VIP Darshan: A Violation Of Articles 14 And 21
India, a land of immense cultural heritage and spiritual richness, is home to
over 1.4 billion people who take immense pride in their tradition and religious
beliefs. India is a secular nation with people worshipping different gods as per
their beliefs and the same is been provided under Article 25 of the Indian
Constitution which guarantees the right to conscience, practice and profess
religion. For Indians religion is not merely a personal practice but an
intrinsic part of their daily lives, influencing festivals, rituals and even
social norms.
The confluence of diverse religious practices and philosophies has profoundly
shaped the country's ethos, making it a beacon of faith and devotion. In India,
VIP's or any authoritative Indian is treated very differently from the rest of
the citizens in a public place which some or the other way is discriminative
towards the citizens. Article 15 and 21 of the Indian Constitution talks about
the prohibition of discrimination and right to life and personal liberty
respectively. This article would particularly focus upon the violation of
article 15 and 21 with respect to the VIP darshans being practiced across every
temple.
VIP Darshan: A Practice of Discrimination
Temples such as Kashi Vishwanath, Vaishnodevi are some of the very famous
temples in India which are visited by more than lakhs of people each month.
These lakhs of people wait for hours in long queues every day just to get a
glimpse of their God/Goddess for even less than a minute but this isn't the case
with the privileged ones. They don't have to wait in long queues, they have
their special entries for the darshan known as VIP darshan, in which one will be
getting to see the glimpse of their God/Goddess for longer time as compared to
the common people standing in long queues for hours.
By granting privileged access to individuals based upon wealth, social status or
political influence, temple create a hierarchy that contradicts the inclusive
ethos of religious worship. This preferential treatment marginalizes ordinary
devotees, who are often left waiting for hours in long queues while others
bypass these lines due to their perceived importance.
Such practices disproportionately affect economically weaker sections and those
who lack social or political clout, perpetuating inequality within sacred spaces
that should ideally promote unity and humility. This discrimination is
particularly stark in places of worship, where the divine is believed to be
accessible to all, irrespective of their social or financial standings.
Moreover, VIP entries often disrupt the smooth flow of temple activities,
creating logistic challenges and further inconveniencing regular devotees.
How Article 14 Enshrines Equality in Worship
Article 14 of the Indian Constitution guarantees that all individuals are equal
before the law and are entitled to equal protection of law. This fundamental
right permeates all facets of public places, including religious practices. In
the context of temple worship, Article 14 guarantees each and every devotee
irrespective of their socio-economic status, has an equal opportunity to access
and participate in religious rituals. Temples, as public institutions are duty
bound to uphold this constitutional mandate and provide equality to all the
worshippers.
VIP darshan at temples violates the right guaranteed under Article 14 by
creating a class-based hierarchy among the devotees within a space that should
ideally promote spiritual equality. This practice favors some individuals
sidelining the majority which degrades the vision of Article 14 as enshrined
under the Indian Constitution. This is a clear discrimination based upon one's
political influence, financial condition and social status.
Every devotee is treated equally by the God irrespective of its socio-economic
condition, then who are we to discriminate among them in a place devoted to God?
Thus, VIP darshan clearly goes against the vision of Article 14 and it should be
stopped in a religious place where equality should be promoted.
Dignity and Liberty Under Article 21: A Devotees Right
Article 21 of the Indian Constitution guarantees the right to life and personal
liberties, which includes right to live with dignity. Dignity in literal sense
means the importance and value that a person has, that makes other people
respect them or makes them respect themselves. The concept of dignity is central
to a devotees experience in a place of worship where ideally everyone should be
treated with dignity and equality. However, giving preferential treatment to
selected individuals violates the principle of Article 21 by creating an
atmosphere of exclusion and subjugation. When common devotees are given
secondary treatment in a place of worship where every devotee is equal before
God, dignity is said to be compromised.
Moreover, the liberty to worship freely and without discrimination is intrinsic
to the right of personal liberty. The havoc created; delay caused due to VIP
darshan disrupts the personal liberty of common devotees in the said place of
worship. Article 21 thus demands that temples provide an environment where every
individual dignity and liberty are upheld, ensuring that all devotees can
worship freely and equally without interference or discrimination.
Judicial Observation
A petition was filed in Supreme Court challenging the rising practice of "VIP
darshan" and "paid darshan" across every temple in India by Vijay
Kishor Goswami. Recently, a division bench comprising Justice Sanjiv Khanna and
Justice P.V. Sanjay Kumar has decided to hear the said petition and the bench
feels that the issue needs to be examined deeply. It would be interesting to
watch the further proceedings and the understanding of the court in the said
filed petition.
Conclusion
The word 'VIP: Very Important Person' is nowhere defined in law as a term.
Hence, the legality of it can be question of law before the Hon'ble Court. This
practice discriminates against the common devotees and goes against the
principles of Article 14 and 21 which guarantees the right to equality and right
to live with dignity respectively. It is the right of each and every individual
to be treated equally and with dignity in a public place such as a worship place
i.e. temples. It would further be clarified by the Supreme Court when it will be
hearing the petition filed challenging the practice of VIP darshan and paid
darshan. Let's keep a close look onto the said petition proceedings!
Share this Article
You May Like
Comments