Financial decisions, dementia, and forced separation are all important issues in
the field of family law. It becomes clear from examining these problems in the
Indian context that they present special difficulties that call for careful
consideration and legal action. When one spouse is forced to separate against
their will, this is referred to as a forced separation. Family matters are
governed by both personal and secular laws in India, and grounds for divorce
include cruelty, desertion, adultery, and mental illness.
People who have been
forced apart may seek legal redress, including divorce based on suitable grounds
or protection under domestic violence laws. Such disputes require extensive
knowledge of the legal system and the capacity to maneuver challenging emotional
dynamics. A neurodegenerative disease that worsens over time is dementia.
Cognitive processes, memory, and behavior are all impacted by dementia, a
progressive neurodegenerative condition. The legal framework in India regarding
dementia patients' ability to make decisions is still developing. Legal experts
are essential in helping families navigate these complexities and guaranteeing
that the rights and welfare of people with dementia are upheld. Property
division, alimony, and maintenance are just a few examples of the financial
decisions covered by family law.
In conclusion, family law faces a variety of
difficulties related to forced separation, dementia, and financial decisions. To
address these problems, one must have a complex understanding of India's legal
system, emotional sensitivity, and unique cultural settings. To safeguard the
rights and interests of those involved in such cases, it is crucial to seek
legal advice from experienced experts.
Introduction
Cognitive decline in old age is common. Many elderly residents of communities
suffer from clinical depression and significant cognitive decline. In people 65
and older, dementia is the most common cause of cognitive impairment. As people
age, dementia becomes more common.
Dementia must be distinguished from other
clinical conditions like mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and other widespread
mental health issues like depression. Many different diseases can cause
dementia, which is a clinical syndrome. Depending on the aetiology, the onset
and progression vary, but they are typically gradual. Dementia is frequently a
problem that goes unrecognized, especially in societies where it is not widely
recognized.
In light of the authors' clinical and forensic psychiatric experience, which
ranges from early career (NC) to mid-career (MC) psychiatrists, this
point-of-view paper makes an effort to synthesize the pertinent scientific
literature. Senior psychiatrist with experience in geriatrics (KSS),
neuropsychiatrist (MC), and senior psychiatrist with experience abroad (RK). We
had internal conversations about particular problems involving dementia patients
in India. We chose and examined pertinent articles from PubMed and other online
databases, and we discussed concerns about clinical practice. In this essay, we
discuss some of the numerous problems that clinicians encounter.
Forced Separation, Dementia, And Financial Decision-Making Can All Be Complex
Issues In The Context Of Family Law
Forced separation, dementia, and financial decision-making can all play
important roles in family law cases, particularly those related to divorce,
property division, and elder law. Forced separation refers to a situation where
one or both parties are separated against their will, typically due to an order
from a court or other legal authority. This can occur in cases of domestic
violence or child custody disputes, for example.[1] Dementia is a medical
condition that affects cognitive function, including memory, reasoning, and
decision-making abilities. It can be particularly challenging in the context of
family law, as it may impact a person's ability to make sound financial
decisions or participate in legal proceedings.
Making financial decisions is a crucial component of family law, especially in
situations involving divorce or separation. This may involve choices regarding,
among other things, the division of property and the payment of spousal and
child support. Making sure that everyone has access to the facts they need to
make wise decisions and that any agreements reached are just and equitable is
crucial. In cases where dementia is a factor, additional steps may be necessary
to protect the interests of the affected party.
This may include appointing a
guardian or conservator to make financial decisions on their behalf or seeking a
court order to ensure their rights are protected. Overall, family law cases that
involve forced separation, dementia, and financial decision-making require
careful consideration of a range of legal and ethical issues. Individuals who
are facing these challenges need to seek the advice and guidance of experienced
legal professionals to ensure that their rights and interests are protected.
Forced Separation, Dementia, And Financial Decision-Making Can Be Complex
Issues In The Context Of Family Law.
