Alternative Dispute Resolution is commonly known as ADR. This is a way to
resolve disputes without long trials. It saves both money and time. This is a
less formal and less stressful process than the regular trial courts. The
Alternative Dispute Resolution resolves matters of civil, family, commercial,
etc. except criminal matters. The person who resolves the matters is called an
arbitrator or mediator.
An arbitrator is a person appointed by the parties in
dispute with their conditions. If the parties are not pleased with the decision
of the arbitrator they are free to appeal in a court of law. For the
arbitration, the government has passed an act Arbitration and Conciliation Act
in 1996. The government has also established arbitral tribunals.
Different types of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Alternative Dispute Resolution has different types which include arbitration,
mediation, conciliation, negotiation, and lok adalat.
- Arbitration
Arbitration is a method of resolving conflicts between private parties outside
of the judicial system. An arbitrator renders a ruling or an award on the case
that is mostly binding on the parties. It is less formal than a trial, and
evidentiary rules are frequently eased.
- Conciliation
Conciliation is a non-binding procedure in which the parties to a dispute are
assisted by an impartial third party, in reaching a mutually satisfactory agreed
settlement. The parties have the option of accepting or rejecting the
suggestions of the conciliator. If both parties approve the conciliation
settlement document, it will be final and binding on both parties.
- Mediation
Mediation is another way of arbitration, the person known as a mediator sits
between the parties and assists them in negotiating and reaching a final
decision. The mediator strives to make it easier for the parties to communicate
openly so that they can reach a mutually agreeable resolution. The parties
retain control of the outcome in mediation.
- Negotiation
Negotiation is a non-binding procedure in which the parties to a dispute
communicate with each other without the involvement of a third party with the
goal of reaching a negotiated settlement.
- Lok Adalat
Lok Adalat, or People's Court, is an informal environment that encourages talks
in the presence of a judicial official. The decision of Lok Adalat is final and
it is regarded as a civil court judgement that is binding on the parties to the
dispute.
Importance of Alternative Dispute Resolution
In the last few decades, the pendency of cases in Indian Courts has increased.
There are more than three crore cases are pending in the Supreme Court, High
Courts, and Subordinate Courts. The Supreme Court has only 0.2 per cent of
pending cases while the High Courts have 13.8 percent of pending cases and the
most of all 86 percent of cases pending before the subordinate courts.
In the
last decade, there is a hike of 8.6 percent in the pendency of cases in all
courts of the country with the rise of 36 percent in the Supreme Court, 17
percent in the High Courts, and 7 percent in the Subordinate Courts.[i]
Alternative Dispute Resolution plays a very crucial role in providing justice to
the aggrieved parties. Before this parties had to wait for years to get justice.
But now with the Alternative Dispute Resolution excess to justice become very
easy and cheap. The Alternative Dispute Resolution helps to provide equal
justice and free legal aid to the people. This is a remedy to achieve Article
39A of the Directive Principle of the State Policy.[ii] Alternative Dispute
Resolution (ADR) is the most often used strategy and can be successful in many
cases. This endeavor is to reduce the pendency rate of cases in Indian courts.
Challenges
Despite so many benefits the Alternative Dispute Resolution is not actively used
to resolve the disputes. The main reason behind this is the lack of awareness.
People from rural or backward areas are not aware of the laws of arbitration and
their benefits. However, it is considered a part of litigation.
To match the
need for time the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 has been amended three
times so far in 2015, 2019, and 2021. In the latest amendment of 2021, the
change has been made that if the court found any evidence of fraud and coercion
related to the award of the arbitration the court can stay on the award.[iii] In
spite of the amendments, there are still many issues that need improvement.
Suggestions:
The object of the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is the settlement of the
matters outside the court. For the more effective working of the Alternative
Dispute Resolution, there is a need for a council where the parties can
explicitly challenge the arbitrator if he has not fulfilled the necessary
grounds. There should be different acts for arbitration, mediation, and
conciliation.
The government needs to increase the arbitration and conciliation centers across
India. Conduct many awareness projects in various areas of the country
specifically in the rural areas. So that people become aware of the benefits of
arbitration and consider it for the redressal of their disputes.
In subordinate courts, more of the pending cases are criminal. To reduce the
pendency rate, the government needs to include criminal cases in arbitration.
Conclusion:
Arbitration is a boon for the judiciary. India has millions of cases pending in
the Supreme Court, and High courts, and more than these in the district or
subordinate courts. Arbitration is the best way to resolve any dispute in an
easy way it is a fast and cheap manner. In this parties have the option to
present their terms and conditions and they choose the arbitrator or the
mediator of their choice.
But with the rise of the Alternative Dispute
Resolution, challenges relating to it restrain the easy growth and performance.
As a result, parties consider litigation over alternative redressal. Hence, it
is necessary to reflect on the issues and remove them by amending with better
solutions.
References:
-
https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-1678-alternative-dispute-resolution-adr-.html
- https://blog.ipleaders.in/challenges-arbitration-india/
End-Notes:
- https://prsindia.org/policy/vital-stats/pendency-cases-judiciary
- Constitution of India, 1950
- https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-arbitration-and-conciliation-amendment-bill-2021
Please Drop Your Comments