One type of sexual assault that has long been mainly disregarded is marital
rape. It is a crime that takes place inside of a marriage or other relationship;
it is a grave transgression of human rights and a breach of trust. Marital rape
is not regarded as a crime in many nations, including India. This is gradually
changing, though, as more nations realize how important it is to deal with this
problem.
Due to the high rate of non-reporting, marital rape is a hidden crime.
Particularly if the offender is their spouse, victims may experience feelings of
humiliation, embarrassment, or fear when speaking up. Because they may have been
conditioned, victims of sexual assault occasionally may not even be aware that
they have been abused.
It is important to recognize that marital rape is a crime and that it is never
acceptable. Just because two people are married does not give one partner the
right to force the other to engage in sexual acts against their will. It is a
violation of their bodily autonomy and a form of domestic violence.
One of the reasons why marital rape has been ignored is due to the traditional
view of marriage. Marriage has often been viewed as a sacred union between two
people, and sex is seen as an essential element of that union. This has led to
the belief that a spouse has the right to have sex with their partner,
regardless of their consent. However, this view is outdated and harmful. Consent
is essential in any sexual encounter, including within a marriage.
Another reason why marital rape has been ignored is due to the lack of legal
protection for victims. In many countries, marital rape is not considered a
criminal offense, and victims have little legal recourse. This has led to a
culture of impunity, where perpetrators can commit sexual violence against their
spouses with little fear of consequences.
Recognizing and understanding the issue of marital rape is the first step
towards ending it. It is important to educate ourselves and others about the
issue and to challenge the harmful beliefs and attitudes that have perpetuated
it. This includes promoting a culture of consent, where all sexual encounters
are based on mutual respect and understanding.
In addition, it is important to provide legal protection and support for victims
of marital rape. This includes criminalizing marital rape, as well as providing
victims with access to legal and social services. Victims should be able to seek
help without fear of judgment or retaliation.
Marital Rape in India: A Legal Perspective
Marital rape, also known as spousal rape, is a form of sexual violence that
occurs within a marriage or intimate relationship. It is a serious violation of
human rights and has been recognized as a criminal offense in many countries,
including India.
In India, marital rape is not explicitly recognized as a criminal offense under
the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Section 375 of the IPC defines rape as an act of
sexual intercourse with a woman without her consent or against her will.
However, an exception to this section provides that sexual intercourse by a man
with his wife, who is over 15 years of age, is not rape, even if it is without
her consent.
This exception has been the subject of much controversy and criticism. It has
been argued that it violates the fundamental rights of women and perpetuates the
patriarchal mindset that treats women as the property of their husbands. Many
women's rights activists and organizations have called for the removal of this
exception and the criminalization of marital rape in India.
While the Supreme Court did not explicitly rule on the issue of marital rape,
the judgment has been seen as a step towards recognizing the rights of women in
marriage. It has been argued that if sexual intercourse with a minor wife is
considered rape, then sexual intercourse with an adult wife without her consent
should also be considered rape.
In recent years, there have been several attempts to amend the law to
criminalize marital rape in India. The Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 2019,
which was introduced in the Lok Sabha, proposed to remove the exception to
Section 375 of the IPC and make marital rape a criminal offense. However, the
bill lapsed with the dissolution of the 16th Lok Sabha.
The issue of marital rape is a complex one and involves not only legal but also
social and cultural factors. Many people in India still view marriage as a
sacred institution and believe that a husband has the right to have sex with his
wife whenever he wants. This mindset needs to change, and there needs to be
greater awareness and education about the issue of marital rape.
The legal framework in India does not recognize marital rape as a criminal
offense. This is a serious violation of women's rights and needs to be
rectified. The exception to Section 375 of the IPC needs to be removed, and
marital rape needs to be criminalized. However, legal reform alone is not
enough. There needs to be a societal shift in attitudes towards marriage and
women's rights. Only then can we hope to eradicate the scourge of marital rape
in India.
Comparative Analysis Of Marital Rape Provisions:
For many years, marital rape has been a contentious issue due to differing legal
and cultural views on the matter. We shall examine the laws pertaining to
marital rape in India, the US, and England in this comparative examination.
India
In India, marital rape was only criminalized in 2013, with the introduction
of the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act. Before this, marital rape was not
considered a criminal offense. However, even with this amendment, there are
still loopholes in the law. Marital rape is only considered a crime if the wife
is under the age of 18, and if the act of rape is committed during a separation
or divorce proceeding. This narrow definition has come under heavy criticism,
with many arguing that it does not go far enough in protecting women.
