Marital rape, which refers to a spouse's coercion for sexual intercourse
regardless of consent, appears to violate the principles of a marriage
relationship hence it poses a great risk. Traditionally marital unions have
often been viewed as an arrangement that to a great extent provides for the
spouses' unending sexual activities. However, this view has undergone scrutiny
as society has accepted that consent for sex should be given willingly, always
and freely even within marriage. Hence, the issue of violence against women is
neither only a crime nor only a public health matter but resides at the boundary
of violence against women and violation of human rights[1].
Some countries have made great progress in accepting and recognizing this
conduct as a criminal offense. On the other hand, many others like India still
harbour sunk legal provisions which endorse impunity against marital rape and
therefore extension of gender discrimination. This article contains the legal
provisions on marital rape in various countries, its implications on women, its
classification as a violation of human rights, and discussions on its
prosecution which is ongoing globally.
Legal Framework
The status of the marital rape laws is with enormous discrepancies among
countries due to the differences in cultural, social and legal spheres.
India
Late in India, the issue concerning the criminalization of marital rape has
generated a lot of debate. The definition of rape under Section 375 of the
Indian Penal Code (IPC) states, is the act of sexual violence where a woman does
not give her consent. However, there is one condition that is important to
highlight here – if a man happens to have a sexual intercourse with the woman
above the age of eighteen who is his wife one cannot sue for rape against him.
This exemption has its basis in archaic legal principles which viewed marriage
as a transaction so that once a wife accepts her husband it implies that she
concedes all sexual relations and this is operative for life.
On the other hand, the Indian judicial system has improved slowly but steadily.
The Supreme Court of India in Independent Thought v. Union of India (2017) held
that sexual intercourse with a wife who is 18 years or lesser than that age is
an offense of rape. This case featured a historically significant judgment for
the protection of the sexual rights of child brides, but sadly did not offer any
solution to the problem of marital rape to adult women. The continued existence
of this exception remains one of the most irritating Achilles' heels in any
legislation in India concerning Women's Rights[2].
Certain legal experts and activists in India still advocate for the removal of
the exception concerning marital rape. They argue that such a law regards
married women as inferior and perpetuates wrong cultural practices that deny a
woman control over her own body in a marriage relationship[3]. However, despite
the increasing public debate on the issue, attempts to pass a bill making it
illegal to rape one's spouse have met the opposition of several political,
religious and sociocultural groups who regard such reforms as a threat to the
family institution.
Global Context
While marital rape remains a work in progress in India, there are Western
countries that have gone overboard in this legal area. Countries that make up
the United States of America, and or United Kingdom, Canada, and most of the
European countries treat marital rape just as any other form of rape, and so, it
has been fully criminalized in all those countries. Such laws have been derived
by principles of self-determination, and gender equity, which argues that
marriage ought not to erase one's independence to say no.
In the UK it was in 1991 that the first law was passed to prohibit marital rape,
following the case of R v R,[4] where it was decided that a husband may be
charged with rape of his wife, contrary to the established belief over several
ages; that husbands couldn't face charges of raping their wives under common
law. Likewise, in the USA, marital rape laws started being in place late in the
20th century but one state didn't follow suit until 1993 when the last repeal
came in.
Global norms, such as the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of
Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), have been significant in the attempts to
recognize and define marital rape as a crime in various states. Vivas S. The
CEDAW Committee regularly encourages the state parties to these Conventions to
repeal all provisions that permit examples of marital rape to go unpunished and
to ensure that legal provisions are made equally available to all and not just
married women[5]. However, there are still countries in which the act of marital
rape is either partially criminalized, or not regarded as criminal offense at
all.
In particular, some society in the Middle East, places of Africa or
countries in the Southeast Asia, buy the idea that there is no such thing as
martial rape because the cultural and religious norm is that family honour and
responsibilities of marriage come before the rights of a person. In such cases,
change through legislative efforts is painstakingly gradually and normally needs
others changes in the society in addition to the legal changes.
Social Implications
The impact created by marital rape cannot be felt solely on the individual
victim because it has general societal effects on attitudes about women,
marriage, and violence. There are cultures, especially in many of the
patriarchal societies, where a woman is considered to 'owe' her husband sex and
that makes a culture of marital rape acceptable. This patriarchal outlook is at
times supported by some aspects of culture or religion that emphasize the
sanctity of marriage and the subordination of women.
For that reason, reporting of spousal sexual rape seems to be extremely low in
societies in which women are taught to take whatever their husbands dish out as
part of their duties as wives. Disclosing that a person has been sexually
assaulted by their partner is undoubtedly stigmatizing, and particularly[6], is
associated with the dread of socially induced shame, which suffocates a number
of victims. There are societies where divorced women are looked down upon, hence
the fear of losing financial, and/or child custody further prevents women from
speaking out or legal action.
