The Matter Of Legal Recognition Of Same Sex Marriages In India
Concepts like that of 'homosexuality' is considered a taboo in India,
especially considering the conservative nature of our society. This is not just
the state of affairs in our country, but in more than 70 nations around the
world, homosexuality has been criminalized resulting in pronouncement of either
capital punishment or lesser form of sentence to the observers. However, in
almost 20 countries it has been legalized as well, the Netherlands being the
very first state to have legalized same sex marriages and granting the couples
all the rights as have been to heterosexuals in 2001.
Apart from this, nations which have validated the same includes Canada, Mexico,
New Zealand, United States and many others. So, this essentially is an
international matter but transcending through national realms as well.
The traditionalistic nature of our Indian society in terms of maintaining a
status quo in the current gender norms (heterosexuality) could be regarded as an
asset to us derived from our customs. Heterosexuality is regarded as a
reflection of the highest form of human values in almost every country,
including ours.
However, we are living in progressive times where amendments in laws including
the norms needs to be made in order to keep ourselves abreast with the
developments and thought processes. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India is
currently applying its judicial mind and deliberating upon the matter of
granting legal recognition to same sex marriages which was first produced before
the court by petitioners with a plea to put a judicial assent to such
relationships.
The petitioners have contended that since section 377 of the Indian Penal Code,
which dealt with 'unnatural offences', has been decriminalized by the apex court
in the case titled as Navtej Singh Johar v Union Of India, 2018, by
declaring the same as unconstitutional being violative of Articles 14, 15 and 21
of the Constitution of India, then such marriages be also given a legally backed
nod.
The subject matter of granting or not granting legal recognition to same sex
marriages in India is a sensitive one and needs to be adjudged keeping into
consideration the current needs of the society as well as giving equal respect
and appreciation to every individual irrespective of their gender identity.
Therefore, a balanced approach needs to be adopted in this matter.
On the other side, if we look at it from the lense of international law, the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the major and paramount international
human rights instrument in the world which has inspired the formation and
adoption of other human rights conventions and Protocols intending to achieve
the goals of humanity; human dignity; equal rights and equal opportunities, aims
to establish 'a common standard of achievement for all people and all nations'.
Article 1 of this great document states that 'all human beings are born free and
equal in dignity and rights', along with this, the preamble of UDHR states that
'inherent dignity and equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human
family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world.' Since
India is a signatory to UDHR, which establishes a stage where equal treatment be
meted out to every individual irrespective of any possible differentiations,
therefore, reaching a just and fair decision both in the interests of our
society as well for the people who are an equal part of it is the need of the
hour.
Therefore, the matter of the legal recognition of same gender marriages in
India, presently placed before the court of law, is being judged by the most
competent and judicial minds of our nation and it is hoped by the society that
whatever judgement comes the same shall encourage the growth of a bright future
of our country.
Law Article in India
You May Like
Legal Question & Answers
Please Drop Your Comments