Trafficking means a trade which is illegal. Human trafficking is carrying out
a trade on humans. Humans are trafficked for the purpose of sexual slavery,
commercial sexual exploitation, extraction of organs or tissues, forced
marriage, forced labor or domestic servitude. Human trafficking after drugs and
the arms trade is the third largest organized crime across the world.
Introduction
Human trafficking across the world is mainly done for sexual exploitation where
women and children turn as victims to it. Human trafficking is done for a number
of purposes but sadly in our country the act which exists against human
trafficking is Immoral Trafficking Prevention Act (ITPA) and it only combats
against the human trafficking if it is done for the purpose of sexual
exploitation.
So the legal provisions relating to human trafficking as whole must be
strengthened in order to prevent human trafficking in India. Human trafficking
leads to violation of human rights of the individuals and also they are
subjected to re-victimization. The laws for human trafficking must be
strengthened that it meets all the requirements for preventing human
trafficking.
Relationship between Human Trafficking and Fundamental Rights:
Fundamental Rights as provided under part III of Indian Constitution have
unequivocally claimed the wrongness of human trafficking in terms of morality
and legality both. There is a well-established link between Human Rights,
Fundamental Rights, and Human Trafficking. Indian Constitution recognizes the
fundamental right of non-discrimination, equality, education, constitutional
remedies, freedom of speech and expression that includes right of free movement,
right to life and liberty, etc.
Article 23[4] talks about the prohibition of traffic in human beings and forced
labor and provides its citizens altogether a right against trafficking. And if
there have been no separate article or fundamental right for prohibition for
human trafficking it would have been a violation of fundamental rights by the
virtue of the golden triangle of fundamental rights that is constituted by
Article 14, 19 and 21.
Dealing further with this, Article 19 protects certain rights regarding freedom
of speech and expression that protects the right to move freely throughout the
territory of India under sub-clause (d). It is one of the directly related
rights and there are numerous rights that are going to be affected or violated
as of right of practicing the profession of carrying business, it is more of a
consequence of human trafficking.
Article 21 protects the very Right to Life and Liberty of people in India, both
citizens, and non-citizens. Referring to the interpretation made in the case of
Kharak Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh[5] It was stated:
life is not a mere animal existence and there is more to it. Hence humans can
not be sold like commodities or animals hampering their Right to life.
As very rightly said in the case of Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India[6], right
to life embodied in Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, is not merely a
physical right but it also includes within its ambit, the right to live with
human dignity. And hence dignity cannot be hampered by any act of contractual
human dealing.
Reasons For Human Trafficking
There are many reasons for human trafficking. They are determined by political,
economic and cultural factors. Trafficking in persons is according to the
doctrine of supply and demand. Firstly, there are certain factors in the country
such as need of employment, poverty, social conditions, instances of armed or
war conflicts lack of political and economic stability, lack of proper access to
education and information etc. Secondly, in developed and wealthy countries
there is demand for inexpensive products, cheap labour and low priced services.
The organized crime groups have found an opportunity for making huge profits by
connecting the supply and demand that by clubbing the first and the second
instances. These reasons lead to increased migration but a condition of
restricted migration due to numerous policies of the State. People use smuggling
channels for human trafficking exposing themselves to exploitation, deceit,
violence and abuse.
Consequences Of Human Trafficking
The victims in the process of trafficking in persons are abused and exploited in
certain conditions which may result in short term and long term minor and severe
psychological and physical attacks, diseases especially sexually transmitted
diseases or HIV viruses. This condition can even lead to the permanent
disability and death.
The direct consequences of human trafficking are aggression, depression,
disorientation, alienation and difficulties in concentration. Many studies have
shown that injuries and traumas acquired during the process of trafficking can
last for a long period even after the person has become free from exploitation
and this mainly occurs when the victim is not given with proper care and
counsel.
Even the rehabilitation process for the victims cannot be guaranteed for a
certain result. Although the victims are brought out from the physical problems,
the trauma and the psychological problems does not allow the victim to totally
recover from the consequences. Some of the victims find it difficult to adapt to
the normal lives that they previously carried out.
