Talaq is an arabic word which means' freeing or undoing the knot'it signifies
the dissolution of marriage when a Muslim man can severe all marital ties with
his wife. Talaq in its original sense means repudiation, or rejection, but under
Muslim law, it means a release from the marriage tie. It is a genric term from
all types of divorce but it was particularly applied to repudiation by or on
behalf of husband.
Forms of Talaq under Myslim law
First one is Talaq -us- sunnat
This Talaq means which is sanctioned by sunnat Or according to the traditions
laid down by Prophet (pbuh)
These can be of two types
Talaq Ahsan
The most appropriate method of divorce. In this type of Talaq there are certain
requirements which have to be fulfilled.
The husband must make a single pronouncement of divorce
This pronouncement must make during tuhr (period between menstruation)
The husband must abstain from sexual intercourse for the period of Iddat.
In this form of Talaq pronouncement is revocable during Iddat. Such revocation
either express words or implied. Cohabitation is an implied revocation. After
the expiration of Iddat it becomes irrevocable.
Talaq Hasan... This is also proper method but not the most proper method. The
requirements of this form is
There are three pronouncements of Talaq made during sucessive tuhrs
There must be abstinence from sexual intercourse for the period of Iddat.
Talaq Ul BIddat nd Triple Talaq
As the name suggest "Biddah means an innovation that has no roots in the
traditional practice (Sunnah Of The Prophet)
Talaq ul BIddat is an instant nd irrevocable divorce. It is mostly banned in
many Muslim nations. In India it was only recognized by sunni Muslim . It was
held unconstitutional by supreme court in Shayra Bano v/s Union Of India.
Supreme court describes it as "manifestly arbitrary " And said that it allows a
man to breakdown a marriage whimsically and capriciously.
If we consider the Quranic view on divorce. Quran is incredibly explicit about
divorce . It leans more towards safeguard the marriage rather than dissolving it
abruptly.
In Surah e Talaq
Allah says:
When you intend to divorce women, than divorce them with concern for their
waiting period, and count it accurately. And fear Allah your Lord.
Do not force them out of their homes nor should they leave unless they commit a
blatant misconduct. These are the limits set by Allah. And whoever transgresses
Allah's limits has truly wronged his own soul.
It is concluded from Qurans view that Talaq is discouraged by Quran also but it
is available for Muslim in certain situations. The Islamic scriptures demands
time and patience in executing a divorce in the hope of continuing the Union
knowing that the couple is bound to have differences.
Triple Talaq
First of all it is banned in most of the Muslim countries and it is considered
as most disapproved form of Talaq but yet recognised. Islamic jurists considered
it as an innovation within the fold of shariat. Some jurist considered it bIddat
as it has no sanction of holy Quran nor the approval of prophet (pbuh).
It was not in practice during lifetime of prophet (pbuh) nor during the time of
first caliph Abu Bakr.
It was permitted by second caliph Hazrat umar on account of certain peculiar
situations.
When the Arabs conquered persia syria and egypt and they found women there much
more better in appearance as compared to Arabian women's and hence they wanted
to marry them. But the Egyptian and Syrian Women insisted that in order to marry
them, they should divorce to their existing wives instantaneously by pronouncing
three divorce in one sitting.
The condition was not acceptable to Arabs as they knew divorce was only
permissible only twice in two tuhr periods and it's reputation at one sitting is
Unaslamic and void and shall not be effective. In this way, they could not only
marry these women but also retain their existing wives.
The fact was reported to the second caliph Hazrat Umar the caliph then in order
to prevent the misuse of the religion by the unscrupulous husbands decreed that
even repetition of the word Talaq, Talaq, Talaq at one sitting would dissolve
the marriage irrevocably.
It was however a mere administrative measure of caliph umar to meet an emergency
situation and not to make it a law permanently. But unfortunately the Hanafi
jurists later on at the strength of this instant administrative order of second
caliph declared this form of divorce valid and also pave religious sanctions to
it.
Imam Abu Hanifa Holds that three Pronouncement shall amount to three separate
divorce and they shall result in a Mughallazah Divorce. Though it is sinful and
bad in theology but at the same time good in law.
Imam Malik regarding effectiveness of Triple divorce makes a distinction between
various expressions used in the Prouncenment of divorce . A husband in the
process of Prouncenment of divorce may use the word as when he says, I divorce
you divorce you divorce you. He may, on the other hand not use it as when he
says , "I divorce you, I divorce you, I divorce you " The Prouncenment in the
former case shall amount to three divorces or Mughallazah Or irrevocable final
divorce but in the latter case the matter can according to Imam Malik, be
considered from the following two aspects
- When the husband merely repeats the word ' you are divorced "three times
or as when he says " You are divorced, divorced, divorced. In such a case if
husband explains that he had repeated the words three times merely to
emphasie the divorce then his explanation that he had repeated the divorce
to make it more emphatic would not be accepted.
- If a husband did not repeat the divorce to lay emphasis but intended
three divorce or repeated the divorce without any intention at all then
three divorces shall be affected. If the husband pronounces three divorces
on different occasions but in the same tuhr, then same result shall follow.
..Judicial trend of Triple Talaq in India...
In the British India as well as independent India all the courts are declaring
triple Talaq Prouncenments of divorce in one sitting as lawfull and effective.
The common pharse used by courts at that Talaq ul bIddat or triple Talaq is good
in law though but bad in thelogy. The triple divorce is recognised and endorsed
by the indian judiciary.
The Bombay highcourt in
Sara Bai v/s Rabia Bai 'recognised triple divorce
on irrevocable footing.
The calcutta High Court in
Fulchand vs Nazib Ali held that presence or
absence of wife makes no difference so far as effectiveness of triple divorce is
concerned.
Justice Venkta subha Rao observed:
"We therefore hold that it is not necessary for the wife to be present when the
Talaq is pronounced. Triple divorce to be effective, it is imperative that it
should be addressed to the wife in particular sense. "
The triple divorce Pronounced at one time was condemned by jammu and Kashmir
highcourt but nevertheless treated it effective and expressed helplessness
regarding the bringing of any change by judicial interpretation.
The present scenario if triple Talaqs validity can be traced from the recent
judgement of supreme court in shayra bano vs union of India in which courts
struck down this arbitrary practice unconstitutional and declared void.
It was challenged on the grounds of Article 14 , 15 , 21.
In another case sumaila vs Aqil ahmed where husband divorced his wife by single
Prouncenment was held by Allahabad highcourt as wrongfull and violative of
Article 14.
Conclusion
Needless to say Talaq ul bIddat has devastated the lives of many women's and
childrens. Depreived of any opportunity for settlement, this mode of divorce has
been subject to certain criticism in several Muslim countries and have brought
about reform through codification.
Countries like Pakistan turkey tunsia syria iraq iran Malaysia have either
reformed this law completely or brought strict preventive measures in this area.
In India
Parliament passed the Triple Talaq law also referred to as protection of rights
on marriage Bill, 2019 to make instant triple Talaq a criminal offence.
The law also makes triple Talaq non bailabe and cognizable offence.
The supreme court considered triple Talaq unconstitutional as it is against
gender law and against the principle of equality as a fundamental right as per
Constitution and it is not fundamental to the faith of islam.
It mostly favours the men and it pavs an easy way to break marital tie.
India is a diverse country of culture and religion no doubt . Each community
have their personal practices and personal religious laws which governs their
family matters.
However, a fine balancing has to be done between the right to practice any
religion and social justice..
Divorce is Discouraged by Allah and prophet (pbub).
Written By: Rashad Amin Malik, LLB 3rd Sem University Of Jammu
Please Drop Your Comments