Advertising is an instrument in the hands of the people who use it. If evil
men use advertising for base purposes, then evil can result. If honest men use
advertising to sell an honest product with honest enthusiasm, then positive good
for our kind of capitalistic society can result.-
John W. Crawford
Since globalization, there is cutthroat competition in the markets of India.
Every firm or trader want to have edge over other in order to increase their
sales, profits, and business. To promote the product of their company, they do
advertisement to attract the large number of people at the same time. Those
advertisement are made with the only motive to manipulate or influence the
consumer towards the product.
Advertisements play a very vital role, as it creates goodwill for the
manufacturing companies. Therefore, in order to boom and sometimes survival of
the business in the market, companies use the misleading, false and deceptive
advertisement to promote the sales. In this effort, sometimes advertisements are
filled with the claims that are too hard to believe. Like, energy drinks are
depicted as if they give superhuman powers to the consumer.
Some even believe that if they don't consume their chocolate-flavored milk
powder, or if the addition of these powers helps their children absorb more
calcium, their children will not grow properly. These fake advertisements are
promoted by celebrities who never use the product themselves but appear in
advertisements for products that promise consumers the same celebrity skin and
hair. In all cases, the glow on the skin of the actress is due to the skills of
the makeup artist.
Deceptive and false advertising is not only unethical; they distort competition
and, of course, consumer choice. An advertisement becomes misleading or false
when suppose an advertisement of a water purifier that filters only bacteria
(and not viruses) claims that it gives 100 percent safe water, then it is a
false statement or if an advertisement for a face cream claims that it removes
dark spots on the face and even prevents them from coming back, the manufacturer
should be able to prove this. Or else, it is a deceptive advertisement.
Section 2(1) (r) of Consumer Protection Act, 1986 defines the term 'unfair trade
practices.-
Unfair trade practice means a trade practice which, for the
purpose of promoting the sale, use or supply of any goods or for the provision
of any service, adopts any unfair method or unfair or deceptive practice
including any of the false and deceptive practice.
Other such protection acts are Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act
1969, the main objective of the MRTP Act is to ensure that the operation of
economic system does not result in the concentration of economic powers in the
hands of a few hands but MRTP generally did not include any provinces against
misleading and false advertisement but the 1984 amendments in MRTP Act
incorporated, inter alia, new provisions for the regulation of unfair trade
practices e.g. false representations, misleading advertisements, bargain sales,
bait and switch selling, hoarding and destruction of goods etc.
People must be aware of their rights when someone breached their basic rights,
there are many large firms on which consumers has filed a suit for not
performing same activity as promised in the advertisements. This article will
aid marketers to understand the impact advertisements have on consumer buying
decisions.
It would give a suggestion, what entices a customer to choose a particular
product? What are the other factors that lead a customer to buy a product? And
finally, can advertisers still sell their products based on pure facts, or do
they need to add big fancy lines that claims to push their products forward.
Advertising meaning and definition:
An advertisement is a marketing tool, which is used for sales promotion and
publicity by the producers/manufactures to familiarize their product to
consumers. It is a process of communication between the owner of the products or
services and consumers. The consumers become familiar to the effectiveness and
utility of the existing products and future products.
It helps the consumer in taking right decision and it is an art and
communication technique by which the Trademark or brand of the product or
service is made known to the people. According to William J. Stanton,
Advertising consists of all the activities involves in presenting to a group, a
non-personal, oral or visual, openly sponsored message regarding disseminated
through one or more media and is paid for by an identified sponsor[7].
Overall advertising broadens the knowledge of the consumers, it helps the
consumers to but product without wastage of must time, it creates the goodwill
and increase the sales volume of the producers/manufactures. It is necessary to
meet the competition in the market and to survive. Advertising prepares
necessary ground for the salesman to begin his work effectively. And it also
leads to large scale production creating more employment opportunities to the
public in various jobs directly or indirectly.
Misleading and false advertisements:
An advertisement is said to be deceptive if it misleads people, changes reality
and influences consumer buying behavior. In most jurisdictions, advertising
regulations make it illegal to use false or misleading advertising. It is
illegal to misrepresent the quality of any product, or its related
specifications related to its Composition, manufacture, price or place of
origin. "false" refers to the misrepresentation of the facts; false information
can result in an unacceptable number of people using the information to make
wrong decisions, but consumers are vulnerable to advertising when presented with
a unique environment.
