Surrogacy is the process in which a woman carries and delivers a child for a
couple or individual. It became very popular among parents in India as well as
across the nation also because in India, cost of surrogacy is relatively low as
compared to other nations. This research article discusses about surrogacy, its
introduction, about its legal provision in India with landmark judgements. This
article also discusses about the legal issues related to surrogacy in India. It
aims to provide a clear knowledge about the concept of surrogacy and to enhance
the knowledge of the readers.
Introduction
Surrogacy is a word which is derived from the Latin word 'Surrogatus' which
means 'Substitute' or someone appointed to act in the place of another.
India was very popular for surrogacy among other countries before commercial
surrogacy was banned in India.
The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act,2021 prohibits the commercial surrogacy. It only
allows the altruistic surrogacy in which a surrogate mother does not receive any
monetary compensation except necessary medical and legal expenses.
'When money is exchanged for pregnancy, some believe, surrogacy comes close to
organ-selling, or even baby-selling....'- Thomas Frank
Legal Provisions and landmark cases
In India, surrogacy is regulated by Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021. This act
prohibits the commercial surrogacy in India and allows only altruistic
surrogacy.
There are various landmark judgements related to the surrogacy in India.
Here are the cases:
Baby Manji Yamada V Union of India (2008):
It was resolved by the Indian Supreme Court in 2008, making it the first
surrogate verdict. It was developed under the assumption that surrogacy
contracts were lawful and only discussed the legality of such arrangements.
Jan Balaz V Anand Municipality (2009):
This is a landmark case in Indian surrogacy law. It dealt with the issue of
nationality of children born through surrogacy to an Indian surrogate mother and
a father having German citizenship. Since surrogacy was not recognised in
Germany, newly- born children could not receive German citizenship.
Legal issues related to surrogacy in India
In India, Surrogacy involves various legal issues, according to the Surrogacy
(Regulation) Act, 2021 which set various strict regulations.
The legal issues include:
- Ban on commercial surrogacy:
This Regulation Act prohibits commercial surrogacy in India and aims to prevent exploitation, but it has led to concerns that it will increase the risk of illegal and unregulated surrogacy arrangements.
- Altruistic Surrogacy only:
This law allows only altruistic surrogacy, where a surrogate mother does not receive any compensation beyond medical expenses and insurance.
- Single-Time Surrogacy:
Surrogate mothers can only undertake surrogacy once in their lifetime. This limitation may reduce the availability of surrogate mothers.
- Eligibility Restrictions:
Only Indian heterosexual married couples who have been married for at least five years can opt for surrogacy. This excludes single individuals, same-sex couples, and foreigners.
- Ethical and moral concerns:
Various ethical debates continue around the morality of surrogacy and the welfare of the child born through surrogacy.
Conclusion
Surrogacy in India has undergone significant changes with introduction of
Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, which prohibits the commercial surrogacy and
it allows on altruistic surrogacy.
Altruistic Surrogacy involves no compensation to the surrogate mother other than
the medical and insurance expenses related to the pregnancy.
The eligibility criteria restrict surrogacy to Indian heterosexual married
couples. It excludes single individual, same-sex couples and foreigners.
Various cases have highlighted the complexities associated with surrogacy. It
illustrates the diverse legal, ethical and emotional complexities involved in
this practice.
Please Drop Your Comments