Legal maxims and terms are an established principles or prepositions of law
or a legal policy usually stated in Latin form.[1] These are used on a regular
basis in the legal domain due to their precise and accurate meaning especially
by the judges in order to ensure a tactile base in the judgments. They serve as
a legal jargon due to their confined application and understanding among the
individuals of the legal system. Maxims and legal terms usually do not have the
dogmatic authority of statutes neither they are normally considered as law
except to their application in the adjudicated matters to a certain extent and
in some cases are incorporated by the legislature while framing laws.
Origin of the most of the Latin maxims can be traced in the European states of
medieval era that used Latin as their legal language.[2] With the expansion of
commerce and industry during the 16th and 17th century, English courts were
faced with novel cases for which the judges felt the need for broad
authoritative principles in order to support their judgments because the rules
of the medieval common law proved of little or no significance while deciding
those cases.[3]
The problem of judges and the attitude of early English philosophers like Thomas
Hobbes who in his book Doctor and Student stated that:
Legal maxims are of the same strength as that of acts and statutes[4] and
Francis Bacon who in the preface to his book collection of maxims stated that
maxims would be used in deciding doubts, and helping soundness of judgment, but,
further, in gracing argument, in correcting unprofitable subtlety, and reducing
the same to a more sound and substantial sense of law, in reclaiming vulgar
errors, and, generally, in the amendment in some measure of the very nature and
complexion of the whole law[5] lead to the evolution of legal maxims.
Several eminent lawyer philosophers and jurists came up with the compilation of
legal terms and maxims like the writings of English jurist Sir Edward Coke were
crammed with Latin aphorisms where some were borrowed from the Roman law while
some were invented further the English Lawyer and philosopher Francis Bacon
composed a collection of the maxims of the common law in Latin with an elaborate
commentary on each.
Such collection of legal terms and maxims followed by explanatory comments and
references to the illustrative cases continued to appear during the next three
centuries in England and United States and even the Indian legal system being
subject to British rule for centuries has extensively opted the legal terms and
maxims as a part of the legal jargon.
Indian courts witness and interpret large number of legal maxims and terms some
of them are as follows:
- Actio Personalis Moritur Cum Persona:
This maxim means that a personal right of action dies with person. According
to it a person cannot opt for a legal recourse once he is dead however the
Supreme Court of India has limited its scope to certain actions like actions
for damages for defamation, actions for assault, and actions for other
personal injuries not causing the death of the party. Supreme Court in
Girja Nandini Devi & Ors. Vs Bijendra Narain Choudhury held that an
action for account is not an action for damages ex delicto, and does not
fall within the enumerated classes.
Nor is it such that the relief claimed being personal could not be enjoyed
after death, or granting it would be nugatory.[6] The above maxim plays a
significant role in determining the rights of a person who no longer exists
and reduces the burden of courts to reinterpret those rights repeatedly in
every individual case.
- Nemo debet essex in propria sua causa:
This maxim means that:
No one ought to be judge in its own case. It is human tendency to lean
towards personal benefit whenever possible hence a person presiding over a
matter that involves his personal interest will definitely pass an order or
decree that will help to achieve its personal benefit and in order to avoid
such happenings and to ensure that justice is rendered in real sense it is
necessary to ensure the implementation of this maxim in due course of legal
proceedings in order to ensure justice to the victim.
Application of this maxim is also essential in order to ensure the sanctity
of the judicial process among the masses that is else exposed to criticism
as witnessed recently in the Indian system when the former Chief Justice of
India resided over his own case where he was accused of sexual harassment by
one of his employee, Hence in order to ensure free and impartial trial and
to prevent the judicial proceedings from being subject of criticism its
essential to ensure the proper implementation of the aforesaid maxims.
Other than the legal maxims there are plenty of legal terms that we witness in
legal jargon like Corpus Juris (compendium of law), Guardian Ad Litem (a legal
guardian appointed by the court during the course of litigation to protect the
interests of infant or mentally incompetent person involved in litigation),
Amicus curie (friend of court), Contract (an agreement between two parties that
are enforceable or otherwise recognizable at law), judicial ( concerning the
process of judging) and countless others.
From the above discussion we can conclude that legal terms and maxims are of
higher importance among the people of legal arena because it not only helps the
judges to support their judgments but it also makes the judicial process a bit
more conducive and short due to their precise nature. It saves a lot of time of
people involved in the judicial proceedings and also helps in stipulating ideas
and avoids excess verbal arguments involved. With time they have evolved as an
indispensable part of the judicial system and is also getting common among the
folks.
End-Notes:
- Minakshee Orga Mukherjee, Legal Maxims used by courts in India, mondaq.com,
Khurana & Khurana Advocates and IP Attorneys, June 02 2020, https://www.mondaq.com/india/personal-injury/945062/legal-maxims-used-by-courts-in-india (
Accessed April 1,2021)
- Legal Maxim, Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_maxim#:~:text=Most%20of%20the%20Latin%20maxims,was%20one%20of%20unmingled%20adulation.&text=26)%2C%20they%20are%20described%20as,in%20the%20law%20as%20statutes.
(Accessed April 1, 2021)
- Britannica, T. Editors of Encyclopaedia. "Legal maxim." Encyclopedia
Britannica, May 5, 2009. https://www.britannica.com/topic/legal-maxim.
- Aritra Sarkar, Legal Maxims: Meaning and Importance, Legal bites,
February 4,2020, https://www.legalbites.in/legal-maxims/ (Accessed April 2,
2021)
- Ibid
- Girja Nandini Devi & Ors. Vs Bijendra Narain Choudhury,
MANU/SC/0287/1966: AIR 1967 SC 1124: 1967 (1) SCR
Please Drop Your Comments