Sati Pratha: Widow Burning in India
Meaning Of Sati- Sati (Su-Thi Or Suttee) Is The Traditional Indian (Hindu)
Practice Of A Widow Immolating Herself On Her Husband's Funeral Pyre
Introduction
Indian society might have progressed and move forward but the social evil of
sati continues to hang around in Indian society. The recent shocking incident of
a seventy one year old woman performing sati in Chattisgarh (13th October 2008)
is an eye opener. The practice of sati has been a part of Indian society for
ages with its inception being traced to the time of the Gupta period.
Though sati is illegal and is highly condemned in Indian society, the act of
sati being performed in the 21st century has shocked people. Lalmati aged
seventy one, resident of Chechar village in the Raipur district in Chattisgarh,
had come to the funeral pyre of her husband Shivnandan Verma, dressed in a new
sari. When the husband's body had been almost burnt and the villagers were about
to leave, Lalmati jumped into the pyre and was reduced to ashes in moments (The
Hindustan ,newspaper, Lucknow, India, editorial ,17 October 2008 ).
It is yet not known whether Lalmati chose to do this voluntarily or was pushed
by someone. A police case has been registered and investigation is ongoing. But
the incident is a glaring example of how such incidents continue to occur in
rural India.
Sati was never widespread, and it has been illegal since 1829, but a few cases
of sati still occur in India every year. In choosing to die with her husband, a
woman gains great merit and power and is thought to bring kudos to her husband's
patrilineage and to others who honour her. Thus, through her meritorious death,
a widow avoids disdain and achieves
glory, not only for herself, but for all of her kin as well In September 1987,
18-year-old Roop Kanwar, a young widow (she was married for just 8 months ) of
Rajasthan was forced to commit sati after the death of her husband. Many litres
of ghee (cooking butter) were poured on her as she burnt to death on her
husband's funeral pyre. People who assisted her in suicide were arrested. But
Roop Kanwar is idolized and has attained the status of a deity; a temple was
built for her.
In October 1996, the Indian Court upholds the suicide as a social tradition and
acquitted all 38 defendants who assisted Roop Kanwar. Another incident was the
case of Kuttu Bai, a 65 year widow committed sati in the state of Madhya Pradesh
in August 2002 , another was Vidyawati a 35-year-old woman committed Sati by
jumping into the blazing funeral pyre of her husband in the year 2006 in Utter
Pradesh, Janakrani (40years old) was burnt to death on the funeral pyre of her
husband in Sager District of Madhya Pradesh in August 2006 and very recently one
Lalmati (71 years old) of Chatisgarh has committed sati in October 2008.
In some regions of India, women are still treated as appendages to their
husbands, and are expected to either follow their husbands into death or to
remain chaste throughout their widowhood. Social pressures to commit sati remain
strong in certain areas of India.
But now a days the people are being aware of all the rights and also the
condition of women is improving and it also can be improved when all the people
understand and help the women who are still facing problems in some regions of
India
Religious Aspect:
In ancient Hindu law, stridharma (dharma signifies one's duty, responsibility,
or moral responsibility) is the dharma of women. Stridharma for women entails
devotion to one's husband, a woman's husband is a sort of God and, in fact, the
Sanskrit word for
"husband" - "Swaami" - literally means "Lord and Master". He is essentially her
"lord" for the very meaning of the word husband (Pati) means both husband and
lord. In view of that, what chance does a woman have? The ideal wife is one
whose sole joy in life is to satisfy her husband.
Her only concern is to perform properly any of the services demanded by her
husband. Such a woman is attached to her husband even after he has died. Total
subservience is enjoined and the ultimate expression of such complete marital
devotion was expressed in sati. Although many widows are treated less harshly
today they still face discrimination and neglect. In some corners of this
strange and complex land, that act of murdering widows is a tradition.
Economic And Political Aspects:
Insofar as the community is concerned, there is and economic gain to be made
from the commercialisation of a sati and the worship surrounding her death (Jethmalani,
Widows, Abandoned and Destitute Women, 46; ILHR Mar. 1991; p72). The latter
practice is illustrated by Roop Kanwar's story. The proponents of sati glorified
her sacrifice by
having town celebrations and by constructing a temple in her honour, without
interference from the authorities. In 1990, 400 people attended a celebration of
her death, even though the celebration was banned. An article in Women, Law and
Development-Action for Change, points out that the region where this incident
occurred is a fairly "modern" one, where the literacy rate is relatively high.