Here Are Some Key Points To Consider:
Forced separation can occur in situations such as domestic violence or child
protection concerns. In these cases, the court may make orders to protect the
safety and well-being of family members. The court may also consider the views
of the parties involved, as well as any evidence presented when making decisions
about forced separation.
Dementia can affect a person's ability to make decisions, including financial
decisions. In family law, this can be particularly relevant when determining
issues such as property division and spousal support. If a party has been
diagnosed with dementia, the court may appoint a guardian or trustee to make
financial decisions on their behalf. The court may also consider medical
evidence and the views of family members when making decisions related to a
person's dementia.
Making financial decisions can be a big deal in family law, especially in
divorce or separation cases. Then the court may consider a range of factors when
determining issues such as spousal support and property division, including the
financial contributions of each party, their earning capacity, and their
financial needs. [2]The court may also consider any agreements or arrangements
that have been made between the parties.
Overall, navigating the issues of
forced separation, dementia, and financial decision-making in family law can be
complex.[3] It is important to seek the advice of a lawyer with expertise in
family law to help you understand your rights and obligations in these
situations.
Forced Separation Situation In India
In India, forced separation is commonly associated with instances of forced
marriages or cases where one spouse separates from the other against their will.
Below are some important laws related to forced separation prevalent in Indian
societies:
- The Act on the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005: The act states the law that provides protection and relief to women who are victims of domestic violence, including forced separation from their husbands. The law recognizes that physical, sexual, verbal, emotional, and economic abuse can all constitute domestic violence.
- Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: This law governs Hindu marriages and provides for divorce on various grounds, including cruelty and desertion. In cases of forced separation, where one spouse has left the other against their will, this law can be used to seek a divorce.
- Special Marriage Act, 1954: This law provides for the marriage of persons from different religions or nationalities. It also provides for divorce on various grounds, including cruelty and desertion, and can be used in cases of forced separation.
Acts related to Legal Protections and Offenses
- The Indian Penal Code: The Indian Penal Code Section 498A makes it a criminal offense to subject a married woman to cruelty by her husband or his relatives. This includes acts that lead to forced separation, such as harassment, verbal abuse, and physical violence.
- Act of 1986 Protects The Rights Of Divorced Muslim Women: Muslim women who have experienced divorce from their husbands are protected by this law. It contains provisions for child custody and the payment of maintenance.
- The 2012 Protection of Children from Sexual Offenses Act: Children are protected by this law from exploitation and sexual abuse. It contains guidelines for reporting crimes, designating special courts to hear cases of child sexual abuse, and protecting young witnesses.
These are some of the important laws related to forced separation in India. It
is important to note that the legal remedies available to victims of forced
separation may vary depending on their religion, marital status, and other
factors.[4]
Cases Involving Forced Separation In India
Forced separation is a form of domestic violence and is considered a violation
of human rights. In India, family law has provisions to address cases of forced
separation and to protect the rights of the affected individuals. Here are some
notable cases related to forced separation in India in family law:
The case of Sunita Kumari vs. Sanjeev Kumar: In this case, the wife filed a
petition seeking protection from her husband, who had forcibly separated her
from her children. The court directed the husband to return the children to the
wife and granted her protection from further harassment.
The case of Anjana Kishore Sawant vs. Kishore Babulal Sawant: The wife requested
a divorce in this case on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. The court
granted her divorce and directed the husband to pay maintenance and compensation
for the suffering caused to the wife.
Union of India v. Shabnam Hashmi: In this case, the Supreme Court ordered the
government to pass legislation to address the issue of forced separation and to
offer assistance to the affected parties.
The case of Shamima Farooqui vs. Shahid Khan: In this case, the wife filed a
petition seeking protection from her husband, who had separated her from her
children and was threatening to harm her. The court directed the husband to
return the children to the wife and granted her protection from further
harassment.
These cases highlight the need for legal remedies to protect the rights of
individuals who are victims of forced separation. [5]Family law in India
recognizes the seriousness of this issue and provides for legal provisions and
remedies to address it.
Laws And Legal Provision Of Dementia
Dementia is a neurological disorder that affects the cognitive abilities of a
person, leading to memory loss, impaired judgment, and changes in behavior. In
India, family law has provisions to deal with cases involving dementia,
particularly those related to the care and protection of individuals suffering
from this condition.
