The Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement,
enacted on January 1, 1995, is a cornerstone of an IP-based international legal
framework, serving as a comprehensive multilateral treaty among all World Trade
Organization (WTO) member nations. (WTO members consist of 164 distinct nations.
That is in addition to 24 observer governments)
Background of the TRIPS Agreement:
Before the establishment of the TRIPS Agreement, there was no comprehensive
international framework governing intellectual property rights. Different
countries had varying levels of protection and enforcement. This led to
disparities and potential trade disputes. The TRIPS Agreement was negotiated
during the Uruguay Round of multilateral trade negotiations. It came into effect
on January 1, 1995, as part of the establishment of the WTO.
What is TRIPS:
TRIPS (Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights) is an
international legal agreement between all the member nations of the World Trade
Organization (WTO). It sets down minimum standards for the regulation of
different forms of intellectual property by national governments.
Salient Features Of TRIPS Agreements:
- General Provisions and Basic Principles (Article 1 to Article 8)
This part covers the requirements for the availability, scope, and application of intellectual property rights. (Article 9 to Article 40)
- The enforcement of IPRs is the focus of this part. (Article 41 to Article 61)
- This part covers the procedures for obtaining and maintaining intellectual property rights. (Article 62)
- This part deals with the prevention and resolution of conflicts resulting from the provisions of the Agreement. (Article 63 to Article 64)
- This part is about transitional agreements. (Article 65 to Article 67)
- This part of the Agreement deals with a variety of institutional arrangements. (Article 68 to Article 73)
Its primary objective is to standardize a common baseline for national regulation of various forms of intellectual property such as:
- Foster technical innovation: Encouraging the creation of new technologies and ideas by providing inventors with exclusive rights and protections.
- Facilitate transfer and distribution of technology: Facilitating the sharing of technological knowledge and advancements across borders, promoting global economic growth.
- Integration of rights and obligations: Striking a balance between the interests of creators and users of intellectual property, ensuring fair competition and access to knowledge.
Key Features of the TRIPS Agreement:
- Standards: The TRIPS Agreement establishes minimum standards for intellectual property protection across member countries, specifying subject matter, duration of rights, and the scope of protection.
- The incorporated commitments from the Paris Convention and Berne Convention have resulted in it being dubbed as "Berne and Paris-plus" agreement.
- This integration offers a consistent approach to intellectual property protection across all member states.
- Enforcement: This component of the agreement emphasizes the importance of effective enforcement mechanisms for domestic intellectual property rights. This feature outlines procedures for all IPR proceedings such as criminal and civil cases, border measures, and temporary injunctions.
- Dispute Settlement: Disputes between WTO members regarding TRIPS obligations are settled through the organization's established dispute settlement procedures. This provides a neutral and internationally recognized framework for resolving complex IP challenges, standardizing fair and equal settlement among all.
Role of TRIPS Agreement in Shaping India's Intellectual Property Regime:
Patents:
One of the important impacts of the TRIPS Agreement on India's intellectual
property command was in the area of patents. India had historically granted
process patents in its place of product patents for pharmaceuticals, allowing
local manufacturers to produce common versions of patented drugs at a lower
cost. However, under TRIPS, India was required to evolve to a product patent
regime and also this change led to challenges for the Indian pharmaceutical
industry in terms of admission to affordable medicines and the convenience of
generic drugs.
Copyrights:
The TRIPS Agreement also influenced India's copyright law. It introduced minimum
standards for copyright protection, including the term of protection, rights of
authors, and limitations and exemptions and India amended its Copyright Act in
1999 to align with TRIPS requirements and extend copyright protection to
computer software, digital works, and performances in the digital environment.
Trademarks and Industrial Designs:
The TRIPS Agreement set minimum standards for the protection of trademarks and
industrial designs and also required India to provide satisfactory protection to
trademarks and establish a system for the registration and enforcement of
industrial designs as India amended its Trademarks Act in 1999 to comply with
TRIPS obligations and habituated provisions for the registration and guard of
well-known trademarks.
Geographical indications:
Customarily, some commercial items have been manufactured in a geographically
defined territory and commercial relations, the geographical indicator becomes
the dependable "carrier" of qualifying product features when these items are
credited to certain criteria basically due to their geographical provenance. The
purpose and value of geographical indications are subsequently given to
trademarks, and they are allowable legal protection.
Definition of TRIPS Agreement within Humanitarian Context:
In a humanitarian context, the TRIPS Agreement has a strong relevance. It
contributes to protecting rights pertaining to intellectual property and
facilitating access to goods and services in times of crisis.
From a humanitarian perspective, the TRIPS Agreement is of significant
importance because it allows for exceptions in cases of emergencies, with
provisions for compulsory licensing that can be used to increase the
availability of vital pharmaceuticals in developing countries.