The Indian government has dropped attempts to strengthen the anti-Sati law, more
than 20 years after it was first enacted (The Times of India, 23 April 2008).The
proposed legislation recommended that coercing a woman to commit sati be made a
non-bailable offence.
The women and child development ministry said the amendments have been dropped
following political pressure. Some influential persons in the ruling party as
well as politicians from certain states had actually been actively campaigning
and lobbying against tougher laws for those inciting sati.
One of the person who has opposed the law is a minister in the present UPA
government, is not keen on stopping or deterring the practice of sati. That may
be because Jhunjhunu (Rajasthan), his constituency, is famous for its Rani Sati
temple, a big tourist attraction for hundreds of thousands of devotees, and
obviously an important economic engine for his constituency
The Historical Background
Ibn Batuta, an Arab traveler (1333 A.D.) observed that sati was considered
praiseworthy by the Hindus, without however being obligatory. Historically,
efforts to prevent sati by formal means existed even before the Moghul rulers
came to power. Under the Delhi Sultanates (Alauddin Khilji, 1294-1316 and
Muhammad bin Tughlaq, 1325-1351) permission had to be sought prior for sati to
be committed. In time this check against compulsion became a mere formality.
In any case Hindu women from royal families continued to burn unchecked (Mahajan,
V.D, History of Medieval India, S.Chand, N.Delhi). Humayun(1530-1540 ) tried to
prevent sati, but eventually withdrew a royal fiat against it. Akbar ( 1556
-1606) insisted that no woman could commit sati without the
specific permission of his Kotwals ( police officers in charge of police
station) ). They were instructed to delay the woman's decision for as long as
possible. Pensions, gifts and rehabilitative help were offered to the potential
someone who might commit sati to wean her away from committing the Act.
Children were strictly forbidden from the practice. The later Mughals continued
to put obstacles in the way but the practice carried on in the areas outside
Agra. In their own sphere of influence the Portuguese, Dutch and French banned
sati but efforts to stamp out sati were formalised only under Lord William
Bentinck after 1829(Anne E. Carr, Mary Stewart Van Leeuwen, Religion, Feminism,
and the Family, Westminster John Knox Press,1996 ).
British Regulation
The British were by no means certain of their approach to the custom no matter
how abhorrent they found it. Following Mughal example, for a while they tried to
regulate it by requiring that it be carried out in the presence of their
officials and strictly according to custom. Perhaps Bentinck was spurred on to
legislation by the unacceptable rise in sati in his province, Bengal (Sarkar,
Jadunath , A History of Jaipur, Orient Longmanc 1984). In
the 10 years between 1815 and 1825, the figure had doubled to 639 deaths by
burning (Binita Mehta, Widows, Pariahs, and Bayadères: India As Spectacle
Published by Bucknell University Press 2002 ). He was certainly under pressure
from the constant entreaties of missionaries and encouraged to action by the sea
change being wrought amongst an influential section of Hindus led by Raja Ram
Mohan Roy's Brahmo Samaj.
Lord William Bentinck passed the Sati Regulation, XVII of 1827 on 4 December
after assuming the governorship of Bengal. The regulation was clear, concise and
unequivocal in its condemnation of Sati, declaring it illegal and punishable by
the criminal courts (C. A. Bayly, General Editor, The Raj: India and the British
1600-1947.
London: National Portrait Gallery Publications 1990). It made zamindars
(landlords), petty land owners, local agents and officers in charge of revenue
collection especially accountable for immediate communication to the officers of
their nearest police station of any intended sacrifice of the nature described.
In case of willful neglect the responsible officer was liable to a fine of
Rs.200 or 6 months in jail for default
The Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act 1987:
The Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act 1987, substituted the various
legislation that had been operative in different parts of the country with a
central law that sought not only to prevent and punish the commission of the act
itself, but also to make any glorification of the act of sati an offence.
There are provisions in the Act to take action against exploitation of such
criminal occurrences either for financial or political purposes. Specifically,
the Act makes a criminal offence, equivalent to murder, the abetment or
encouragement of a Sati or an attempted Sati. Such action is liable to sentence
of death or life imprisonment, with an appropriate fine (S-4(1))
Sati means the burning or burying alive of any widow along with the body of her
deceased husband or any other relative or with anything or article associated
with husband or such relative, or any woman along with the body of any of her
relatives. Such burning or burying may either be voluntary or otherwise. (s 2
(1) (c))
The person committing sati is herself is liable to prosecution for attempted
suicide, the Penalty being a year's imprisonment with a fine(s3). Glorification
of sati is defined as the observation of any ceremonies or the taking out of
processions in connection with the incidence or practice of sati; the support,
justification or propagation of the practice; or the arrangement of or
participation of any function to eulogies a person committing sati; the creation
of a trust or fund or collection of donations for the purpose of a temple or any
other structure with a view to perpetuate or honour the memory of a person
committing sati; or the performance of any ceremony for the same purpose (s 2
(1) (b)).