Here are some important laws and legal provisions related to dementia cases in
India:
- The Guardians and Wards Act of 1890: Allows for the appointment of a guardian for a person who is unable to care for themselves because of illness, youth, or other circumstances. In cases of dementia, a guardian can be appointed to take care of the individual and manage their affairs.
- Act of 2007 Concerning the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens: The maintenance and welfare of parents and senior citizens, including those with dementia, are covered by this law. It enables the elderly to claim maintenance and provides for their protection against abuse and neglect.
- Indian Succession Act, 1925: This law deals with the inheritance of property in India. In cases of dementia, the provisions of this law can be used to ensure that the property of the affected individual is managed and distributed properly.
- The 2017 Mental Healthcare Act: guarantees the protection, care, and treatment of people who suffer from mental illnesses, including dementia. Additionally, it allows for the appointment of a nominated representative who can make decisions on behalf of someone unable to do so due to a mental illness.
- Act of 2005 Protecting Women from Domestic Violence: Domestic violence is protected under this law for all women, including elderly women with dementia. It enables them to look for safety and protection from mistreatment and neglect.
In cases involving dementia, family law in India recognizes the need for special care and protection of affected individuals. The legal provisions and remedies available can help ensure that their rights and interests are safeguarded. It is important to seek legal advice and guidance to understand the options available in such cases.
Dementia Case Law In India's Family Law
There are several notable dementia case laws in India in family law that deal
with issues related to the care and protection of individuals suffering from
this condition. Here are some examples:
-
The case of Ratnamala Kothandaraman vs. Kothandaraman: In this case, the daughter of an elderly man suffering from dementia filed a petition seeking to be appointed as his guardian. The court appointed the daughter as the guardian and directed her to take care of her father's health and well-being.
-
A case involving the Union of India and the National Trust for the Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation, and Multiple Disabilities:
The Supreme Court ordered the federal government to create a national policy for the protection and care of people with disabilities, including those who have dementia, in this case.
-
The case of Neelam Kumar vs. Union of India: The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, was passed in this case, and the Supreme Court ordered the federal government to put its provisions into effect for the welfare and protection of elderly people, including those with dementia.
-
The case of Mohammad Aslam Sheikh vs. Halima Sheikh: In this instance, the Bombay High Court designated a dementia-stricken elderly woman's son as her guardian to look after her health and well-being.
These cases highlight the need for proper care and protection of individuals
suffering from dementia, particularly in the context of family law. They also
emphasize the importance of legal remedies available to address the needs and
concerns of affected individuals and their families.
Lack Of Financial Decision-Making Cases In Indian Family Law
In India, family law recognizes the importance of financial decision-making in a
family and provides for legal provisions to deal with cases where there is a
lack of financial decision-making. [6]Here are some notable cases related to the
lack of financial decision-making in India in family law:
-
The case of Narinder Singh vs. Harminder Kaur: In this case, the husband had filed a petition seeking divorce on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. The court granted him a divorce and directed the wife to pay him maintenance and compensation for the financial loss suffered due to her lack of financial decision-making.
-
The case of Bimla Devi vs. the State of Haryana: In this case, the mother of a mentally challenged adult son filed a petition seeking to be appointed as his guardian to take care of his financial and other needs. The court appointed the mother as the guardian and directed her to take care of her son's health and well-being.
-
The case of Praveen Singh vs. Meenakshi Singh: In this case, the wife filed a petition seeking divorce on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. The court granted her divorce and directed the husband to pay her maintenance and compensation for the financial loss suffered due to his lack of financial decision-making.
-
The case of Savita vs. State of Uttar Pradesh: In this case, the mother of a mentally challenged adult daughter filed a petition seeking to be appointed as her guardian to take care of her financial and other needs. The court appointed the mother as the guardian and directed her to take care of her daughter's health and well-being.