The sad part about the victims of human trafficking is that the rights of the
victims are violated even after they come out from the status of exploitation.
In many cases they face re-victimization. In many of the countries the
protection provided to the trafficked persons is directly conditioned by their
willingness to cooperate with the competent authorities. But these conditional
protection is contrary to the full access and protection of human rights and the
use of trafficked persons as an instrument in the criminal proceedings are not
allowed.
Legal Frameworks To Counter Human Trafficking In India
Indian Penal Code 1860:
Interestingly the Indian Penal Code which came into existence in 1860 addresses
the problem of human trafficking in human beings. It is addressed in Section 370
and 370 A of the Indian Penal Code. It prohibited trafficking of women and girls
and prescribed ruthless punishments for the criminals. It lays down that anyone
who buys or sells the person under the age of 18 years for the purpose of
prostitution and for sexual exploitation and for other immoral purposes shall be
liable to imprisonment for up to 10 years and also be liable to fine.
It also recognizes cross border trafficking into prostitution and whoever
imports into India from any country outside India any girl under the age of
twenty one years with the intent that she may be, or knowing it to be likely
that she will be, forced or seduced to illicit intercourse with another person
shall be punishable with imprisonment which may extend to ten years and shall
also be liable to fine.[3]
Constitution of India
The Indian Constitution of India prohibits trafficking in persons and guarantees
many of the internationally acknowledged various human rights norms such as the
right to life and personal liberty, the right to equality, right to freedom, the
right to constitutional remedies. The right to be free from exploitation is also
assured as one of the fundamental rights of any person living in India.[4]
The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000
According to this Act there is no difference between a minor and a child. All
the persons under the age of eighteen years are considered children. A child who
is a child in need of care and protection (National Legal Research Desk 2016).
The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act,
1989
Many victims of trafficking belong to marginalized groups. Traffickers target
only such area which is backward in social and literacy sense. This gives an
additional tool to safeguard women and young girls belonging to scheduled Caste
and scheduled Tribes and also to create a greater burden on the trafficker or
offender to prove his lack of connivance in the matter
If the offender has the knowledge that victim belongs to these communities then
this act can be effectively used to counter the offence of trafficking. Section
3 of this act deals with atrocities committed against people belonging to
Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes. It covers some forms of trafficking such
as forced or bonded labors and sexual exploitation of women. A minimum
punishment of ix months is provided which may extend to five years if the
offence is covered under section 3.
Immoral Traffic Prevention Act 1986
The government of India ratified the International Convention for the
Suppression of Immoral Traffic in persons and the exploitation of the
Prostitution of others in 1950. As a consequence of this ratification of the
convention the Government of India passed the Suppression of Immoral Traffic in
Women and Girls Act (SITA) in the year 1956. In the year 1986 the act was
further amended and changed which was known as the Immoral Traffic Prevention
Act, 1986 (PITA).
Conclusion
The laws for human trafficking must be strengthened that it meets all the
requirements for preventing human trafficking. People who are in poverty line
across the country must be made aware about human trafficking and its
consequences in order to prevent them from becoming victims. Many national and
international seminars and conferences can be conducted across the country so
that the general people and the government can join hands to prevent human
trafficking.
The vulnerable sections of the society must be protected by the Government so
that they don't fall as victims to human trafficking. The victims of the human
trafficking are only the persons from below poverty line so the offence of human
trafficking can be greatly prevented if the Government helps the poor sections
of the society and provides them with adequate education and employment.
References:
- Prof. N.V. Paranjape, Criminology, Penology Victimology, Central Law
Publications, 17th Edition
- Vimal Vidushy, Human Trafficking in India, International Journal of
Applied Research, 2016.
- Prof. S.N Mishra, Indian Penal Code, Central law Publications Human
Trafficking, available at https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/human-trafficking/what-is-human-trafficking.html
(last visited on april 9th, 2020)
- Janani. G.S , Dr. S.Pandiaraj, HUMAN TRAFFICKING IN INDIA, International
Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics 44 (2018)
- The Constitution of India
- AIR 1963 SC 1295
- 1978 SCR (2) 621
Written By: Rahul Khokhar
Please Drop Your Comments