They see advertising messages as a guide for purchasing decisions. Consumers are
helpless when they fail to spot misleading news. In the age of wider access to
information, consumers should be careful to gather as much information as
possible. Gathering information or
searching is an important phase of
buying behavior, the warning
buyer beware still holds. Advertising
consists of communications about the characteristics of the product or service.
False advertising consists of intentionally made statements about a product or
service with the aim to Mislead consumers into conclusions about the product or
service.
Advantages and disadvantages of unfair trade practices:
Advantages from the viewpoint of manufactures:
- Increase in the sales:
The main objective of the manufacturer in advertising their products is to
promote sales of its products. Goods produced on a mass scale will retain
existing markets through mass advertising, but they can also expand markets
by attracting more people to their products and suggesting new uses for
them. Advertising is a helping hand in sales.
- Reduces cost:
Sales turnover and encourage mass production of goods are enhanced by
advertising that results in large scale production, average cost of
production reduces and results in higher profits. At the same time, when the
cost of advertising and selling costs gets distributed over a larger volume
of sales, the average cost of selling also lowers down.
- Constant demand:
Seasonal fluctuations on demands for products are smoothened by advertising
generally the manufacturers try to discover and advertise new possible uses
of which a seasonal product maybe put. The innovation of cold tea and cold
coffee for the use during summer has helped in increasing the demand for
these beverages even in that season.
Advantages from the viewpoint of consumers:
- Improvement in quality:
Generally, products are advertised under brand names; when the advertisement
prompts a person to use the product, it is done in the hopes that the
content of that brand is better than that of other brands of the same
product. A repeat order is to be expected based on your expectations.
Otherwise, sales can be very high once and then very low as consumer
confidence in the quality of the product deteriorates.
- Purchasing convenience:
Shopping becomes easy for consumers after advertising. In general, resale
prices (prices at which retailers must sell products) are set and
advertised. advertising offers a definite and positive assurance to the
consumer that they will not be overcharged for the advertised product. The
consumer can make his purchases with the greatest ease and confidence.
- Consumer education:
As an educational and dynamic principle, the main aim of advertising is to
inform and educate customers about new products, their properties, prices
and uses, as well as to convince them to adopt new ways of life, improve
their old habits and indolence and have a better standard of living.
Disadvantages of unfair trade practices:
- Deferred revenue expenditure:
It is an accrued income expense because the results do not occur immediately
as advertising is a significant part of the organization's total budget, so
a large investment does not necessarily produce immediate results that limit
its usefulness.
- Misrepresentation of facts:
A major disadvantage of advertising is the misrepresentation of facts about
products and services. Advertisers often misrepresent the unreal / false
benefits of a product and make big claims to encourage people to take action
that is beneficial to them but is counter to the consumer's self-interest.
- Consumer's deficit:
Advertising arouses desires, since consumers have little purchasing power,
it leads to dissatisfaction, which is obviously undesirable from a social
point of view, especially if it affects a large majority of people.
important if it acts as an impetus for social change.
- Increased cost:
It is highly debated whether advertising creates additional costs for a
product that have to be paid for by the community. In some ways this is true
because the cost of doing it is part of the total cost of the product, but
at the same time it would be unfair to assume that if the cost of
advertising were reduced, the product would inevitably be cheaper. it is one
of the cost elements, but it is cost that brings savings on the sales side.
- Multiplication of needs:
Advertising forces people to buy things they do not need as they are human
instincts, possessions, social recognition, etc. that are induced by the
advertiser to sell products. Various appeals are made to arouse interest in
the product. Feelings and emotions are played with in order to acquire
customers.
All the above factors drive consumer behavior to purchase a product after
viewing the ads. As they are also vulnerable to unfair business practices due to
a lack of knowledge of adequate rights. These unfair business practices can give
manufacturers an advantage in the short term, but in the long run they affect
the organization and ultimately the entire industry and society.
Misrepresentations of the products can be of any kind. Unfair business practices
also cause several grievances and can lead to unwanted financial losses for
sellers.
Existing Legal situation
The Indian Courts are under constant pressure to expand counterfeiting offenses
in order to broaden the base of relief through the mechanism of restricting and
punishing improper conduct in the marketplace. In addition, criminal sanctions
and administrative enforcement are available in the context of monopolies and
restrictive trade. The Practices Act of 1969 (hereafter the "MRTP Act") and the
Consumer Protection Act of 1986 perform the functions of the Unfair Competition
Action.
