Corporate bodies are more corrupt and profligate than individuals, because they
have more power to do mischief, and are less amenable to disgrace or punishment. They neither feel shame, remorse, gratitude nor goodwill Hazlitt-CeliaWells
The general belief in the earlier centuries was that companies couldn't be held
reprehensibly liable. Legal thinkers didn't believe that companies might possess
the ethical guiltiness necessary to commit crimes of intent. It had been the
common intent of the people that a company has no soul, hence it cannot have
actual wicked intent.
It cannot, therefore, be
guilty of crimes requiring evil intentions'. However it cannot be denied that
company crimes and frauds are at rife since several decades before, as long as
Corporate Entities are alive. These includes criminal activity on behalf of a
business concern, entailing embezzled and deceptive techniques, to get
associated with the unfair advantage to that the offender isn't in the
least entitled. Within the eyes of law, a company is a separate legal entity.
It's established through a method of registration and legislation.
Compared to the people, this situation is such the companies have currently
become way more dangerous criminals than the traditional voters. But, there's no
correct methodology to penalize the crimes of those companies.
The most reason
why the companies are successful to flee the prosecution is barely as a result
of the intention to commit criminal act of the corporation has invariably been
unable to be verified. Moreover, a company cannot be confined and therefore
the last downside is, in each case the court needs physical
presence of the wrongdoer at the time of thehearing.
However, Under Section 11 of the Indian Penal Code 1860, a Company is
additionally enclosed within the definition of the term
person.
Therefore, just in case corporation commits any crime it may be chastened
beneath IPC. But, before that it is important to know about most significant
out of all the thought , that a company cannot be chastened for acts like rape
as a result of the sole penalty for that crime is,imprisonment.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India through its numerous judgments has time and
again tried to resolve the difficulty of Corporate Criminal Liability in India.
Within the landmark case of
Assistant Commissioner vs. Velliappa Textiles
Ltd, (2003) 11 SCC 405the Supreme Court commanded that, just in case
Corporation cannot be confined , they will even be not prosecuted for the
offence that's chastened with imprisonment beneath IPC.
It had been then after the Velliappa case that companies became additional
dreamy, thinking that, being a juristic person they can not be chastened simply
and sent to jail, and, they committed such a big amount of crimes throughout the
course of the utilization. It had been unfair on the part of the judiciary to
permit a company freely with noneliability.
Thereafter, in the case of
Standard Chartered Bank vs. Directorate of
Enforcement, AIR 2005 SC 2622the Hon'ble Supreme Court overruled the
Velliappa case and declared that, a Corporation cannot be let free merely
because it imposes imprisonment for its criminal act.
In case where, it imposes imprisonment, it should be punished with fine.
Thereafter in
Iridium India Ltd. Vs. Motorola Incorporated(2011) 1 SCC
74, it had been expressly held that the corporations are punished under both
common law and statutory law similar to an individual. It is because; a
corporation is controlled and managed by a person.
It acts through a person. Therefore, a court should punish a corporation with
such punishment, which it would have given to a person on commission of such
offence. Even, if corporation cannot be punished for certain acts, the authority
acting on behalf of it ispunished.
It has been time and again reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India that for the relevancy of the ism of Corporate Criminal Liability, the
criminal act of the employer or employee should be committed with the intention
of benefiting the corporation in some manner and be committed with the
intention of accelerating their own personal gain, that consequently
ends up in the advantage of the corporation that it is not otherwise
entitledto.
Conclusion
There are numerous crimes committed by the companies that we have a tendency to
bump into daily through completely different channels of communication, that
severely bring down serious harm upon the economy. Over the years, the approach
to Corporate criminal liability has modified from there being no thought
of liability for crimes committed by company to liability based on the
identification of some persons as the main brain behind the running of the
company.
India endow with for the Corporate Criminal Liability in broad terms. As noted
earlier, the recent ruling of the Supreme Court of India in Standard Chartered
Bank, Corporations in India may be prosecuted for nearly each penal offence that
exists in any Indian statute. The Companies Act conjointly provided for criminal
liability of companies yet as its administrators beneath a number of
variouscircumstances.
Written By:
- Abhay Gupta, Advocate, Kapoor & Co.
Email: [email protected], Tele: +91 9560147929
Please Drop Your Comments