U.S.A
In the United States criminalizes marital rape in all 50 states. However, the
laws surrounding marital rape vary from state to state. Some states require
proof of physical force, while others do not. Some states also have spousal
exemption clauses, which mean that spouses cannot be charged with rape if they
have had consensual sex before the act of rape. These exemptions have been
heavily criticized, with many arguing that they undermine the severity of the
crime.
England
In England, marital rape was criminalized in 1991, with the introduction of the
Criminal Justice Act. However, like in the United States, the laws surrounding
marital rape vary depending on the circumstances. For example, if the act of
rape was committed before 1991, the perpetrator cannot be charged with rape.
Additionally, if the victim is incapacitated or asleep, the act of rape is not
considered a crime.
While some progress has been made in criminalizing marital rape, there is still
much work to be done. The narrow definitions and exemptions present in some laws
undermine the severity of the crime and do not go far enough in protecting
victims. Lawmakers must continue to review and update these laws to ensure that
all victims of rape, regardless of their marital status, are protected by the
law.
Impact Of Marital Rape On Victims
Marital rape is a concept that has been debated for years in India. The country
has been known for its patriarchal society, where women are often subjected to
violence and abuse by their husbands. However, until recently, marital rape was
not even recognized as a crime under Indian law. Despite the efforts made by
activists and lawmakers, marital rape is still not considered a criminal offense
in India, and this has had a significant impact on victims.
The impact of marital rape on victims in India is profound, and it can have
long-lasting consequences. Most victims of marital rape in India suffer in
silence, as they are often afraid to speak out against their husbands. This fear
is not unfounded, as many women who do speak out against their husbands are
often ostracized by their communities and even face violence and retaliation.
Victims of marital rape often suffer from physical and emotional trauma. They
may experience pain, bleeding, and infection from forced sexual activity. The
emotional trauma can be even more devastating, as victims of marital rape often
feel violated and helpless. They may suffer from depression, anxiety, and
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) as a result of the abuse.
Victims of marital rape have psychological and physical distress in addition to
other effects. Marital rape victims frequently find themselves in challenging
legal circumstances. Marital rape is not punishable by law in India, so victims
may have trouble pursuing legal action. Many victims feel imprisoned in their
violent relationships and helpless as a result.
It is quite concerning that Indian victims of marital rape are not afforded any
legal protection. It diminishes the dignity and rights of women and gives
offenders the message that they may get away with abusing their spouses. The
Indian government is failing in its duty to safeguard its people from abuse and
violence by refusing to acknowledge marital rape as a criminal offense.
The impact of marital rape on victims in India is devastating. Victims suffer
from physical and emotional trauma, and they often find themselves in a
difficult legal situation. The lack of legal protection for victims of marital
rape is a serious concern, and it is time for the Indian government to recognize
marital rape as a criminal offense. Lawyers, law students, and professors can
play an important role in addressing this issue by raising awareness and
advocating for legal reform. It is time to put an end to the violence and abuse
that women in India face within their own homes.
Judicial Pronouncements
In India, marital rape has long been a contentious and delicate topic. It
describes a husband and wife having sex without the woman's consent. For a very
long time, marital rape was not regarded as a crime in India, despite being an
egregious crime. But as events have changed, the Indian legal system has begun
to acknowledge the seriousness of this crime. We'll talk about some of the most
important Indian case laws pertaining to marital rape in this article.
The first case law that we would like to discuss is the
State of Maharashtra
v. Madhukar Narayan Mardikar [1]case. In this case, the accused was charged
with raping his wife while she was in an unconscious state. The defense argued
that since the victim was his wife, he had the right to have sexual intercourse
with her. However, the court rejected this argument and held that the right to
sexual intercourse does not give a husband the right to rape his wife. The court
convicted the accused of rape and awarded him a sentence of seven years of
rigorous imprisonment.
The second case law that we would like to discuss is the Independent Thought v.
Union of India[2] case. In this case, the Supreme Court of India held that
sexual intercourse with a minor wife, even if she is above the age of consent,
would amount to rape. The court observed that the age of consent for sexual
intercourse should be eighteen years for both boys and girls, irrespective of
their marital status.
The court also observed that the exception to rape under Section 375 of the
Indian Penal Code, which exempts husbands from being charged with rape if the
wife is above fifteen years of age, is unconstitutional. The case concerned the
validity of an exception in the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO)
Act, 2012, which allowed sexual intercourse with a minor wife in the age group
of 15-18 years. The Supreme Court held that the exception was unconstitutional
and violated the rights of the child.
The third case law that we would like to discuss is the Sakshi v. Union of India
[3] case. In this case, the Supreme Court of India issued guidelines for the
investigation and prosecution of cases of sexual violence against women. The
court observed that marital rape is a form of sexual violence that is often
ignored or condoned by society. The court directed the government to take steps
to prevent and punish marital rape and to provide support and assistance to
victims of sexual violence.
