and properly around the world and to promote their well-being,
but child rights go beyond that. Children, who are defined as anyone under the
age of 18, do require more than just human rights to meet their specific
needs.
The constitution makers were concerned about making provisions for
children's safety and made provisions for protection of children by which
they mean the protection of the mind, of the body, dignity, of their rights,
and so on. The Constitution included numerous provisions concerning the lives of
children. Many laws, policies, and schemes have been enacted to strengthen the
constitutional provisions.
Various Rights of Children
Right to education (Article 28)
Article 21-A of the Constitution provides that "the state's right to education
must provide all children between the ages of six and fourteen with free and
mandatory education in a manner which the state may determine by law. In its
generous interpretation of life and freedom, as laid down by Article 21, the
Supreme Court held that the term freedom does not only include freedom, but also
the standard of living, human rights to live dignified lives and also includes
the right to education.
The Mohini Jain case was strengthened by the supreme
court, which held that the right to education could be limited to primary
education rather than secondary education. The right to free primary education
is crucial for children's development of discipline and life skills, as well as
finding a healthy and safe environment in which is required to nurture their
physiological development. In India, access to education remains a major problem
and a major impediment to the realization of children's rights. India continues
to have the world's largest number of illiterates, with 287 million adults, and
37 percent of the global total.
Though India's literacy rate has increased by
15% between 1991 and 2006, but the total number of illiterates remained high due
to eventual population growth. Even after India's efforts to devote 10.5 percent
of total government spending to education, the country's decentralized nature
means that wealthy states can spend significantly more on education than poorer
states.
Article 26 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, as well as Articles 13
and 14 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights,
represent the right to education in international law. Most importantly, these
Articles ensure that all children, regardless of religion, caste, gender, or
financial circumstance, receive an education. This Article ensures that no child
is denied access to a fundamental education. Everyone should have access to a
basic education.
Right to life
“
Every individual possesses the right to life, liberty, and the security of
individuals,” according to the Indian constitution of 1950, and “no one shall be
deprived of his life or personal liberty...” Even after the constitution's
protection of this fundamental right, the concerns about life, survival, and
child development remain the same. Thousands of children die every day, not only
because of poverty, but also as a result of the widespread practice of female
infanticide.
Female infanticides remains a cultural practice that still
continues, and is the biggest danger to Indian children's right to life.
Thousands of minor Indian girls die every day, either before or after birth,
since they are not desired or accepted by their families. The dowry system,
which tends to make daughters "
an unaffordable economic burden," is one factor
that contributes to the practice of female infanticide.
Numerous Indian family’s
resort to selective abortion of the female foetus to address this issue
(feticide). Even more frightening is when a child's birth is unavoidable,
families drown, poison, suffocate, or cause the child's death through deliberate
misconduct. The reality is even more terrifying: globally, 117 million girls go
missing as a result of selective sex-abortions, and in India, 9 female foetuses
are aborted every minute. India also ranked fourth among countries with the most
skewed sex ratio, with 112 males for every 100 females, due to sex-abortions.
Right to equality
Within the territory of India, the State shall not refuse any person
the equality before the law or equal protection under the law, according to this
Article. Citizens of India, including children, must be treated equally in front
of the law and must be given equal protection by the law, free of discrimination
and unfairness. This right, which is enshrined in the Indian Constitution,
safeguards children's rights so that their dignity and integrity as children are
not abused.
In Indian society, children who are vulnerable are more likely to be
treated unfairly. Discrimination is prohibited under Article 15 of the Indian
Constitution. Nothing in this Article prevents the state from making special
provisions for women and children, according to Article 15(3). Article 15(3)
makes it clear that "special provision" does not imply unequal treatment, but
rather is formed for the well-being and advancement of Indian children.
Right to health (Article 23 and 24)
Access to health is a crucial component of achieving children's rights. Nearly
one million children below the age of five die in India, with an estimated 39
deaths per 1,000 live births. Women and children are disproportionately affected
by barriers to health care, such as maternal and infant coverage. Only one out
of every three Indian women benefits from regular pregnancy monitoring.
Only 37%
of births in rural areas are aided by qualified healthcare professionals. India
has over 204 million malnourished people, with Indian children suffering the
most. India's children suffer from a high prevalence of stunting, with rates as
high as 39%. As a result, the government launched a massive public awareness
campaign to educate the public about the importance of eating a varied and
balanced diet.
Other issues that children face include a high rate of HIV
infections (3700 new infections among children), a lack of clean drinking water,
and proper sanitation. The latter is due to inequitable access to comprehensive
health care for women and children in rural areas.
Employment of children in factories is prohibited (Article 24)
No child under the age of fourteen may be employed in a factory or mine, or in
any other dangerous occupation, as per this Article. Construction or railway
work are examples of hazardous conditions. This Article does not forbid any work
that is not harmful. In India, child labour is regulated and prohibited under
this Article.
