India's accession to the Madrid Protocol on July 8, 2013, marked a significant
milestone in its intellectual property landscape. This article delves into the
profound impact this accession has had on trademark registration and protection
in India. The Madrid Protocol, administered by the World Intellectual Property
Organization (WIPO), facilitates the international registration of trademarks by
providing a streamlined, cost-effective process for registering trademarks in
multiple countries through a single application. This paper explores the
historical context, the procedural changes brought by the Protocol, the benefits
and challenges faced by Indian businesses, and the broader implications for
international trade and brand protection.
Introduction
India made a calculated decision to become a member of the Madrid Protocol in
order to further integrate its economy with the world economy. Due to this
integration, Indian companies now have easier access to international trademark
protection, which has increased the country's appeal to foreign investors. The
Protocol has streamlined the difficult process of registering trademarks across
several jurisdictions by providing a centralized, effective method. The
influence of India's Madrid Protocol membership on trademark registration and
protection is examined in this article along with its effects on legal
frameworks, commercial perspectives, procedural efficiencies, and cost
implications.
The Madrid Protocol: An Overview
History and Evolution
The Madrid Protocol, established in 1989, is part of the Madrid System for the
international registration of trademarks, which also includes the Madrid
Agreement of 1891. The Protocol was designed to address the shortcomings of the
Agreement and to make the system more accessible and flexible for modern
business needs.
Mechanism and Benefits
The Madrid Protocol allows trademark owners to file a single application and pay
one set of fees to protect their marks in multiple member countries. This
simplified process offers several advantages:
- Cost Efficiency: Reduces the need for multiple applications and payments.
- Simplified Management: Allows for centralized management of trademark portfolios.
- Legal Certainty: Provides consistent protection standards across member countries.
- India's Accession to the Madrid Protocol
Historical Context
Prior to 2013, Indian businesses seeking international trademark protection
faced complex and costly procedures, requiring them to file separate
applications in each target country. India's accession to the Madrid Protocol
was driven by the need to streamline these processes and to align with global
intellectual property standards.
Legislative and Regulatory Changes
To comply with the Madrid Protocol, India amended its Trade Marks Act, 1999. The
Trade Marks (Amendment) Act, 2010, and subsequent rules introduced the necessary
legal framework to implement the Protocol's provisions.
Simplified procedure for registering as a foreigner
One of the primary advantages of India's participation to the Madrid Protocol is
the expedited international registration process it provides to Indian trademark
owners. The administrative effort and expense were increased because each
country where trademark protection was previously sought after required a new
application. However, under the Madrid Protocol, Indian applicants are allowed
to file one international application through the Indian Intellectual Property
Office (IPO), and that application is then sent to the World Intellectual
Property Organization (WIPO).1. The application is subsequently forwarded by the
WIPO to the trademark authorities of the corresponding member nations for
examination and registration. This expedites the process, eliminates work that
would otherwise need to be done twice, and minimizes paperwork for Indian
trademark owners.
Cost and time efficiency
Indian trademark owners can save a lot of money and time by utilising the Madrid
System. The conventional method required applicants to hire local solicitors in
each prospective nation, which resulted in high legal costs.2 With the Madrid
Protocol, however, there is no longer a requirement for hiring local solicitors
for initial filings because the application is processed through the IPO and
sent to the relevant national trademark authorities. With fewer files, there
will be a significant decrease in the administrative and legal expenditures. The
Madrid Protocol also makes it easier for trademark owners to manage their
international trademark portfolio with just one application by streamlining
subsequent trademark management procedures including renewals and modifications.
Greater Geographic Reach
Indian brand name owners now have a wider geographical inclusion thanks to their
country's ratification of the Madrid Convention. Currently, Indian businesses
have access to trademark protection in all 124 Madrid System members, including
important markets like the US, China, Japan, and Australia. Thanks to this
expansion, Indian brands may now reach new audiences and safeguard their
intellectual property in significant overseas markets, which promotes brand
extension and worldwide commercial opportunities3. Additionally, it facilitates
the entry of Indian enterprises into numerous markets with a single application,
thereby enabling them to compete on a global scale.
