Abstract
In this paper the author has interpreted the various definitional aspects of
word “DRUGâ€. Author have made an attempt to trace out the legal definition for
the term “DRUG†through different statute, legislation, case laws but, author
found that they are lacking this. In this paper, I will try to focus upon
delivering the possible definition of drug, consequences of non defining of
“Drug†and its possible solutions.
After going through my study materials I found out that existing laws are trying
to define what is drug? But, they failed. They speaks about component, uses,
different types of drug (cannabis, coca, controlled substances, manufactured
drug, medicinal cannabis, narcotic drug, opium, opium derivates, opium poppy,
poppy straw, psychotropic substance, cosmetic, adulterated drug, spurious drug,
misbranded cosmetics, misbranded drug, dangerous drug, etc but they does not
define specifically word ‘drug'.
Definition of Drug
Being a British Colony, Indian Laws are influenced with Common Law system and
drug is not a new concept.[3]It has its origin from old French word ‘DROUGUE', possibly
deriving later into "droge-vate" from Middle Dutch meaning "dry barrels",
referring to medicinal plants preserved in that. Use of drug is also not a new
concept; our ancestors used it through different way. With the development of
society and use of drugs in society need of new laws to deal with this concept
arose. Herbal cannabis, Opium, Ganja, Bhang are traditional drug which were used
by Indian for decades. Religious sentimental are also attached with certain
drugs.[4]
There are two main way to define word drug. First, a distinction may
be drawn between medicines, which are medically sanctioned psychoactive
substances used for clinical purpose, and drug, which are controlled substances
whose use is not sanctioned either by law or by medical practitioner. Secondly,
the classifications according to their pharmalogical make up and attributed
psychoactive effect. However, the definition of drug and the distinction between
drugs, substances and medicines are disputed.
Drugs were classified in four
categories such as:
(i) Stimulated (drug which speed up the central nervous
system);
(ii) Depressants (drugs which slow down the function of the central
nervous system);
(iii) Hallucinogens (drug that distort the senses) and
(iv)
Deliriums (as anaesthetics have effect upon both mind and body).
Other
categories are such as Hard and Soft Drug, HARD drug means which are likely to
result in addiction. SOFT drug are primarily relate to cannabis.
Indian Legislature
Statutory control over drug is exercised in India through a number of Central
and State enactments. The Principal Central Act, namely, the Opium Act, 1857,
the Opium Act 1878, Dangerous Drug Act, 1930, the Drug and Cosmetic Act
1940,[5]Article 47 of the Constitution of India 1950, the NDPS Act 1985, the
PITNDPS Act, 1988, and two International Convention on Narcotic Drug and
Psychotropic Substances 1961 and 1971 of which India is signatory.
This paper will discuss about definitional part of legislation. The Opium Act
1857 was consolidated and amended the law relating to cultivation of poppy and
the manufacture of opium. This Act focused only upon opium rather than drug. So
drug was not defined in this act. New legislation The Opium Act, 1878 in which
section 3 deals with definition part. It defines ‘Opium', and this Act fails to
define word ‘Drug'. India participated in the Second International Opium
Conference, which was convoked in accordance with the resolution of the Assembly
of the League of Nations, dated the 27th day of September, 1923, met at Geneva
on the 17th day of November, 1924, and on the 19th day of February, 1925,
adopted the Convention relating to Dangerous Drugs. India was a State signatory
to the said Geneva Convention. India adopted the Dangerous Drug Act, 1930. This
act defines two terms under section 2[6].It is first time the word ‘dangerous
and manufactured'drug was defined. Initially the Drugs Act 1940 was passed by
Indian parliament and an amendment in 1962 was done and word ‘cosmetic' was also
added. And now it became The Drugs and Cosmetic Act, 1940. This Act was passed
to regulate the impact, manufacture, distribution and sale of drugs and
cosmetic. Section 3(aaa) of the Act 1940 defines word[7]“Cosmetic†and section
3(b) defines word[8]“Drugâ€. Though the words “Drug†got its definitional
provision, it says what ‘includes'. So medicines, substances and devices are
covered under drug. Now question is that whether this is complete definition? It
does not give any element by which we can say that these elements will be called
drug[9].
