Patent In Pharmaceutical Industry
A patent acts as a limited barrier for new ideas and inventions. Patent is a
legal right that is given to the inventor by the government for a specific
period of time. No one can copy, use, sell or make the product without the
permission of the inventor. Patents are essential for protecting the
intellectual property and encouraging innovation.
Patents are important as they protect the new innovative ideas or the inventor.
It gives the inventor the sole authority to control, manage and benefit from
their innovation for a certain period of time. Patents protection guarantees the
creation that inventors can gain profit from their innovative work and
investment in their research and development. Patent also encourages competition
and grow many kinds of industries by rewarding for their creation.
Patent plays a very important role in the pharmaceutical industries. It protects
the new drugs, medicines and treatments in which a lot of time and money is
invested by the company. If a pharmaceutical industry gets the patent for a drug
then it means that they have the sole right for using or sale of that medicine
for a certain period of time. This division helps companies recoup their
research and development costs. It's also encouraging because companies know
they can benefit from their discoveries. Without patents, companies cannot
invest in the development of new drugs because they do not have the necessary
protection to be effective. So patent plays a very crucial role in promoting
innovation and enhancing healthcare by guaranteeing the development of the
innovation.
Introduction
Patents are exclusive rights that protect innovations in drug development in the
pharmaceutical industry. They can be granted to inventors, pharmaceutical
companies, or research organizations. Patents give the holder the right to
prevent others from making, using, selling, or importing their patented
inventions without permission for a set period of time.
Patents can cover the process of tangible items, for example drugs can be
patented for formulations. during the life of patent, no other entity can sell
any version of drugs, which can increase deflation or inflation, but companies
may file secondary patents which are illegal in nature.
Patents also serves share knowledges, advantages and disadvantages of
pharmaceutical sector as well as different entities such as, startups, research
organisation, public safety, and many more. However, pharmaceutical patent
requires a better knowledge and understanding related to pharmaceuticals sector
as well as science and legal concepts, and require close amalgamation between
law sector and pharmaceutical sector.
What Is Patent?
A patent has effective rights provided by the government (such as the US Patent
and trademark office USPTO) of for invention which is new, added an inventive
steps as well as capable for industrial application but in different way patents
will not give you the personal rights to make your own products, they can only
prevent others making, using, or selling of your product, or importing a product
in different countries. Patent protection is limited to the country or any other
countries that it was issued in and limited to a certain amount of time, mainly
20 years from the date of application filling of patients. Recently by the US
food and drug administration government advices that pharmaceutical patent may
be extended to compensate.
WHAT IS PATENTABLE?
A patent discovery must be related to novel, non-obvious. An invention is
defined as a new and inventive solution to technical problems, ideas, law of
nature, human nature, behaviour, scientific principal. In order to be a
patentable, an invention must have never been publicly disclosed or nor
discussed in seminar, presentation, paper, even with your family and friends or
colleagues. Once a discovery is granted a patent must fully disclose more
details about the invention so that people can understand. On the other hand,
the inventor couldn't disclose their invention by themselves but run the risk of
it being unprotected and has a monopoly over it until the competition figure
out.
Common Pharmaceutical Patent Extensions
There are many different types of pharmaceuticals patents in the world,
depending on the drug they are protecting, the selectness of each patent can be
extended by various method of lengths because drug invention, validation, and
marketing can take more than 10 years. It emphasizes companies to study and
develop new drugs by the extended time and effort during the development of
drugs. This is equivalent important for drugs in understudied areas such as rare
diseases , antibiotics, and population , because a large population of
pharmaceuticals industries( up to 80% ) revenue comes from their patents they
want to extend their patent as long as possible . once a patent expires, other
companies can manufacture and sell the drug. patents for new chemical entities
can be extend for five years under the FDA and European Medicines Agency (EMA)
sponsors also receives up to 11 years of exclusivity for new drug, eight years
of data exclusivity, two years of market exclusivity and one year of extension.
Patents for drugs with pediatric exclusivity (ones that include pediatric data)
can enjoy an additional six months of exclusivity under the FDA and EMA.
Patents for certain new antibiotics can have an extra five years of exclusivity
under the FDA.
Trips Agreement
The pharmaceutical patent is assume as true or real for a pharmaceutical
substance which mean any new existence or matter involving one or more
innovative or ingenious steps as per section 2 (t) of the Indian patent act. To
turn over the new leaf of the trips agreement the pharmaceutical industry was
highly unstable industry towards the patent protection. Their existed
inconsistency or unevenness towards the health status and medical need of the
people were largely unfulfilled. Then there exists only a process patent that
provides protection to the pharmaceutical companies but for bow article 27 (1)
of the trips extend the patent protection to the product as well as all the
fields of technology.
The TRIPS Agreement came into effect on 1st January 1995. It is an agreement
regarding intellectual property rights which is comprehensive and multilateral.
The Agreement defines the standard to protect the domestic law provided by each
member country. Under the TRIPS agreement, the main condition is that patent can
be issued for inventive measures, no matter it is a product or the process, in
all the categories of technology it should satisfy the three requirements that
is novelty, inventive measures and industrial applicability.