For Example;
For instance, during the HIV/AIDS pandemic, several low-income countries used
the flexibilities allowed under the TRIPS Agreement to produce generic versions
of antiretroviral drugs, bringing down costs and increasing access to lifesaving
treatment.
Role of WTO in TRIPS Intellectual Property Protection:
WTO plays a crucial role in the TRIPS intellectual property protection. It
administers the TRIPS Agreement and other WTO agreements, provides a forum for
trade negotiations, handles trade disputes, monitors national trade policies,
and cooperates with other international organizations in global economic
policy-making.
For Example:
In 2001 during the Doha Round of meetings, the WTO clarified that protecting
public health should be central to TRIPS. The declaration affirmed that the
agreement should not prevent countries from taking necessary steps to protect
public health, demonstrating the central role that WTO plays in balancing the
goals of access to essential medicines and the need to promote pharmaceutical
innovation.
Impacts of WTO TRIPS Agreement on Global Trade:
The WTO TRIPS Agreement holds significant impacts on global trade. Imbued within
the construct of this agreement, is the power to shape international trade
policies and arguably, influence economic stability on a worldwide scale.
The
impacts of this agreement on global trade can be broadly categorised into
several key aspects:
- Encouragement of innovation and creativity: By providing better protection for intellectual property rights, the TRIPS Agreement fuels further innovation and creativity.
- Boosting foreign direct investment (FDI): By enforcing consistent, reliable and transparent IPR laws, the agreement attracts greater foreign direct investment.
- Providing a level playing field for trade: By enforcing standardized IPR protections, developing countries can compete fairly with their developed counterparts.
- Promoting technology transfer: Fosters an environment conducive for technology sharing, contributing to the economic growth of member countries.
How WTO TRIPS Protects Patents Internationally:
Within the global purview, the WTO TRIPS agreement safeguards patents in
several critical ways.
The following points shed light on the salient features of this
international patent protection:
- The TRIPS Agreement ensures that patents are available without discrimination concerning the place of invention, the field of technology, or the fact that products are imported or locally produced.
- It establishes minimum levels of protection that each government must give to the intellectual property of both its own nationals and nationals of other WTO member countries.
- It provides dispute settlement procedures that can be initiated if a country doesn't comply with the agreement. These proceedings can ultimately lead to trade sanctions being imposed against the offending country.
Criticisms of the TRIPS Agreement:
- The agreement has been criticized for potentially limiting access to affordable medicines in developing countries. This is particularly due to stringent patent protection and high drug prices.
- Some argue that the agreement disproportionately benefits developed countries with strong intellectual property industries. It hinders the development opportunities of developing nations.
- Some argue that the TRIPS Agreement restricts the ability of member countries to tailor their intellectual property laws to suit their specific developmental needs and priorities.
- Enforcement of intellectual property rights can be complex and costly, especially for developing countries. This leads to concerns about the effectiveness of enforcement measures.
Advantages of the TRIPS Agreement:
- Transparency in IP policy was brought to the world's attention.
- WIPO's existing international legal system, which was designed and controlled by them, was greatly enhanced by this agreement.
- Trade conflicts over intellectual property concerns were reduced by establishing a clear, rules-based framework for resolving disputes.
- It has aided in the acquisition and exercise of intellectual property rights, as well as providing a solid platform for the trade in knowledge products.
- In developing countries, the number of patent applications is increased.
Disadvantages of the TRIPS Agreement:
- TRIPS mandates high levels of patent protection.
- Fertilisers, insecticides, pharmaceutical items, and procedures were not protected by patents, resulting in low-cost food and drugs.
- Education and technology transfer were fostered by the lack of copyright protection for informational products.
- Jobs in the local imitative industries were lost.
- In general, increased prices resulted in significant deadweight losses, with minimal stimulation of local innovation.
- Traditional knowledge is not protected in any way.
Conclusion:
The Trade Related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement is an important
step forward for the protection of intellectual property throughout the world
when it was contracted into effect by GATT in 1994. The TRIPs provisions should
assist as the foundation for the creation of domestic intellectual property
legislation in member nations, as this is a suggestion of the TRIPs agreement.
The agreement's long-standing legacy lies in its evident efforts to mesh the
interests of creators and users with IP, for the sustainable growth of a world
that is conducive to sharing knowledge and economic prosperity.
References:
- https://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e/whatis_e/tif_e/agrm7_e.htm
- https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/trips_e/intel2_e.htm
- https://www.e-ir.info/2013/12/23/the-arguments-for-and-against-the-trips-agreement/
- https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/trips_e/tripfq_e.htm
- https://www.studysmarter.co.uk/explanations/law/international-and-humanitarian-law/trips/
- https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-11908-role-of-the-trips-agreement-and-its-scope-in-india.html
- https://www.abounaja.com/blogs/trips-agreement-of-1995
Please Drop Your Comments