Centralized Trademark Administration
The Madrid System offers a consolidated method for overseeing global trademarks.
Once a global enrollment is approved, further updates, recharges, and
recordkeeping can be efficiently managed with just one application. This
streamlines the administrative tasks associated with brand owners' executives,
giving Indian brand owners greater notable control and ease of managing their
international brand portfolios.4 For trademark owners, the centralized
management system facilitates the coordination of actions across several
jurisdictions, resulting in faster and easier modifications or renewal
processes.
Benefits For Indian Business
Enhanced Global Reach
Indian businesses can now expand their reach more efficiently and
cost-effectively. This section discusses how the Madrid Protocol has facilitated
easier access to international markets for Indian brands.
Improved Legal Protection
With international registration, trademarks receive stronger legal protection in
member countries. This part examines the legal benefits and protections afforded
to Indian trademarks under the Madrid Protocol.
Competitive Advantage
The streamlined process and broader protection offer Indian businesses a
competitive edge. This subsection highlights case studies and examples of Indian
companies that have benefited from the Madrid Protocol.
Improved methods of enforcement
India's entry into the Madrid Protocol improves trademark enforcement for Indian
companies. The agreement gives Indian brand owners access to the global security
tools provided by the Madrid Framework.Six In the case of trademark
infringement, Indian brand owners can use the centralized system to start legal
action against infringers in member nations, expediting the legal procedure and
boosting enforcement efficiency. This provides more credible and notable
evidence as well as another effective way to protect brand names worldwide.
Domestic ramifications and difficulties
The acceptance of the Madrid Convention by India has resulted in certain
domestic consequences and challenges. First, because trademark registration is
now easier to get, the Indian Intellectual Property Office (IPO) might have a
backlog of applications, which might cause the assessment process to drag on.
The IPO needs to upgrade its infrastructure and resources in this case in order
to handle the growing demand. Ensuring the effectiveness and productivity of the
assessment interaction is essential to meet the demands of brand name
enlistments.
Benefits for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs)
India's promotion to the Madrid Convention holds specific importance for little
and medium-sized endeavors (SMEs) working in India. SMEs frequently face
difficulties in tying down and safeguarding their brand names all around the
world because of restricted assets and information. Small and medium-sized
businesses (SMEs) can easily and economically expand their trademark protection
outside of India by using the Madrid System8. It furnishes them with a chance to
lay out and deal with a global brand name portfolio, improving their market
reach and seriousness. By improving on the cycle and lessening costs, the Madrid
Convention enables SMEs to safeguard their protected innovation privileges all
the more successfully and take part in worldwide exchange.
India's promotion to the Madrid Convention has achieved huge changes in brand
name enlistment and assurance in the country. The overall impact of India's
decision is influenced by the streamlined international registration process,
cost and time savings, expanded geographical coverage, centralized trademark
management, examination of trademark applications, enhanced enforcement
mechanisms, domestic implications, and benefits for SMEs and FDI.
India has made
it easier and less expensive for its businesses to secure international
trademark protection by aligning its trademark system with international
standards. Indian brands can compete on a larger scale and protect their
intellectual property rights in important global markets thanks to the Madrid
Protocol's increased global engagement.
Notwithstanding, tending to homegrown
ramifications and difficulties, for example, dealing with the expanded
responsibility and blending brand name rehearses, stays pivotal for India's
successful execution of the Madrid Convention. In general, India's participation
in this international treaty has been beneficial for trademark registration and
protection, fostering international business opportunities, and promoting
intellectual property harmonization.
Challenges Faced Before Accession:
- Till 2007 semi-automated system was being used.
- By 2010 fully-automated system was adopted.
- Amendment for trademarks act 1999 was passed in the year 2010.
- Till 2010, there were only 42 classes of goods and services and in 2011, classes of goods and services was increased to 45.
