The pandemic COVID-19 has severely affected the industries of every sector and
the aviation sector is one of them. The Indian aviation sector is one of the
fastest-growing industry, according to the IATA-commissioned Value of Aviation
study conducted in 2015, India's air transport sector has supported 8 million
jobs and contributed to $72 billion in GDP. IATA's recent 20-year air passenger
forecast estimated that India will overtake the United Kingdom to become the
third-largest market with 278 million passengers in 2025. By 2035, India is
expected to be a market of 442 million passengers, with the aviation industry
supporting 19.1 million jobs and contributing to $172 billion in the GDP of
India[1].
Since the world has tightened their seat belt to fight against the pandemic
COVID-19 and trying to overcome the turbulent situation then the IATA's Director
General and CEO Alexandre de Juniac recently in its press release stated that
“Major stimulus from governments combined with liquidity injections by central
banks will boost the economic recovery once the pandemic is under control. But
rebuilding passenger confidence will take longer. And even then, individual and
corporate travelers are likely to carefully manage travel spend and stay closer
to home.”[2] It shows how this industry is looking with hope towards its
government.
Challenges and Legal Issues:
Due to virus outbreak and nationwide lockdown the Indian aviation sector is
facing many challenges and crises. As per the instruction of the government, all
scheduled flights are canceled excluding cargo from 24th March 2020 and as per
the direction of Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) and a circular
issued by the Ministry of Civil Aviation[3] all the airline's companies have to
refund airfare during the lockdown period without deducting cancellation charges
and suspended domestic and international flight operations.
Some important challenges and legal issues which may be faced by this
industry are:
- Increase in Consumer Litigation: Due to unprecedented complete
nationwide lockdown all the national and international flights are canceled
and as per the direction of DGCA the companies had to refund the ticket fares of the customers
without deducting any cancellation charges and there might be chances that many
of them will not get the refund in their accounts and they can knock the door of
Consumer Forums. It will increase the proof of burden and litigation cases on
companies.
- A dispute between Aviation Companies and Online Travel
Companies/Agent: Many customers in India and around the world booking their
air tickets through online travel companies and travel agents and the
airline's companies are paying commission to agents that have been charged
indirectly by the passengers on their tickets. Since during the lockdown all
the tickets are canceled then the airline's companies had to return full
fare without any deduction of cancellation charges to customers in result
the airline's companies may be denied to make payment of commission to agent
or travel companies which may create a dispute which results in the travel
companies or agents can take legal action.
- Contractual Disputes & Litigation: As we know, that the aviation
industry also deals with various small businesses and service provider
companies and contractors who help them to provide world-class service to
the passengers and due to unprecedented lockdown there might be the
possibility of contractual disputes and payment disputes between the
companies and contractors. Apart from that due to lockdown the companies
also face the problem of liquidity crunch so there is a possibility that the
company may default to make payment to the debtors and it increases the
litigation for the companies
- Employment Issues: Due to the complete stop of services and to distress
the financial burden the companies are cutting salary up to 60%, some
companies have made part payment to employees and give a leave without pay
and also expelling the employees from a job to sustain the business. Since
the company is expelling the employees on shorter notice then the employees
are opting to file court cases against the companies
- Aircraft lease charges: During this pandemic these lease charges or
rentals put the financial burden on the companies because most of the
airline companies take the aircraft on lease and they have to pay the
charges to the Lessor as per the terms and condition of lease deed.
- Cost of Aviation Turbine Fuel (ATF): Its price increases from time to
time and covered almost 35% to 40% of the operating cost which includes Central
Excise Tax and GST. The Cost of the fuel puts an extra burden on the airline's
service and directly hits there profit margin. In a competitive market airline
companies cannot increase airfare on every increase or decrease of fuel price.
- The parking charges, landing charges, and airport charges: The airline
companies have also paid parking charges, landing charges, airport charges,
and navigation charges as per the direction and tariff plan of Airport
Authority of India or Ministry of Civil Aviation.