Child labour is defined as work that deprives children of their
childhood, ability, and dignity, as well as work that jeopardizes their physical
and mental development. With such a large population, UNICEF estimates that
India has a high rate of child laborers. Following its independence from
colonial rule, India enacted numerous legal protections and laws regarding child labour.
The Right to form an Opinion (Article 12 and 13)
Every child is entitled to express his/her opinions without criticism or
disdain. When adults decide actively on their children's choices, adults have a
right to take their views into account. Although the views of children may not
be based on facts, they nonetheless provide parents with important insights and
should be taken into account. However, the level of maturity and age of the
child depends on that. Children have freedom of speech, as long as their
opinions and understanding do not harm others.
Right of children to be protected from an armed conflict. (Articles 38 and 39)
In this armed conflict innocent children are converted to refugees, prisoners or
armed conflict members and all these circumstances are in violation of war
spirit and of any armed conflict that can severely harm the morale of a child
and the interpretation of ethics, which must be rectified in a safe environment
for nurturing. The government must also make sure that children are not forced
to take part in any armed struggle while trying to rehabilitate children
affected by war.
The right to an identity (Articles 7 and 8)
Children have the right to a name registered legally by the government and a
nationality (that belong to a country). Moreover, in the form of a public record
they must have a right to an identity. This guarantees both domestic support and
access to social services.
Challenges to children rights
Child Labour
The term child labour is defined in Articles 23 and 24 of the
constitution. In recent years, India has made strenuous efforts to combat child
labor through various programs. Food scarcity, extreme poverty, and social and
economic circumstances are all major contributors to this problem. Other factors
include a lack of awareness about the negative effects of child labor, as well
as a lack of basic and meaningful quality education and skills training. Child
labor is frequently the result of adult unemployment or low parental wages,
which forces children to help with household chores. Children who are forced to
work rather than attend school are unable to develop physically, mentally,
emotionally, or psychologically. Despite the fact that India has one of the
world's youngest populations, but there are more than 42.7 million children are
out of school.
Child Abuse
Child sexual abuse is a pervasive problem in India that has a negative impact on
children's health and well-being. According to statistics, one child is sexually
abused every 15 minutes. Child abusers can be divided into two groups, as per
research. The first group accounts for roughly 60% of officially identified
offenders who do not have a sexual preference disorder but commit sexual assault
for various reasons. Those with a sexual preference disorder, such as paedophilia, are in the other group.
Child Marriage
Over the 20-year period 1992–2012, the percentages of girls marrying under the
age of 16 and under the age of 18 in India decreased. Furthermore, the average
age of marriage is 16.6 years. There is some proof that child labor increases
the likelihood of child marriage. Girls who married as children were also less
likely to have completed secondary school. Only 40% of child brides remained
enrolled in school by the age of 15, particularly in comparison to 86 percent of
girls who were not married when they turned 18.
Acts for protection of children
Protection From Sexual Abuse (Pocso) Act 2012
The POCSO Act, 2012 provides for the protection of children from sexual assault,
sexual abuse and pornography crimes, whilst safeguarding the interest of
children through the incorporation of child-friendly mechanisms, at each stage
of the judicial process.
Child Labour (Prohibition And Regulation) 1986 Act
The hiring of children in certain jobs that are dangerous for the child and can
mentally and physically affect the child are prohibited. It governs the working
conditions of children in other jobs and protects them from being exploited and
has severe punishments. It was the intention of this Act to prohibit children's
work commitments in certain jobs and regulate them in areas not prohibited. It
gives the government the power to lay down health and safety regulations
wherever child employment is allowed. Children's working in night is also
forbidden. State and Central Government shall also consider the hours of work
for children.
Supervision And Control Act 1960, The Orphanaces And Other Charitable Homes
This law provides for oversight and control over the homes of abandoned women in
orphanages.
The 2015, Juvenile Justice Act
The earlier Juvenile Justice Act of 1986 was repealed by this, which had
complied with the Child Rights Convention. In 2006 and 2010 this Act was
revised. This Act was reversed in 2015, this Act provides a particular approach
to protecting, treating and developing children and mentions how to protect a
child in a family without home or supplications etc.
In accordance with Section
15 of this Act special arrangements were made to address offenders who commit
abominable offences under age 16-18. This Act provides a special approach to
child protection and treatment and ways to protect a child from all external
threats.
Child Marriage Prohibition 2006
Following the repeat of the Child Marriage Restriction Act, the government of
India introduced the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act 2006. The Act's primary
objective is to prevent marriage between children. This Act guarantees that
marriage between children is entirely eradicated. A child according to this Act
is a woman who is under the age of 18, and a woman who is under the age of 21.