Marital rape is a serious offense that is now recognized as a criminal offense
in India. The Indian legal system has started to recognize the gravity of this
offense, and the courts have started to convict the accused for rape. However,
there is a long way to go in terms of prevention and punishment of marital rape.
The government needs to take proactive steps to prevent and punish marital rape
and to provide support and assistance to victims of sexual violence.
Suggestions:
It appears jus and proper to state that following suggestions can be looked into
to minimize instances of marital rape cases.
Marital rape is a serious issue that has been the subject of much debate and
discussion in recent years. Even though it is a crime in many countries, there
are still many places where it is not recognized as such. In this article, we
will provide legal suggestions that can help stop marital rape.
The first step in stopping marital rape is to recognize that it is a crime. In
many countries, marital rape is not recognized as a crime because it is believed
that a husband has the right to have sex with his wife whenever he wants.
However, this belief is based on outdated notions of marriage and gender roles,
and it is important to recognize that no one has the right to force another
person to have sex against their will.
Once it is recognized that marital rape is a crime, it is important to ensure
that the legal system is equipped to deal with it. This means that laws need to
be put in place that make it clear that marital rape is a crime and that provide
for appropriate penalties. In addition, the legal system needs to be set up in
such a way that victims of marital rape feel safe and supported when they come
forward to report it.
One way to do this is to provide training for judges and lawyers on how to
handle cases of marital rape. This training should include information on the
nature of the crime, the psychological impact it can have on victims, and the
best ways to support victims throughout the legal process. It is also important
to ensure that there are adequate resources available for victims, such as
counseling services and legal aid.
Shifting societal perceptions of marital rape is a crucial step in ending it.
This entails attempting to inform the public about the characteristics of crime
and the suffering that it inflicts on its victims. Challenging the antiquated
notions that support a husband's entitlement to have sex with his wife whenever
he pleases is another aspect of it. Campaigns for public education as well as
adjustments to the way relationships and gender roles are portrayed in the media
can accomplish this.
Lastly, it's critical to guarantee that rape victims in marriage have access to
justice. This entails making sure the legal system is set up in a way that
encourages individuals to come forward and report the crime and giving them the
support they need to do so.
Stopping marital rape is a complex issue that requires a multi-faceted approach.
It requires changing societal attitudes towards the crime, ensuring that the
legal system is equipped to deal with it, and providing victims with the support
they need to access justice. By working together, we can create a world where no
one has to suffer from the trauma of marital rape.
Conclusion
The topic of marital rape has been the focus of intense discussion for many
years. The way society views the matter has significantly changed, and an
increasing number of people are in favor of making marital rape a crime. The
question of whether or not marital rape should be illegal has generated a great
deal of controversy. But it's crucial to realize that making marital rape
illegal is a step toward achieving equality and justice for everybody.
The problem of marital rape is grave and has been disregarded for far too long.
It is a kind of domestic violence as well as a violation of human rights. It's
critical to acknowledge and comprehend the problem, oppose negative attitudes
and ideas, and offer victims support and legal protection. Legal experts like us
have a big part to play in putting a stop to this covert crime.
Marital rape must be made illegal in order to send a clear message that no one
has the right to violate the body of another. It also guarantees the same legal
protections and access to justice for victims of marital rape as for victims of
rape that occurred outside of marriage.
The legalization of marital rape is opposed by some who claim that it would be
impossible to enforce and that it would result in false claims. But these
worries are unwarranted. The prosecution would have the burden of proof in any
enforcement of the legislation, just like in any other instance involving sexual
assault. While false charges are a concern in any criminal case, it is
imperative that survivors of marital rape be not allowed to be ignored.
It's also critical to remember that making marital rape illegal would not cause
marriages to fail. Conversely, by guaranteeing that each partner has equal
rights in the partnership, it would enhance marriages. The foundation of a
marriage should be mutual love, trust, and
In conclusion, the criminalization of marital rape is a critical step towards
ensuring justice and equality for all. It sends a strong message that no one has
the right to violate another person's body and ensures that survivors of marital
rape have access to justice and legal protections. The criminalization of
marital rape should be supported by all individuals who believe in the
fundamental human right to bodily autonomy.
End-Notes:
- AIR 1991 SC 207
- AIR 2017 SC 4904
- (2004) 5 SCC 518
Written By:
- Akarshita Singh, B.B.A Ll.B (Hons.), 10th Semester, Amity Law
School, Lucknow.
- Dr.Anuj Kumar Sharma, Assistant Professor, Amity Law School,
Lucknow.
Please Drop Your Comments