A contract[1] is a formal agreement established between two or more parties,
which holds legal enforceability and creates a set of obligations and
responsibilities for each party involved. This agreement can encompass various
aspects, such as goods, services, or rights, and it outlines the terms and
conditions under which the parties agree to operate. By defining the rights and
duties of each party, a contract provides clarity and protection in business
transactions or other interactions, ensuring that all parties understand their
roles and responsibilities and are held accountable for fulfilling them.
International instruments categorise contracts as "international" when they
involve parties from two or more different States, as outlined in conventions
such as the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of
Goods (Vienna, 1980) (CISG) and the Principles on Choice of Law in International
Commercial Contracts (2015)[2] (Hague Principles). That said, more flexible
definitions are possible, such as contracts with 'significant connections with
more than one State', 'involving a choice between the laws of different States',
or 'affecting the interests of international trade'. These broader criteria
reflect the diverse nature of international contracts and the complex legal
frameworks governing them.
One method of determining a contract as "commercial"[3] is when "each party is
acting in the exercise of its trade or profession," as stated in the Hague
Principles (Article 1(1)). Another approach, as seen in the CISG, involves
defining commercial matters and excluding contracts related to consumer goods
intended for personal, family, or household use (CISG, Article 2(a)).
These distinctions help differentiate between contracts primarily for business
purposes and those involving consumer transactions.
Background
In 1971, the Governing Council of UNIDROIT[4] initiated the project, initially
named "Progressive Codification of International Trade Law" and later renamed
"Preparation of Principles for International Commercial Contracts." However, due
to prior commitments, the project did not gain priority status until 1980, when
a special Working Group was established to draft the Principles. The Group
comprises leading experts in comparative law and international trade law,
including academics, judges, and civil servants. The Rapporteurs, appointed from
within the Group, were tasked with drafting and revising chapters of the
Principles based on discussions and feedback from the entire Group.
The ongoing phase involves the Group's meticulous examination of the final draft
chapters of the Principles. Subsequent to this meticulous review, the draft
Principles will undergo formal submission to the Governing Council of UNIDROIT
for authoritative validation. Concurrently, the detailed text of each individual
draft chapter, accompanied by a compilation of the most contentious matters, is
circulated among a diverse network of over 100 collaborators associated with the
Institute. Additionally, the draft documents are distributed to governmental
bodies to solicit their considered responses and perspectives on the proposed
Principles.
UNIDROIT International Commercial Contract principles advocate the freedom of
parties to decide the terms and conditions of the contract. That implies that
the parties can decide the jurisdiction of the dispute(in case there is a
dispute between the parties).
Importance of ICC
In the realm of international commercial contracts[5], two primary question hold
significant importance: First, determining the jurisdiction for resolving
disputes arising from the contract involves selecting a suitable legal forum or
arbitration tribunal based on factors like convenience, expertise,
enforceability, and procedural fairness. Second, identifying the applicable law
or rules means choosing the legal system or framework that will govern the
contract's interpretation and enforcement, which impacts rights, obligations,
remedies, and liability allocation. These decisions require careful
consideration and negotiation among parties to ensure clarity, fairness, and
enforceability of contractual terms, especially in dispute scenarios.
In business contracts, parties often include choice-of-forum and choice-of-law
clauses. The choice-of-forum clause determines where disputes will be resolved,
ensuring clarity and efficiency in legal proceedings. Meanwhile, the
choice-of-law clause specifies which laws govern the contract's interpretation,
promoting consistency and reducing legal uncertainties. These clauses enhance
the contract's reliability, protect parties' interests, and facilitate smoother
business transactions.
However, many times, parties fail to include choice-of-forum and choice-of-law
clauses while drafting. Which could lead to ambiguity in contract and in case of
dispute there will be no apt forum to deal with such cases. Therefore UNIDROIT
Principles becomes very important as they provide systematic way to deal with
these situation. The UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts
provide valuable guidance and standardisation in international business
dealings.
These principles serve as a reference point for parties entering into
contracts across different jurisdictions, offering a common framework for
contract interpretation and application. By aligning with these principles,
parties can promote legal certainty, fairness, and efficiency in their
contractual relationships. Additionally, the UNIDROIT Principles contribute to
harmonising international contract law and facilitate the resolution of disputes
by providing clear rules and principles that transcend national legal systems.
Overall, they play a crucial role in
promoting international trade and fostering trust and cooperation among business
entities worldwide.
Applicability in the Indian Context
Contract enforcement is vital to ensure that trade and commerce flourish in any
society. In the absence of contract enforcement, private parties may resort to
self-help and seize goods from a seller or use private means to coerce
performance[6]. The 2018 Amendment to specific relief act[7] can be viewed as a
notable departure, particularly regarding the application of the UNIDROIT
Principles of International Commercial Contracts (PICC).