Under the Act, all temples dedicated to such practice or persons are to be
removed (s 7). The penalty for glorification of Sati is imprisonment from 1 to 7
years, a fine of Rs. 5,000- to Rs.30,000-and the confiscation of all assets
collected in the name of Sati (s 5). Special Courts, equivalent to sessions
courts, are to be convened for the trial of offences under this Act with judges
of equal powers (s 9).
All such cases are to be tried without delay, there being required reasons to be
furnished if trials are adjourned beyond the next day (s 12 (3)). The onus of
proof of innocence rests with the accused (s 16). No person who had abetted the
commission of sati may inherit the estate, either whole or even in part, of the
deceased woman (s 18)
Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women
CEDAW:
Violence against women is a global problem. Violence against women manifests
itself as Rape, molestation, stripping, kidnapping and abduction, domestic
violence including wife battery, dowry harassment, dowry death, cruelty to women
driving them to commit
suicide or other forms of murder like female foeticide and sati. A Convention on
the Elimination Of All forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) was adopted
by the General Assembly of the United Nations on December 18, 1979. The
Convention
came into force in the year 1981. Consisting of a preamble and 30 articles, it
defines what constitutes discrimination against women and sets up an agenda for
national action to end such discrimination. India has ratified the U.N.
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW)
a few years ago.
Definition of "Discrimination against Women":
Although the International Bill of Human Rights laid down a comprehensive set of
rights to which all persons, including women are entitled, additional means for
protecting the human rights of women were considered as necessary because the
mere fact of their 'humanity' has not been sufficient to guarantee women the
protection of their rights. The
preamble to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination
against Women explains that, despite the existence of other instruments, women
still do not have equal rights with men. Discrimination against Women continues
to exist in every society.
Article 1 of the CEDAW defines the term 'Discrimination Against Women' as any
distinction, exclusion or restriction made on the basis of sex which has the
effect or purpose of impairing or nullifying the recognition, enjoyment or
exercise by women, irrespective of their marital status, on the basis of
equality of men and women, of humans rights and fundamental freedoms in the
political, economic, social, cultural, civil or any other field.
Conclusion
It is most unfortunate the present Indian Government has dropped the move for a
stringent sati laws under the pressure of her own cabinet ministers. In any
other civilized society, this would be called murder but still in India the act
of murdering widows is traditional rituals. It is astonished that country's
inability to cross political and Fundamentalist barriers in straightforward and
non-confusing matters of human rights such as dowry and Sati.
India is a signatory of the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, meaning
that, along with other issues, slavery is prohibited by law, and yet, in the
form of widows, there are millions of slaves existing in India today - innocent
victims who have no way of defending themselves - and no longer an "escape"
through "sati" - because society has come to accept their miserable plight as --
"all part of our Tradition and Culture ". For those who abuse widows, it is a
Vulture's culture.
It would seem that males have not only used their extra physical strength to
dominate women, but also their use of religion as a very powerful weapon.
Though, the provisions of the Sati Act, CEDAW, and Optional Protocol must be
enforced in its true spirit, it appears that certain amendments in Sati Act are
also required as already discussed above .Social awakening is need of the hour.
Literacy among the women is necessary. Not only this, the women also must come
forward to achieve the
goal. Only then, ray of hope to save the lives of the innocent women can be
seen. The Indian Constitution is actually far more liberal than those of many
nations which have been governed by "democratic" systems for many years. India
has produced a present female President, a female Prime Minister, female
Governors, female Chief Ministers, High Court judges, university professors,
surgeons, airline and Air-Force fighter pilots, to name only a few areas where
women have been able to claim an equal place with the male species, however, in
general, and especially when it comes to women of "lower" (yet with equal
potential ) rank in society - those of "low" caste communities -women have a
long way to go to reach the full human potential for which they were ordained.
Law Article in India
You May Like
Legal Question & Answers
Please Drop Your Comments