Introduction To Section 233
Section 233 of the Companies Act, 2013[1] provides for a procedure known as
Fast-Track Merger. It is an alternative method to the normal proceedings as
mentioned under Sections 230 to 232 of the same Act which allows restructuring
of companies in a swifter manner.
This provision allows only certain companies
to follow the proceedings as laid down, which include small companies, start-up
companies, etc. Section 233 allows companies to merge or acquire another entity
within a specific period. It enables a cost-effective solution for companies to
merger with one another, within a specified timeline of 60 days. This provision
gives the Central Government the power to decide whether a combination or
arrangement is of public interest or in the interest of the creditors of the
companies in question.
If the Central Government is of the opinion that such an
arrangement does not fulfil the criteria of Section 233, then it may file for
its arrangement under sections 230 to 232. The procedure laid down in Section
233 essentially binds all the parties to specific deadlines to disable any sort
of delay to the process. This procedure also reduces the strain of the Company
Law Tribunals that have the strenuous job of deciding numerous cases that aren't
bound to any timelines.
History And Surrounding Circumstances Of The Law
This section was not present in the Companies Act, 1956, it is a new addition in
the 2013 Act. The provisions of the 1956 Act made it such that the entire
proceedings of mergers and acquisitions were lengthy and very costly. With
changing times, the Parliament sought the need to include a provision that would
not only be time affective and cost effective, but it would consequentially also
take away the burden from the tribunals to intervene.
Fast-track mergers are a relatively new concept in India; however the concept is
well established in China and Brazil. With the increase in businesses and
economic growth in India, it was necessary for the Ministry of Corporate Affairs
(MCA) to introduce this provision. The objective behind this was to promote the
ease of doing business and to ensure that corporate entities have a chance to
reorganise their assets in such a way that there was no space for loss
generation or for liquidation of companies. India has been on the path of
enhancing its economy and such a provision only made the transition smoother.
Ministry Of Corporate Affairs Vide Notification
The Ministry of Corporate Affairs made certain amendments to the Fast-Track
merger provisions in Rule 25[2] of the Companies (Compromise, Arrangements and
Amalgamation) Rules, 2016 in relation to Section 233 of the Companies Act, 2013.
The Amendment reduced the timeline within which the Central Government must
confirm the scheme of amalgamation. Before such an Amendment, there was a
specified timeline for the process of the merger however, the 30 day period
binds parties like the Government, Liquidator and Registrar of Companies.
The
Amendment vide the Notification[3] also brought the concept of deemed approval
wherein, if the Liquidator or Registrar of Companies fail to provide objections
to the scheme in a timely manner as specified, it shall be deemed to be approved
by the Central Government. Such an Amendment by the Ministry of Corporate
Affairs was done on May 2023 and was to be effective from June 2023, to
facilitate the true objective of Section 233.
Company Law Committee Report
To enhance the effectiveness of the Fast-track merger approval process outlined
in Section 233 and concurrently safeguard the interests of minority
shareholders, the Company Law Committee proposed a revised twin test. This
involves obtaining approval from (i) a majority of individuals present and
voting at the meeting, constituting seventy-five per cent in value of the shares
represented by those present and voting; and (ii) an endorsement from entities
representing more than fifty per cent in value of the overall shares of the
company.
Additionally, the Committee recommended amending Section 233 of the
Companies Act, 2013 to allow fast-track mergers between a holding company and
its subsidiary company or companies (excluding wholly-owned subsidiaries) under
specified conditions, particularly if such companies are unlisted.
The Company Law Committee suggested amending Section 233(12) to provide leeway
for the Central Government to specify the procedure for invoking Section 233 in
relation to the specified class or classes of companies mentioned in sub-section
(1), particularly concerning compromises or arrangements under Section 230(1)
and Section 232(1)(b). This amendment would grant the Central Government the
authority to establish rules for this specific purpose.[4]
J.J. Irani Committee Report
The J.J. Irani Committee Report of 2005 emphasised on the importance mergers as
a tool for growth and business strategy. However, it also stated that one of the
biggest drawback of this procedure is that it is lengthy, court driven, consists
of too many delays and thus long drawn. Recommendations put forward by the
committee in this regard were to include proceedings that were shorter and would
promote the ease of doing business. With this, Section 233 of the Act and Rule
25 of the Rules 2016 were added.
Even though the report did not directly recommend the incorporation of
fast-track mergers as a provision, it was evident to the law makers that such a
change was required as per the report. India being such a booming country in
areas of business, it was apparent that the courts or tribunals would be
overburdened by the number of cases admitted. Thus, the addition of a faster and
more cost-efficient method was beneficial for everyone. [5]
Conclusion
In a world where companies require fresh strategies to keep up with the
ever-changing corporate setting, Fast-track mergers makes way for combinations
in a strategic yet time-saving manner. It is very important for such vital
procedures to be regulated to ensure that smaller businesses and start-ups have
an option to merge through a method that is not cumbersome and lengthy.
End-Notes:
- Companies Act, 2013, § 233.
- Companies (Compromise, Arrangements and Amalgamation) Rules, 2016, Rule 25.
- Notification No: – G.S.R 367(E), MCA header - ministry of corporate affairs. Available at: https://www.mca.gov.in/content/mca/global/en/home.html (Accessed: 21 January 2024).
- Report of the Company Law Committee - Ministry of Corporate Affairs. Available at: https://www.mca.gov.in/bin/dms/getdocument?mds=bwsK%252FBEAFTVdpdKuv5IR5w%253D%253D&type=open (Accessed: 21 January 2024).
- Report of Expert Committee on Company Law. Available at: https://ibbi.gov.in/uploads/resources/May%202005,%20J.%20J.%20Irani%20Report%20of%20the%20Expert%20Committee%20on%20Company%20Law.pdf (Accessed: 21 January 2024).
Please Drop Your Comments