This amendment
introduces the concept of specific performance, a norm recognised by the PICC,
despite the Indian Contract Act, 1872, not explicitly mentioning the notion of
'good faith', which is fundamental to the PICC. This shift towards principles
aligned with international standards like the PICC signifies a move towards
harmonisation and modernisation of India's commercial contract laws.
However, while this amendment aims to bring India's legal framework in line with
international practices, there are areas of inconsistency and lacunae when
compared directly with the PICC and the CISG. This nuanced approach necessitates
a comprehensive analysis of the impacts, benefits, and potential challenges
associated with the integration of PICC principles into Indian contract law
through the 2018 Amendment.
As India continues to globalize, adopting ICC principles can significantly
benefit its international transactions. The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC)
offers essential services like arbitration and dispute resolution through the
ICC International Court of Arbitration, advocates for trade-friendly policies,
establishes global standards, engages in policy advocacy for business- friendly
regulations, and fosters networking opportunities. These ICC principles
contribute to
7
India's integration into the global economy, enhancing the credibility of Indian
businesses and facilitating smoother international trade and investment
processes.
In the case of Modi Entertainment Network v. WSG Cricket Pte. Ltd[8]., the
Supreme Court provided further clarity on Indian private international
commercial law. It emphasized that parties in commercial contracts have the
freedom to choose any legal system, even if that legal system is unrelated to
the specific contractual obligation under consideration. This ruling underscores
the principle of party autonomy in international commercial transactions,
highlighting India's commitment to facilitating flexibility and autonomy in
contractual arrangements within the global business landscape.
Therefore, the Indian legal system recognises the PICC or International
Commercial contract as an instrument to resolve disputes that might occur in
international trade and commerce. India, being the fastest-growing major
economy, is required to make numerous international trade- related contracts,
which is why this principle is important.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the analysis of international commercial contracts within the
context of India's globalizing economy reveals a dynamic landscape shaped by
legal frameworks, principles, and practical considerations. The adoption of
UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts (PICC) and the 2018
Amendment to the Specific Relief Act reflects India's proactive approach to
harmonizing its commercial laws with international standards. This alignment not
only enhances legal certainty but also promotes fairness and transparency in
business transactions, thereby fostering trust and confidence among
stakeholders.
The role of institutions like the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) is
paramount in providing effective dispute resolution mechanisms and advocating
for business-friendly policies. The ICC's arbitration platforms, such as the ICC
International Court of Arbitration, play a crucial
role in resolving commercial disputes efficiently and impartially, contributing
to a conducive environment for international trade and investment.
Furthermore, the analysis underscores the significance of party autonomy in
international commercial contracts. The freedom granted to parties in choosing
applicable laws, dispute resolution forums, and contractual terms reflects
India's commitment to facilitating flexible and autonomous business
arrangements. This approach not only facilitates smoother business operations
but also enhances India's attractiveness as a preferred destination for
international business activities.
Overall, the analysis highlights the transformative potential of international
commercial contracts in driving India's global engagement and economic growth.
By embracing best practices, legal harmonisation, and effective
dispute-resolution mechanisms, India can position itself as a reliable and
competitive player in the global marketplace, fostering sustainable development
and mutually beneficial partnerships with global counterparts.
End-Notes:
- S, S. (2020, January 24). "Contract. Business Jargons https://businessjargons.com/contract.html. Accessed 5 Apr. 2024.
- e-Vision.nl, The Netherlands. (2015, March 19). HCCH | #40 - Full text. The World Organisation for Cross-border Co-operation in Civil and Commercial Matters, from https://www.hcch.net/en/instruments/conventions/full-text/?cid=135 Accessed April 5, 2024.
- Emery, C. (2016, March). International Commercial Contracts - GlobaLex. Globalex 2015. https://www.nyulawglobal.org/globalex/International_commercial_contracts.html#_edn1 Accessed April 5, 2024.
- Bonell, M. J. "Unification of Law by Non-Legislative Means: The UNIDROIT Draft Principles for International Commercial Contracts." The American Journal of Comparative Law, vol. 40, no. 3, 1992, pp. 617–33. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/840588. Accessed 3 Apr. 2024.
- Emery, C. (2016, March). International Commercial Contracts - GlobaLex. Globalex 2015. https://www.nyulawglobal.org/globalex/International_commercial_contracts.html#_edn1 Accessed April 5, 2024.
- Edward A Tomlinson, 'Performance Obligations of the Aggrieved Contractant: The French Experience' (1989) (12) LLICLJ 139 188-192; Subha Narasimhan, 'Modification: The Self-Help Specific Performance Remedy' (1987) (97) YLJ 61, 91
- Parliament of India. (2018). The Specific Relief (Amendment) Bill, 2018. In The Specific Relief Act, 1963. http://164.100.47.4/BillsTexts/LSBillTexts/PassedLoksabha/248-C_2018_LS_Eng.pdf
- Modi Entertainment Network v. W.S.G. Cricket. PTE. LTD, (2003) 4 SCC 341
Also Read:
Please Drop Your Comments