The MRTP Act, as originally drafted, did not contain any provision to protect
consumers from false or misleading advertising or similar unfair commercial
practices, but important changes were made in 1984 to keep the relationship
honest and truthful between manufacturers and consumers. Therefore, the MRTP
Commission was empowered to prohibit a company from publishing certain types of
advertising that were deemed false and misleading and therefore harm the public
interest.
The purpose of the MRTP law is to ensure that the functioning of the economic
system does not lead to a concentration of economic power in the hands of a few
merchants, which is to be achieved by the approval of the central government on
the proposals for significant expansion, establishment of new undertakings,
mergers, amalgamation, takeovers and the like.
Section 33 of the Act is the important section of the Act that lists the
categories of registrable agreements that cover a wide range of corporate
activities. These restrictive and monopoly agreements include sales, production
and distribution, horizontal and vertical agreements, price discrimination and
non-price discrimination, territorial and customer allocation, price maintenance
in resale and agreements on price reductions.
It is worth noting that any agreement that falls under any of the clauses (a) to
(b) of Section 33 (1) is deemed to be an agreement relating to restrictive
business practices and is a record per se.
The MRTP Act restricts restrictive trade practices in three ways:
- certain types of restrictive trade agreements (e.g. exclusive dealing,
pricing) must be registered;
- the MRTP Commission may investigate any restrictive trade practices and,
if the practices are found to be detrimental to the public interest, order
that they may be suspended or not repeated in the future, or cancel the
agreement; and
- the restrictive business practice of maintaining the resale price is
totally prohibited.
The scope of the term
"unfair trade practices" was recently challenged by
the Supreme Court of India at Lakhanpal National Ltd against the MRTP
Commission. The MRTP law focuses on the effect of the manufacturer's
representation on a person in the street.
In India, until 2002, the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act (MRTP),
enacted to prevent monopolies and restrictive Trade practices, was the primary
anti-unfair business practice legislation in the country. The Competition Act
2002, which delegated all cases pending in the MRTP to the Competition
Commission of India (CCI) for ruling from the stages they were in, no provision
to deal with unfair trade practice was incorporated in the Competition Act and
thus this was instead enforced by the Consumer Protection Act of 1986 (COPRA)
which was already dealing with unfair trade practices.
Article 2 (r) of the Consumer Protection Act 1986 defines unfair trade practices
"A trade practice that uses an unfair or unfair method or deception to promote
the sale, use or delivery of goods or to provide a service, including any of the
following practices : make a statement, whether oral, written or visually,
permit the publication of an advertisement in a newspaper or otherwise, permit
the:
- offering of gifts, prizes or other items with the intent not to appear
as advertised or to give the impression of being to awaken that something is
given or offered free of charge if it is covered in whole or in part by the
total amount charged in the transaction.
- the conduct of a competition, lottery, game of chance or skill with the
aim of directly or indirectly selling, using or providing any product or
commercial interest.
Permits the sale or supply of
goods that are suitable for use are intended or can be used by consumers who
know or have reason to believe that the products do not meet the standards
prescribed by the competent authority regarding performance, composition,
content, design, construction, execution or packaging, insofar as this is
necessary is to prevent or reduce the risk of injury to the person using the
goods. Permits the hoarding or destruction of goods or refuses to sell or offer
for sale the goods or provide a service if the hoarding or destruction or denial
increases or tends to increase the cost of those or similar goods or services.
There are other regulatory agencies also that protect the right of consumers
against unfair trade practices:
- Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI):
The ASCI code was made mandatory for television advertising through the 2006
amendment to the Cable Television Network Rules. According to ASCI rule 7,
advertising must not be discriminatory because of race, caste, etc. on crime,
disorder or incident or vulgar then it should be stopped immediately and to
resolve disputes related to this, the Consumer Complaints Council (CCC) was
established.
- Advertising Agencies Association of India (AAAI):
The Advertising Agencies Association of India (AAAI) is the official national
organization of advertising agencies established to advance their interests so
that they continue to make a substantial and growing contribution to the nation
and work towards the following goals:
To benefit Indian consumers and to protect their interests by helping ensure
that advertising is honest and in good taste, To benefit Indian advertisers by
promoting their sales, increasing their sales and increasing productivity &
profitability, to stimulate business and industrial activity, To benefit media
by establishing sound business practices between advertisers and advertising
agencies and each of the various media owners,
To benefit the nation by
harnessing advertising for the good of the country, its institutions, its
citizens to co-operate with the Government in promoting its social objectives
and in the task of nation-building and, To question advertising that is wasteful
and extravagant to make it possible for the small entrepreneur to grow through
advertising and to compete with the biggest to encourage market and media
research to serve society by meeting its social responsibilities etc.[1].
