Sex crimes against children are among the most barbaric crimes against humanity.
Sex crimes are increasing at an alarming rate around the world today. India is
one of the five countries in the world with the highest rates of sex crimes
involving children. About 53% of children in India have been subjected to some
form of child sexual abuse. This percentage is increasing by the day and the
existing laws make it difficult to administer justice against these heinous
crimes. It does not provide any form of deterrence.
Introduction
The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR) on 14th November
2012 brought the Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences Act into place to
protect children from offenses like child pornography, sexual assault,
harassment, etc. This statute involves 9 chapters and 46 sections.
Throughout
the reporting, recording, investigation, and testimony processes, POCSO
emphasizes a child friendly environment. Children are not required to report any
abuse to authorities. Here it defines a child as any person under the age of 18
and places the welfare and well-being of the child at all stages as a paramount
concern to ensure their healthy physical, emotional, intellectual, and social
development.
The need for this act was for the speedy delivery of justice to children who
undergo these heinous crimes, hence the case must be completed within one year
of reporting the crime. Some of its salient features include it being
gender-neutral, reporting and recording sexual abuse, and mandatory, including
all lists of sexual offenses against minors, not only this but it also provides
for the protection of minors during the trial of the case. Child sexual abuse
was previously dealt with under IPC Sections 354, 375, 377, and 509.6.
All of
these legal provisions helped protect female victims. Especially when the
victims were men, they often neglected to serve the children of the victims.
Disclosure of the identity of child victims by the media is also punishable.
During the investigation, the police officer who took the child's statement was
not wearing a uniform. They will first check to see if the child's situation is
safe; if not, they will be placed under government control. During that time, he
or she will undergo a medical examination. [1]
Analysis:
The scenario pre-POCSO:
- Various forms of sexual abuse went unrecognized
- The burden of proof lay on the victims, here in the case of children
instilled fear in their minds.
- Marital Rape was not considered Rape.
After the establishment of POCSO:
- Section 4 of the Act punishes Penetrative sexual assault for a term not
less than 7 years which can sometimes also extend to life imprisonment.
- Section 6 provides that "aggravated sexual assault" will be rigorous
imprisonment not less than a term of 10 years.
- Section 13 provides for use of children for pornographic material is
punishable under section 14.
- Section 15 punishes those who store any pornographic material involving
a child.
- Sections 16 and 17 deal with the abatement of an offense. [2]
Limitations:
Under the POCSO act, any form of sexual intercourse with a minor is considered
to be Rape, despite consent is involved or not. This means that people in this
age group can be beaten together regardless of the legal 18-year-old line. This
constituted the court's view that the relationship between the minor "victim"
and the accused defendant was affectionate rather than abusive. [3] At times,
the treatment cost can get really expensive for the victim's family, and
therefore the state might have to bear it.
When it comes to the marriage of minors, then it is illegal under the POCSO Act,
this goes against the existence of personal laws which consider the marriage of
minors to be legal. It is also important everyone involved in the implication of
this Act is well-trained and knows all of its clauses and procedures. Mental
health professionals must be present at every point because any issue involving
an abused child needs to be treated with utmost sensitivity and care. If not
done in the right way, then it can lead to traumatic experiences for the child.
Conclusion:
When we analyze Indian Criminal Law, we can safely conclude that the present law
even after all the amendments still has a lot of limitations and hence needs to
be worked upon. The police need to ensure the whole investigation takes place
smoothly and thoroughly; this includes collecting forensic samples to be stored
properly so that it doesn't get damaged.
The government needs to make sure that the punishment for such heinous offenses
is more severe and scary so that it prevents people from committing crimes of
this nature. Lastly, everyone should have access to resources that spread
awareness about acts of this sort, so that more people are benefitted. It is up
to all of us to make sure every child knows their rights and they are not afraid
to speak up in case they come across any incident of this sort.
References:
- Statutes
- The Indian Evidence Act, 1872
- The Indian Penal Code. 1860
- POCSO Act, 2012
- Websites:
- https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/the-limits-of-pocso/article34076957.ece
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335916674_The_Protection_of_Children_from_Sexual_Offences_Act_POCSO_2012'_in_Clinical_Settings
End-Notes:
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335916674_The_Protection_of_Children_from_Sexual_Offences_Act_POCSO_2012'_in_Clinical_Settings
- Section 27, Chapter III, The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences
Act, 2012
- https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/the-limits-of-pocso/article34076957.ece
Written By: Lochana Hegde - First Year BA LLB student at Christ University, Pune
Please Drop Your Comments