These cases highlight the importance of financial decision-making in a family
and the need for legal remedies to address cases where there is a lack of
financial decision-making. Family law in India provides for legal provisions and
remedies to protect the interests of the affected individuals and to ensure that
their rights are safeguarded.[7]
Recommendation & Suggestions
Healthcare providers cannot provide legal or financial advice, but they can
encourage patients and their families to have planning discussions. Doctors can
also advise patients, families, the care team, attorneys, and judges on the
patient's decision-making capacity. During the annual wellness visit, Medicare
covers the cost of discussing advance care planning decisions with a doctor.
These discussions may also be covered by private health insurance.
An elder law attorney assists older people and their families in understanding
state laws, planning how wishes will be carried out, understanding financial
options, and learning how to preserve financial assets.
Before scheduling an appointment, it's a good idea to inquire about a lawyer's
fees. Families can get help finding qualified lawyers from the American Bar
Association and the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys. A local bar
association can also assist in locating free legal aid options. More information
can be found in the resources section at the end of this article.
Social workers or nurses with specialized training in geriatric care management
can help dementia patients and their families. You can read more about geriatric
care managers here.
Conclusion
In the coming decades, there will be an increase in the number of people
suffering from dementia, which is a terrible disease. Clinicians, therefore,
need to be aware of current legal requirements that have an impact on diagnosing
and treating dementia patients. Health and social care for those with dementia
are a social obligation. To protect the rights of senior citizens with disabling
medical conditions like dementia, which prevent people from living
independently, we must look into the possibility of strengthening the current
legal system.
This position paper discusses the problems with determining a person's capacity
and level of disability, as well as their applicability to Indian law. According
to the MHCA of India, all individuals with mental illness are assumed to have a
mental illness capacity as of 2017. A thorough capacity analysis is necessary.
Dementia disability can be evaluated and certified using IDEAS.
Clinicians need to understand the implications and problems with advance
directives, choosing nominees for representation, driving, and other prevalent
Indian laws that have an impact on people with disabilities.
In the Western world, divorce is a frequent occurrence. One of the loudest
opponents of this family issue is the Eastern world. The topic of divorce is
still taboo today. Even if a couple marries in a beautiful ceremony and seems to
be the happiest people on earth, it is unknown what will happen after that.
Either a fairy tale existence or the worst nightmares were possible for them.
The couple will file for divorce if things worsen. There is no single law that
governs divorce; rather, every religion has its own set of regulations regarding
marriage and divorce. One of two divorce petitions may be filed by a husband or
wife.
There is no single law that governs divorce; rather, every religion has its own
set of regulations regarding marriage and divorce. One of two divorce petitions
may be filed by a husband or wife. If they decide to get a divorce, they do so
voluntarily. A contested divorce happens when one of the spouses of the marriage
wishes to file a divorce petition. The petition can be filed in court on grounds
like cruelty, adultery, communicable disease, mental disorder, etc. by either
the husband or the wife.
End-Notes:
- Morris JC. The clinical dementia rating (CDR): Current version and scoring rules. Neurology 1993 November 1; 43(11): 2412-2412-a.
- Folstein MF, Folstein SE, and McHugh PR. "Mini-mental state". A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician. J Psychiatr Res 1975 November; 12(3): 189–198.
- Kim SYH and Caine ED. Utility and limits of the mini-mental state examination in evaluating consent capacity in Alzheimer's disease. Psychiatr Serv 2002 October 1; 53(10): 1322–1324.
- Begali VL. Neuropsychology and the dementia spectrum: Differential diagnosis, clinical management, and forensic utility. NeuroRehabilitation 2020; 46(2): 181–194.
- Ganguli M, Ratcliff G, Chandra V, et al. A Hindi version of the MMSE: The development of a cognitive screening instrument for a largely illiterate rural elderly population in India. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1995; 10(5): 367–377.
- International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision (ICD-10) Version: 2016. Available from: http://apps.who.int/classifications/icd10/browse/2016/en#!/X (accessed 20 June 2021).
- American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.) 2013. Available from https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.books.9780890425596 (Last accessed 20 June 2021).
Please Drop Your Comments