- In 2012, new trademarks rule was implemented.
- Till 2012, pendency for examination was 30 months.
- Before July 2013, pendency for examination was reduced to 15 months.
- Various awareness seminars were conducted in the major cities of India which includes Mumbai, Chennai, Ahmedabad, Delhi, and Kolkata.
- Group of six members was formed to study the implementation process and they formed two groups: (i) Legal (ii) IT.
- WIPO officials provided various trainings in India.
- Indian officials visited Geneva and Australia for training purposes.
- India has adopted an 18-month time period for examination.
- Filing and communication of International Applications is processed electronically and no offline communication.
- Modified website of Intellectual Property office implemented and the website address is www.ipindia.nic.in, which is functioning on a real-time basis.
Filing for a trademark under Madrid protocol
It has become very convenient to file an international registration application
for a trademark under Madrid Protocol. To submit such an international
application through Madrid Protocol one needs to first file a basic application
with one’s home country’s trademark office. This is a prerequisite for filing
such an application. In the case of India, one needs to apply with the Indian
Trademark Registry for the registration of the mark in India which is known as
dependency of the mark.
The international trademark registration will depend on
this Indian application for the duration of 5 years. During this period, if
there is any modification, cancellation, or withdrawal of the application in
India then it will immediately reflect on the international application.
In the
case of India, to file an application under the Madrid Protocol through India, a
person should be a citizen of India or should be domiciled in India or should
have a real and effective business in India. It should be presented on the
official form. Such an application has to be submitted to the WIPO only in
electronic form. It should mandatorily specify the name and the address of the
applicant and it should also contain a small representation of the mark. Once
the filing of basic application is done the person is free to begin the process
of the international registration.
The international application will be
presented to the WIPO by the office of origin, i.e. in this case the Indian
Trademark Registry. WIPO will then review and will carry out a formality check
and if there are no issues then the mark is registered and published in the WIPO
Gazette. Later on, the application is forwarded to the Designated Contracting
Parties i.e. to the trademark offices of the countries as specified by the
individual on the application.
The Madrid Protocol just simplifies the application process; it has nothing to
do with approvals. It will not grant the application in every country for which
one has applied. It is granted by those specific countries itself. Each such
individual trademark office of the country for which one has indicated in the
application will examine such application and make a decision based on their
specific trademark legislation. If during this process any opposition or
objection is made then the provisional refusal is communicated to the WIPO who
then communicates it to the office of origin, which in this case is the Indian
Trademark Registry.
Eventually, the trademark registry will communicate the same
to the applicant, who gets a month to respond to the same. In case there is no
such objection or the objections have been waived off then the Designated
Contracting Party will grant protection to the trademark as a mark registered
with their office. Eventually, each trademark office should notify the applicant
within 12-18 months regarding such approval or rejection. Once the application
is approved, then one needs to renew such trademark registration after every 10
years.
Advantages of the Madrid system to the trademark office
Madrid protocol has simplified the international registration process and it has
become easier for the applicants to hunt international protection for them in a
cost and time-effective way. International registration is of the advantage of
the trademark offices also. Due to this system, the offices do not need to
examine formal requirements, or to classify the goods or services, or publish
the marks, etc. such formalities will be already performed by the International
Bureau. Following are other advantages of the Madrid protocol:
- Cost-effective: Earlier the applicant had to file country-by-country registration which was time-consuming and costly since both governmental and legal expenses for filing such international applications on an individual level were expensive. However, the standardized form requirement and fee structure of the Madrid Protocol has helped to curb down international registration fees by 60%. This system saves time and money by filing one application, rather than a bundle of national applications.
- Convenient: This system has made the international registration process simple and convenient for the applicants. One can easily file just a single application in one language and needs to pay one set of fees to apply for trademark protection in several nations.
- Centralization: Madrid Protocol is a centralized process. A person can get protection for his trademark throughout the world by filing a single application. This application allows a trademark owner to target the countries in which one seeks protection for one’s trademark.
