Globalisation, increase in trade, emergence of new ways of transactions and
e-commerce have created new and convenient options for consumers. The growth of
internet has led to a drastic shift in the definition of consumer and has
heralded an era of fast consumer-shipa. This, however, has made consumers
vulnerable to new forms of unfair trade and unethical business practices. Thus,
a need was felt to amend the existing framework for the protection of rights and
interests of consumers. The Consumer Protection Bill 2018 has been passed in the
Lok Sabha on 20 December, 2018 and aims to replace the archaic Consumer
Protection Act 1986 owing to its many pitfalls.
The 2018 Bill will enlarge the ambit of the existing Act to cover and regulate
goods and services, including online market places for consideration in view of
the changing dynamics of consumer protection.
Defining E-commerce and Electronic Service Provider:
Currently, there is no definition of an online marketplace in any of the
existing Indian laws. Though the Information Technology Act, 2000 categorises
these marketplaces as intermediaries, its scope is limited and does not extend
to sale and purchase that occur through their medium. The Consumer Protection
Act, 1986 also does not provide for protection against online marketplaces.
For the very first time, the Bill has defined e-commerce activity as buying or
selling of goods or services including digital products over digital or
electronic network. The Bill also lays down the meaning of an electronic
service provider: A person who provides technologies or processes to enable a
product seller to engage in advertising or selling goods or services to a
consumer and includes any online marketplace or online auction sitesâ.
Inclusion of these new definitions will broaden the scope of the Act to include
the e-commerce sector, which the existing Act does not cover. This way, if the
rights of anâe-consumerâwill be protected and in case of any violation, the
consumer will be able to proceed against the e-commerce website.
Interestingly, the explanation attached to the definition of âconsumer" has been
worded in a way to include consumers who buys goods or avails services through
online platforms and once enacted, will make online retailers and marketplaces
liable for fraudulent sales and defective products sold on their platforms.
The introduction of âproduct liability' provision is one of the most important
features of the Bill, which is not provided for in the current Act. Product
liability, as defined under the Bill, means the responsibility of the
manufacturer or seller of any product or service to compensate for any harm
caused to a consumer by such defective product manufactured or sold or by
deficiency in services relating thereto. As per the new Bill, the product
manufacturer can be held liable even if he proves that he was not negligent or
fraudulent in making the express warranty of a product.
Additionally, the Bill also provides for the liability of a product seller, who
is not a product manufacturer, in circumstances where:
i. The seller exercised substantial control over the
designing, testing, manufacturing, packaging or labelling of a product that
ii. The seller altered or modified the product and such
alteration or modification was a substantial factor in causing the harm.
iii. The seller made an express warranty of a product independent
of any express warranty made by the manufacturer and such product failed to
conform to the express warranty made by the seller which caused the harm.
iv. The product is sold by him and the identity of manufacturer of
the product is not known, or if known, the service of notice or process or
warrant cannot be effected on him or he is not subject to the law which is in
force in India or the order, if any, passed or to be passed cannot be enforced
v. The seller failed to exercise reasonable care in assembling,
inspecting or maintaining such product or he did not pass on the warnings or
instructions of the manufacturer regarding the dangers involved or proper usage
of the product while selling such product and such failure was the proximate
cause of the harm.
This has been done in an endeavour to make the e-commerce companies accountable
in case any defective product or deficient service is made available through
Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements:
The Bill provides for imposing penalty on the product manufacturer or service
provider who causes a false or misleading advertisement to be made, which is
detrimental to the interests of the consumers. The Act does not provide a
definition of misleading advertisement but as per the definition under the Bill,
it will include an advertisement which:
i. Falsely describes a product or service.
ii. Gives false guarantees that mislead consumers about a
product or service.
iii. Convey representations, which if made by the manufacturer,
seller or a service provider would constitute unfair trade practice.
iv. Deliberately conceals important information.
Further, in case of any false or misleading advertisement being released, the
manufacturers or service providers will be punishable with imprisonment up to
two years and/or fine up to Rs.10 Lakhs, or both. The introduction of criminal
liability for misleading advertisements will positively compel the product
manufacturer, product seller or the service provider to release advertisements
with caution and within the contours of the prescribed legal framework. The Bill
also makes the endorser or brand ambassador of such misleading advertisements
liable and provides a penalty of up to Rs.50 Lakhs and ban up to 3 years on a
Thus the product manufacturers, product sellers, the service providers,
e-commerce companies and even the celebrity endorsers will be made answerable
for the false and misleading advertisements of the products being sold or
services being offered/ endorsed by them.
Through this Bill, the Government is trying to establish a watchdog to bust
unfair trade practices, to regulate online marketplaces, to protect the interest
of the consumers and to keep the legislative framework of consumer protection
laws in pace with the changing dynamics of the consumer market and emerging
market trends. If passed, the Bill will aid the rapidly increasing e-consumers
in protecting their consumer rights.
Consumer Justice In India
A Vision of Food
Special and Differential Treatment in WTO
Impact of Securitization Act, 2002 on the Mortgage Transactions
Instances of Disingenuous Advertisements and Consumers
Product Liability: Who is liable?
Consumer Protection Act, An analysis of Branch office
Consumer the King
Judicial Interpretation of Medical Negligence under Consumer Protection
Competition law and Consumerism
Statutory transaction and contract of sale
Packaged by Law
Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, 2009
How brands can save themselves from made in china?
Foreign Direct Investment in Retail - the implications of the new regime
Legal Protection of Consumers
Consumer Protection in the age of E-Commerce
A Comparative Understanding of Dominant Position
Consumer Protection Law In India
Medical Negligence Liability of Hospitals
Advance Pricing Agreement
Unfair Trade Practice in India
The Consumer Protection Law- Birds Eye View
Class Action-How many number of buyers can file suit at NCDRC
Real Estate scam in India