Many other agencies are Press council of India (PCI) and Prasar Bharati which
preserve the freedom of the press and of maintaining and improving the standards
of press in India. The present Council functions under the Press Council Act
1978. It is a statutory, quasi-judicial body which acts as a watchdog of the
press. It adjudicates the complaints against and by the press for violation of
ethics and for violation of the freedom of the press. And the objectives of
public service broadcasting are achieved in terms of Prasar Bharati Act through
All India Radio and Doordarshan, which earlier were working as media units under
the Ministry of I&B and since the above said date became constituents of Prasar
Bharati.
List of Cases:
- Godfrey Philips India Ltd vs. Akshay Kumar[1]:
The lawsuit was filed against the advertisement challenged by the cigarette
company. The product was sold under the name "Red and White", along with the
sentences that read, "Red and white smokers are unique", the packaging also
contained a picture of actor Akshay Kumar.
And also contained a line describing
the harmful effects of the image of a famous actor promoting the tagged
cigarette, giving the impression of an acrobatic ability like that of the actor.
The case reached the National Commission, where the complainants stated that,
due to the announcement by the National Commission that the complainant could
not appear because he did not represent a volunteer organization, there were no
signs of damage or accidents. The appeal was allowed with no costs.
- Pooja Roy vs. Krishnango Bhattacharya[2]:
M / s Kasko India, a licensed pharmaceutical wholesaler, has been charged with
tampering with the manufacturer's original labels and affixing new printed
labels to extend the expiration date, as well as selling counterfeit medicines
in what was considered an unfair business practice in the pharmaceutical sector.
- Reckitt & Colman of India Ltd. Vs. Kiwi T.T. K. Ltd [3]:
Hon'ble Delhi High Court (S.K. Mahajan, J.) ruled that a manufacturer has the
right to make a statement that their products are the best and to make some
declarations to inflate their products, and the same will not lead to Lawsuits
give other distributors or manufacturers of similar products to initiate
proceedings, as this is not a degradation or defamation of the manufacturer's
products. However, a manufacturer has no right to claim that its competitors'
products are bad at bloating and promoting its goods.
- Consumer Guidance Society v. Amway India Enterprises[4]:
Amway companies that sell a wide variety of consumer goods and nutritional
supplements. Some Amway products were mislabeled and adulterous products such as
Nutrilite Protein, Amway Madrid Safad Musli contained ingredients of a different
quality than stated on the label. According to the results, Amway has recovered
and billed unfair business media outlets and directed them to remove their
mislabeled products and renew their advertisements.
- PepsiCo Inc. and ors. Vs. Hindustan Coca Cola Ltd. and Anr[5]:
It was held by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court that- comparative advertising is
permissible subject to the rider that it does not denigrate the product of the
appellant……If a trader compares his goods with the goods of rival without in any
way advertising that the trademark is used in relation to his goods, there is
prima facie no infringement.
- Buddhist Mission Dental College and Hospital vs. Bhupesh Khurana and Ors[6]:
The appellant published an advertisement in the Hindustan Times inviting
applications for admission in the Degree Course of Bachelor of Dental Surgery (BDS).In
the said advertisement it was specifically highlighted that the appellant
college is a premier dental college of Bihar established and managed by the
Vishwa Buddha Parishad. It was also mentioned in the advertisement that the said
institution is the Buddhist Mission Dental College and Hospital under Magadh
University, Bodh Gaya and Dental Council of India, New Delhi. But latter on it
was found that the institute was neither recognized nor affiliated and the
complainant student lost two valuable years.
Hon'ble court supported the view of the National Consumer Redressal Commission
that this was a case of total misrepresentation on behalf of the institute which
tantamount to unfair trade practice. Hon'ble Court also directed the institute
to pay an additional compensation of Rs One lakh to each of the respondents
along with cost of litigation and the amount of compensation imposed by National
Commission within two months of the direction[7]
Consumers are often exposed to unfair business practices by giant marketers and
consumers are victims of their fierce business competition. The outlook for the
consumer justice system in our country appears positive given the provisions in
Indian laws and regulations and the various proactive measures taken by the
government. Consumers need to be aware of their rights which they can use to
protect themselves from such unfair monopoly practices.