- Paying salaries to employees from their reserves and surplus: Due to a
completely nationwide lockdown and stoppage of business operations it became
hard for airline companies to pay off salary and allowances to its
employees. Further, these companies are paying salaries from their reserves
and surplus which is badly affected their financial condition.
- Due to various restrictions and fear the passengers would avoid
traveling which affects the business in broad level: This is one of the
major reason which affects the business badly due to pandemic COVID-19 the
passengers are fear and avoid to travel unnecessarily which directly affects
the airlines business and hotel & tourism industry as well. Before traveling
passengers and airlines companies have to follow various guidelines issued
by the concerned government and authority.
- Companies need to bear some extra costs like sanitization of Planes and
airport terminals: After or during this pandemic this is the essential
guideline to companies by the Government which is mandatory to follow and
also put some extra cost on these companies to sustain business and give a
healthy atmosphere to passengers.
Survival Measures:
In the light of the outbreak of COVID – 19 many companies would be bankrupt and
to avoid such a situation a proposal to promulgate an ordinance to suspend
insolvency proceedings against new defaulters for six months. Once the ordinance
comes into force following Presidential assent then sections 7, 9, and 10 of the
Code which triggers insolvency proceedings against the defaulters will remain
suspended for six months to one year which stops companies from being forced
into insolvency proceedings.
But this step is not sufficient for the aviation industry. As per the
instruction of central government the aviation companies had to refund the fares
of the passengers without deducting the cancellation charges which increases the
financial burden on these companies and to overcome these financial crunches
some companies offered credit for future travel and in my opinion its a good
step taken by the companies. The government should think about it and amend the
guidelines which are helpful for the passengers and aviation companies as well.
Based on the challenges and legal issues as discussed above the companies may
also take the following measures:
- To avoid consumer litigation the companies may share their refund
transaction details with customers through email and SMS from which they
track their refund amount.
- To avoid contractual disputes and litigation cases the companies may
arrange meetings with parties to discuss the disputes and settle the matter
out of court to avoid litigation burden. Further to avoid such conditions
the companies with mutual consent can take some time to make payment to
debtors as per convenience and requirement to avoid any dispute and make the
business smooth.
- To avoid any labor law cases, the companies may cut the payment up to
30% of wages and salary without expelling the employees of the company to
overcome from financial burden. Companies can also opt for the other option
regarding the payment to labor which is acceptable by both parties.
Further, the FICCI Aviation Committee has recommended the central government for
a bailout package for the domestic aviation industry, including direct cash
support from the government, interest-free soft loans, and a two years tax
holiday to help the sector overcome the pandemic. FICCI Aviation Committee
Chairman and President and Managing Director of Airbus India and South Asia,
Anand Stanley said in its recommendation to Civil Aviation Secretary that:
Many airline companies are on the brink of bankruptcy.[4]
The central government can also reduce the taxes on ATF and other excise duties
for a certain period. The government should be liberal for other charges paid by
aviation companies. The aviation companies can also opt to sell their stake to
overcome the financial crisis. Moreover, the Hon'ble Prime Minister of India
introduced the economic package of Rupees Twenty Lakh Crore economic package to
boost the economy under the scheme of the “
Aatmanirbhar Bharat” and
Aviation industry is also looking for its revival.
Conclusion:
As of now, the Ministry of Finance has announced some structural reforms in the
tranch of economic stimulus package for aviation sector like restrictions on
utilization of Indian Air space, Six airports will be auctioned to private
companies and the Tax regime for aircraft maintenance, repair, and overhaul. In
my opinion the government should consider the recommendation of FICCI for the
bailout package and other possible ways to establish this industry to avoid the
measure problem like unemployment and economically backward.
End-Notes:
-
https://www.iata.org/contentassets/5d4c3f78802248378497cc561ca019b0/intervistas-report-aspac-dec2015.pdf
- https://www.iata.org/en/pressroom/pr/2020-05-13-03/
- https://dgca.gov.in/digigov-portal/Upload?flag=iframeAttachView&attachId=130619295
- http://ficci.in/ficci-MediaCoverage.asp#
Please Drop Your Comments