- Prevents the multiplicity of applications: The chaotic situation which existed due to the filing of multiple applications is avoided due to the Madrid Protocol. It has simplified the filing process for an international trademark.
- Changes can be made easily: If any change in the details of the proprietor of the trademark is required to be made (e.g., name, address, etc.) then it can be changed by sending one single document to the International Bureau and no efforts have to be made at every national office.
Negative Impact Of The Madrid System In India
Restrictive registration:
The biggest disadvantage is that international registration can only be done in
the member countries to the Madrid Protocol. There are over 130 countries who
are a party to the Madrid Protocol, the remaining countries have their own
system of international registration of trademark. Though a single application
for international registration of trademark can be filed to get protection of
trademark rights in multiple countries, it is restricted to the 130 countries
who function under the Madrid system. It means that if any Indian trademark
owners wants to gain trademark protection rights in a country who is not a
member of the Madrid system, he shall have to follow the procedure of that
country to get his trademark registered therewith.
Lack of Manpower in India:
Prior to the Madrid system India’s manpower entertained national filings and
international filings differently. But now, there is a lack of manpower as both
the national and international filings are done simultaneously. It has become
difficult for them to look into both filings at the same time and there is need
for more manpower to carry on the work with efficiency.
Time restrictions on applications:
The Madrid system put a time restraint on the process of trademark registration.
According to the Madrid protocol, the international application has to be
processed and obtained with a time period of 18 months, which could at the
maximum be extended to 24 months. As the Madrid system has made it easier for
the member countries to get their trademark registered in multiple countries,
many trademark owners get their trademark registered in most member countries
including India. Now what happens is due to the time restriction on
international registration, India focus on the international registrations first
leading to a delay in the process of its national filings. We can say that
priority is given to the international filings than to the national filings,
leading to a delay in the national filings.
Basic application dependency:
The international application is completely dependent on the basic application
and registration, due to which, if an applicant makes a change in the basic
application or registration, there shall be an automatic change in the
international application or registration as well. Changes like cancellation of
a trademark entry, striking out some goods or services from those in respect to
which a trademark was initially registered. So, if an Indian basic mark is
cancelled then the international mark will be cancelled too. However, it is
important to note that the international registration becomes independent.
Business interest in non-member countries:
Under the rules of the Madrid Protocol, assigning the ownership of an
international registration to entities residing or having a connection with
non-Madrid Protocol countries is prohibited. The Madrid Protocol governs the
international registration of trademarks among its member countries, and the
rights and benefits provided by the Protocol are limited to only those countries
and not the non-member countries. This is a disadvantage or major drawback for
India because it has business interest in several other countries who aren’t the
members of the Madrid Protocol. Due to this drawback India has to file a
separate national applications to do business with these countries.
Conclusion
After carefully examining how the Madrid Protocol affects Indian trademark
registration and protection, I've concluded that it offers all Indian trademark
owners an enticing route forward. They may register their trademark
internationally in the majority of countries with only one application, thanks
to the user-friendly process that offers them the opportunity to establish a
rapid worldwide brand presence. Nonetheless, Indian trademark owners are not
guaranteed worldwide trademark protection by the Madrid Protocol.
Only the participating nations allow an Indian trademark owner to register their
trademark instantly; other countries are not included. However, we should
acknowledge that the nations who are signatories to the Madrid Protocol account
for over 80% of global trade, which makes them an extremely alluring market for
Indian exporters.[vii] There has been an increase in the quantity of
applications for international trademark registration in India following the
implementation of the Madrid Protocol.
India has undoubtedly profited from this arrangement, as Indian trademark owners
can gain international recognition without incurring significant expenses. In
general, I believe that the effects have been more favorable. Even though this
system has several disadvantages for India, there has been a noticeable
improvement over the previous one. The system has increased foreign investment
in India and the recognition of Indian brands on a worldwide scale. For the most
part, the system provides Indian trademark owners with excellent service.
Please Drop Your Comments