The government should
take steps to educate people about the various remedies they can take if their
rights as a consumer are violated. From business and industry, civil society
organizations and, above all, the consumer. It is important to keep the practice
of unfair trade under control in the years to come.
What to do?
Therefore, with a brief look at the above discussion, false and misleading
advertising poses a serious threat to the consumer in general and to society in
general; However, we must take the following precautions to check and stop this
bad practice:
- Before buying any product, ask yourself: if, why, when, where, how, how much,
how often, how long, etc.
- Consumer Oriented advertisement will have to be truthful and ethical, it must
not mislead the consumer,
- Make honest and truthful statements and assertions, which is essential for the
prohibition of misleading advertising,
- Do not offend the public with decency or morals,
- Do not advertise products that are dangerous or harmful to society or people,
especially minors, and respect fairness in competition, considering the
interests of the consumer,
- Main Demand, Reasons to Buy, Hidden Properties, Different Advantages and Money
in Every marketing situation must be carefully analyzed in order to determine
the advertising potential of a products to be determined.
Advertising is an important part of the communication strategy in the marketing
mix. It is an external stimulus that arouses latent needs. This means "internal
tension" between buyers, and it is very easy to promote corruption through such
advertising in the entertainment business in a country like India if not
properly verified. If not properly controlled and avoided, counterfeit
advertisements can compromise and mislead our freedom of choice and buy goods.
However, the government should also take steps to raise awareness among ordinary
consumers such as NGOs. Law enforcement agencies should not be apathetic and
insensitive in implementing existing consumer protection legislation. Take
special care to protect children, youth communities, and patients from the evil
resulting from false and misleading advertising.
Consumers are often exposed to unfair business practices by giant marketers and
consumers are victims of their fierce business competition. The outlook for the
consumer justice system in our country appears positive given the provisions in
Indian laws and regulations and the various proactive measures taken by the
government. Consumers need to be aware of their rights which they can use to
protect themselves from such unfair monopoly practices.
The government should take steps to educate people about the various remedies
they can take if their rights as a consumer are violated. From business and
industry, civil society organizations and, above all, the consumer. It is
important to keep the practice of unfair trade under control in the years to
come.
References:
- Ahmad, F. (April- june 1996). False And Misleading Advertisements —
Legal Perspectives. Journal of the Indian Law Institute, Vol. 38( No. 2 ),
168-183. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/43927467
- Dr Swati Sinha, D. P. (n.d.). False and Misleading Advertisements and
protection of the consumers: Indian scenario. International Journal of Law
and Legal Jurisprudence Studies .
N.S., S. (2015). A Study On Unfair Trade Practices In India. Journal On
Contemporary Issues Of Law [JCIL], Volume 4 (ISSUE 7), 75-83.
Nuseir, M. T. (2018). Impact of misleading/false advertisement to. Int. J.
Economics and Business Research, 16(4), 453-465. doi:
10.1504/IJEBR.2018.095343
Puri, K. (July-September 1992). Protection Against Monopolistic And Unfair
Trade Practices In India. Journal of the Indian Law Institute, Vol. 34(No.
- 443-455. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/43951454
Sayed, I. (2014). An Empirical Research on Misleading Advertisements and Its
Impact on Consumer Buying Behaviour . http://www.globalbizresearch.org/,
4-14.
End-Notes:
- Godfrey Philips v Ajay Kumar AIR 2008 SC 1828
- Pooja Roy v. Krishnango Bhattacharya (2008) C.R.R 2796 of 2008 Calcutta
H.C
- Reckitt & Colman of India Ltd. Vs. Kiwi T.T. K. Ltd 1996 PTC (16) 393
- Consumer Guidance Society v. Amway India Enterprises (2007) C.C 140 of
2007
- PepsiCo Inc. and ors. Vs. Hindustan Coca Cola Ltd. and Anr 2003 (27) PTC
305(Delhi)
- Buddhist Mission Dental College and Hospital vs. Bhupesh Khurana and Ors
MANU/SC/0204/2009; (2009)4SCC484
- Dr. Swati Sinha and Dr. Pradip Kumar Das, False and misleading
advertisements and protection of the consumers: Indian scenario.
International Journal of Law and Legal Jurisprudence Studies: ISSN:2348-8212
Please Drop Your Comments