Trips Flexibilities
A patent grants exclusive rights to the innovation which often allows the patent
holder to enjoy a Monopoly position. Developing nations like India, where
efforts are made to make medicine available to all the parts of India at a
reasonable price, there is a high chance that pharmaceutical companies grab the
chance to exploit the patent monopoly by charging high prices and preventing the
local manufacturers from making common version of the drug. Therefore, some
adaptable changes were made into the trip agreement so that the member countries
could make a space for public interest by taking measures including to protect
public health to reach their social goals.
Drugs developed under the pharmaceutical industry received patent protection
under the trips agreement and their prices were increased as a result of the
Monopoly. This creates a challenging condition for the developing Nations. For
example, in Sub-Saharan Africa over 5 million people suffered from the disease
but are still unable to afford the required drugs. This clearly indicates that
the trip agreement doesn't want these developing countries to access essential
medicine. The to address this issues that Doha declaration on trip and public
health was adopted by members of the World Trade organisation in 2001.
The Doha declaration came into acceptance of the public health problem and they
need trips to be a part of the solution to these health issues. The declaration
seeks for the confirmation that the drips does not prevent member countries for
taking measures to protect public health the Doha declaration came to the
conclusion that trip should explain in such a way that it would support all
members write to protect health and promote access to the medicine for all.
Compulsory Licensing
Under Article 31, on the basis of some protocols, the TRIPS agreement provides a
way to promote public health by allowing the nation to issue a compulsory
license. Without the patent holder's authorisation, a license is established by
an administrative body to a third party to exploit an invention is called a
compulsory license. It is referred to as a non- voluntary license connoting
without any presence of consent by the patent holder.
For the promotion of research and development of new drugs by issuing compulsory
license is the ultimate goal behind it. However, such licenses is a type of mode
of payment for the enhancement of creating royalty in India. On the basis of
that owner/ manufacturer has made enough efforts to produce a voluntary license
from the patent holder on some specific terms within a specific period of time,
compulsory license enables the license to obtain a generic copy of the drug to
be made available in the local market at a price lesser than that of its
competitor.
Compulsory Licensing Of Covid-19 Drugs And Vaccine In India
We have faced the shortage of medicine and vaccines. There has been demanding
around in the market since the COVID-19 pandemic began in 2019. There was
imbalance between supply and demand of market as the cases has rising rapidly.
There were in discussion for past two years.
India had faced death rate around 7.3 per 1000 people. Most of the death was due
to the most viral virus COVID -19. To meet the need of people which was covid
drug and vaccines there was boon in the market to maintain the balance in their
demand and supply. The government shared their intellectual property with other
pharmaceutical companies to manufacture the urgent need of vaccine which leads
to speeding up the production of drugs and vaccines.
The legality of compulsory licensing is concerned, there are many examples that
initiate verification of compulsory licensing of pharmaceutical drugs in India.
In the year 2012, the Indian patent office permit a compulsory licence to the
Hyderabad - based drugmaker Natco to produce and sell a similar of buyer's
Nexavar which is an excellent kidney cancer drug. In the year 2000, our country
has observed that pharma based giant Cipla fighting against the government that
is compulsory for the Anti-Aids drugs so clearly, the law grants it.
Currently, the private sector is bit more unwilling to make use of compulsory
licences even when the government permit them because they are afraid of
prolonged litigation being broadband or in future refused in the partnership by
them even for contracted manufacture. The public health sector is the best
example for undertaking the compulsory licences issued by the government has
been destroyed by years of neglect. Nowadays most of the public health sector
are closed or about to closed. It concluded that we have shot ourselves in the
foot for not being able to make compulsory licences work to our advantage.
However, on 27th May, in a press statement NITI Ayog declared that India is not
planning to issue any mandatory license regarding COVID-19 vaccines and the
active cooperation of the companies that initially produced the vaccine is must.
In the Countries like South Africa and India, resolutions related to an
international debate on whether patent rights should only be suspended for the
vaccines but also for medicine and other equipment have been submitted to the
WTO. The goal of the resolution is to permit many countries for manufacturing
these products properly and thus minimising unnecessary global inequities.
Consequences Of Compulsory Licensing Of Pharmaceutical Drugs
Medicine's duplicates made under a compulsory licence may not meet the same
quality standards. A compulsory license does not guarantee that the background
knowledge of the company is sufficient to produce the drugs with the same
potency as the original product.
New treatment approaches may be discouraged from developing as a result of a
compulsory licensing. The fact that drug manufacturers have to imitate existing
therapies in order to profit from existing patents to prevent them from focusing
on developing new drugs.
Compulsory licensing discourages manufacturers from doing clinical trials in
countries that don't honor patents. This is a loss for patients who miss a
chance to receive treatment. It is also a loss for local economies which would
otherwise get a boost from having clinical trials in a region.
Conclusion
India is a developing market for pharmaceuticals and it has made many efforts in
research and development to produce its own pharma products.
The number of TRIPS (Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights)
restrictions have been cancelled to reciprocate WTO warnings that the epidemic
poses an unprecedented threat to the global economy.
When it comes to compulsory licensing, we should ask Indian pharmaceutical
companies whether they may use their manufacturing capacity to produce vaccines
and high quality medicines. This will allow us to take advantage of the
potential of obligatory licenses as a weapon. Indian private companies should
participate in the mandatory licensing process for foreign-made vaccines as
well. In this process, the government will ring-fence these private
pharmaceutical companies, providing them with financial support to offset
litigation costs and other potential legal repercussions.
Law Article in India
You May Like
Legal Question & Answers
Please Drop Your Comments