What's more, a large proportion of the women do not even consider themselves
victims of marital rape since they have internalized the norm that once married,
there is no need for the husband's consent. This barely existent awareness
combined with the absence of legal recourse for spouses helps cover up the issue
of spousal rape, resulting in untreated violence against women for many.
Human Rights Perspective
One act of rape is not solely a criminal act rather it is a disregard for the
most basic of all human rights. It is a violation of the rights to bodily
integrity, dignity, and liberty of persons to which all international
instruments on human rights afford protection. The world body through its
various agencies and documents such as CEDAW and the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights has classified sexual violence including marital rape as one of the
forms of violence against women which counties undertook to eliminate and make
punishment for offenders.
Scholar and activists like those of the World Health Organization(WHO) and
Amnesty international have also stigmatized marital rape as a public health
issue due to its traumatic effects to the suffers. Trauma may be the most severe
experienced by the victims of marital rape even when such physical violence is
absent. Their physical ill health may include unwanted pregnancy[7], STI and
even injuries caused by violent sexual practice.
According to human rights
advocates, there are countries that commit violations of women's rights since
they do not criminalize marital rape. These activists work for reforms in
legislation, raise awareness at the societal level, and help construct systems
of support for the victims.
Arguments for Criminalization
Elements of criminalizing marital rape offer several key arguments:
- Human Rights Protection: There is a right to agree to engage in sexual activity and this right should be protected. The crime of rape within marriage ensures that an individual retains rights to their body even within the context of marriage.
- Psychological and Physical Well-being: Rape within marriage has been criminalized since the wife is considered property and violence too much destruction would take place in the relationship. It allows the victims to fight back and gain some more respect and understanding within the society regarding the abuse's effects on the mental and physical well-being of the people in the long run.
- Legal Equality: Submission of General and Special Defense for Operate Command (ODS) - Marital rape amendments invite an unequal treatment of women and create a social slightly different for married women from unmarried women. Where there is criminalization, it means that all persons whether married or single are equal before the law.
Arguments Against Criminalization
- Preservation of Family Structure: Some people do oppose the imposition stating that making marital rapes illegal would lead to a rise in the rate of divorces or other family breakdowns. To them, the issue of marriage is personal, and should not be subject to the justice system.
- Proof Challenges: In close relationships, it may be difficult to demonstrate lack of consent which could result in wrongful convictions or unjust persecution. Some argue that the law may not necessarily be the most appropriate means of dealing with issues concerning marriage.
Case Studies and Data
Criminalization of marital rape in numerous nations points towards an increasing
trend in reporting and prosecuting the crime. For instance, in the case of the
United States, studies have indicated that since the criminalization of marital
rape, more women have been able to come forward with the crime, on the other
hand underreporting is still an issue. However, there have also been legislative
changes that have improved the networks available to the victims, for example,
agencies providing therapy and legal aid services.
Recent Developments
We could, however, illustrate reasons why domestic activism against marital rape
should be welcomed postponement in such nations as India where feminist
movements and legal scholars are still pressing for change. Campaigns aimed to
educate have been helpful in changing the attitudes of the population, albeit
the changes in law have taken a slow pace.
Conclusion
Marital rape is a fundamental issue within the intersection of law, society and
human rights. Most countries now report some progress as regards the legal
frameworks towards the prohibition of this form of violence; however,
some-India, for instance – still need to grapple with legal systems that defend
the institution of marriage and its rape. The development of legal and public
attitudes that treat external violence against a spouse as an offense will take
time to achieve. However, efforts should be made to ensure that all individuals
irrespective of their marital status are free from unwanted sexual advances.
Elimination of marital rape and full respect of women's rights can only be
achieved by changing the law, supporting the society, and shifting social
perceptions.
End Notes:
- Randall, M., & Venkatesh, V. (2015). The right to no: The crime of marital rape, women's human rights, and international law. Brook. J. Int'l L., 41, 153.
- Patel, K. (2018). The gap in Marital Rape Law in India: Advocating for criminalization and social change. Fordham Int'l LJ, 42, 1519.
- Ryan, R. M. (1995). The sex right: A legal history of the marital rape exemption. Law & Social Inquiry, 20(4), 941-1001.
- Yllö, K., & Torres, M. (2016). Understanding Marital Rape in Global Context. Marital Rape: Consent, Marriage, and Social Change in Global Context Oxford, 1-8.
- Turkey, F. A., Indonesia, S. A., de Escoto Honduras, M. M. F., France, F. G., & Cuba, M. Y. F. G. (2000). Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women.
- de Ávila, T. P. (2018). Facing domestic violence against women in Brazil: advances and challenges. International journal for crime, justice and social democracy, 7(1), 15-29.
- Woldu, T. H. (2017). Human rights of women and the phenomenon of marital rape in Ethiopia: a critical analysis (Doctoral dissertation, Global Campus).
Please Drop Your Comments