Landmark decision on the rights of children
M.C Mehta v. State of Tamil Nadu [1]
The petitioner was worried about the high incidence of child labour in hazardous
conditions in the Savakis Match factories in Tamil Nadu's Kamaraj district, so
the court issued an order prohibiting child labour in hazardous conditions. The
judgement outlined the constitution's visions and established a connection
between child labour and poverty. It also claimed that the state has failed to
properly eradicate child labour
Sanjay Suri v. Delhi administration [2]
The court issued transfer orders for some of the officers who were found guilty,
as well as laws to protect children in jails. Sanjay Suri's petition focused on
juvenile undertrials. Despite the ban in the Children's Act, several children
were sentenced to prison. The juveniles were grouped with habitual and other
adults, where they were brutalised and forced to perform unpleasant tasks.
Gaurav Jain v. Union of India [3]
The Supreme Court ruled that segregating prostitutes' children was not in their
best interests. The Supreme Court ruled that the children of prostitutes have
the right to equal opportunity, integrity, treatment, and security, and that
they should be recapitalized so that they can enter the mainstream of society
without stigma.
Vishal Jeet v. Union of India [4]
Several directives have been given to prevent children from being sexually
exploited. The state government was ordered by the court to provide
rehabilitation homes for children found begging on the streets and minor girls
forced into the flesh trade.
Sheela Barse v. the Secretary Children’s Aid Society & Ors [5]
The Supreme Court ruled that a child should never be kept in jail
and that a
central law be enforced to add uniformity to the juvenile justice system. The
petition was filed in the public interest due to the inappropriate operation of
a childcare facility in Mumbai.
Unnikrishnan J.P &Ors v. State of andhra Pradesh [6]
The right to education is implicit in the right to life, according to the court.
The Court's decision in this case extended the Right to Education to include in
the Right to Life. The 86th Amendment to the Constitution, passed in 2002,
incorporated the right to education into the right to life.
Conclusion
Despite all these elements of the legal system, there is still a shortage that
exists, and there are still problems to be met in the present and future. There
are many instances where children have been denied justice. Social evils such as
child marriage and child labour continue to exist in society. The explanation
for child labour is, of course, poverty; there have been several instances where
the provisions of the IPC have proven to be ineffective.
There are still cases
where a child is abducted, murdered, or physically, psychologically, or sexually
abused. Even in the today's modern world, the rate of crime is high. The law
should be made more stringent, and all punishments should instill fear in
people's minds. Children have a delicate mind that can be moulded beautifully
into a creative and better vision, they are the gift of god and needs proper
care and attention.
Justice Bhagwati rightly cited that:
the child is a
creature with its own being, nature and ability, and they must be helped to find
them, to reach the maturity, maximum physical and vital energy and the widest,
most profound and highest level of its intellectual, emotional and spiritual
existence".
Children require direction and assistance. They are unaware of the
complexities of life. It is up to citizens like us to take their hand in ours
and lead them in the right direction. Because social workers play such an
important role in eradicating social ills, a more thorough examination of their
qualifications and professional capacity is required. These are the children who
would bring a healthy and prosperous nation to our country. Only with
international cooperation and implementation of the right to development, the
final acknowledgment of children's rights be achieved.
Bibliography
Statues Referred:
- Protection from Sexual Abuse (POCSO) Act 2012
- Constitution of India
- Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act 1986
- Juvenile Justice Act 2015
- Constitution of India
Books Referred:
- M.P. Jain, Indian Constitutional Law 98 (Kamal Law House, Calcutta,
5th edn., 1998).
- M.P. Jain and S.N. Jain, Principles of Administrative Law 38
(Wadhawa, Nagpur, 2001).
Articles Referred:
- Rachit Garg, “Legal framework for the protection of child
rights”, December 6,2020
- Jyoti raj Pathak, “An analytical study on the rights of children and
the constitution of India”, March 9 ,2012
- Imandeep Kaur Grewal, “Understanding Child Rights in India”, September
2011
Websites Referred:
- Realising children’s right in India, available
at https://www.humanium.org/en/india/ (Last Modified November 30, 2019
- Legal framework for the protection of child rights, available at
https://blog.ipleaders.in/legal-framework-protection-child-rights/ (Last
Visited on April 16, 2021)
- Children rights with reference to various provisions of constitution,
available at http://www.legalservicesindia.com/Article/285/Children-Rights-under-the-Constitution.html (Last
Modified August 31, 2017)
- Fundamentals of children rights in India, available at https://www.savethechildren.in/child-protection/fundamentals-of-child-rights-in-india/
(Last visited on April 17, 2021)
End-Notes
- 1991 AIR 417
- 1988 AIR 414
- (1997) 8 SCC 114
- 1990 AIR 1412
- 1987 AIR 656
- 1993 AIR 217
Written By: Himanshi
Please Drop Your Comments