The definition of drug in section 3 of the Drugs Act, 1940, is comprehensive
enough to take in not only medicines but also substances intended to be used for
in the treatment of diseases of human being or animals. This artificial
definition introduces a distinction between medicine and substances which are
not medicine strictly so called. The expression substances therefore, must be
something other than medicine which is used for treatment. However, the
appropriate meaning of the expression substances in the section is a thing.
Hence absorbent cotton wool, roller bandages and gauze are substances falls
within the meaning of the said expression. These things are for or in treatment.
The legislature has designed in such way to extend the definition of “drug†to
include substances.[10]In this a reported case the Bombay High Court discussed
the, question arose whether ‘Boroline' is a Drug or not? And, it was held that Boroline is a Drug. It appears that the Act wants to classify these articles in
two parts, i.e. Drug and Cosmetics. Since the Boroline cannot be used for
cleansing any part of the human body, nor it is used for beautifying or
promoting attractiveness, it is very difficult to classify the Boroline as a
cosmetic. It is true that prevention of an infection is certainly a prevention
of disease in another form, simply because disease is followed by infection.
Boroline, no doubt, is used for preventing of infection in case of minor cuts
and minor skin injuries. From the formula, as mentioned on the carton, it prime
facie appears that Boroline contains certain medicinal quantities. In Further
Act 1940, defines[11]‘Misbranded Drug',[12]‘Adulterer Drug', and[13]‘Spurious
Drug'. If we go through these definitions, we will find out that this Act and
other coming Act defines characteristic of the drug and what makes drug but they
failed to define the word drug. The Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable
Advertisement) Act, 1954 was passed to control the advertisement of drugs in
certain cases. Section 2(B) defines drug. It is same as of Act of 1940[14]. The
Narcotic Drug and Psychotropic Substances Act 1985 defines cannabis, cannabis
plant, coca derivative, coca leaf, coca plant, controlled substance,
manufactured drug, medicinal cannabis, opium, narcotic drug, opium derivative,
opium poppy, poppy straw, poppy straw concentrate, psychotropic substance. It
has not defined drug in the Act.[15]Heroin being an opium is manufactured drug;
in the cases it was held that whether a particular substance is drug or not, but
it does not solved the question of definition of drug. Prevention of Illicit
Traffic in Narcotic Drug and Psychotropic Substances Act 1988 was consolidated
to deal with illicit traffic in NDPS since this is a serious threat to the
health and welfare of the people and the activities of persons engaged in such
illicit traffic. This Act talks about authority, procedure, duty of government,
etc.[16]This Act gives Schedule A, B, C. Which deals about “Controlled
Substances whose manufacture, distribution, sale, purchase, possession, storage,
and consumptionâ€, ‘Schedule B' talks about “Controlled Substances whose expert
from Indiaâ€, ‘Schedule C' talks about “Controlled Substances whose import into
India is subject to controlâ€.
International Aspect
Three Conventions were adopted by the United Nations Organisations (herein after
referred to as the ‘UNO'), Convention of 1961, 1971 and 1988. The Economic and
Social Council of the United Nation had passed resolutions to adopt Conventions
on NDPS. India was represented in these conferences. 1961 Single Convention on
Narcotic Drugs, Article 1(j) defines ‘Drug' as any of the substances in Schedule
I and II, whether natural or synthetic. Schedule I contains Drug like Acetorphine, Alfentanil, Benzethidine, Coca leaf, cocaine, Heroin, MPPP,
Morphine, etc. Schedule II contain drug like Acetyldihydrocodine, Codeine,
Dextropropoxyphene, dihydrocodeine, ethylmorphine, nicocodine, nicodicodine,
narcodeine, pholcodine, propiram. 1971 Single Convention on Psychotropic
Substances deal with Psychotropic Substances, Article 1(e) of the Convention
defines it as any substances, natural or synthetic, or any natural material in
Schedule I, II, III or IV. Schedule I contains LSD, DOET, DOB, MDMA, PHP etc.
Schedule II contains PCP, ZIPEPROL, etc. Schedule III contains CATHINE,
PENTOBARBITAL etc. Schedule IV contains SPA, ALLOBARBITAL, CLOBAZAM, DIAZEPAM
etc. Convention 1988, deal with the Illicit Trafficking in NDPS. SAARC
Convention on NDPS for regional co operation between the South ASIAN Association
for NDPS was passed.
Debate between DRUG and MEDICINE: The term Drug is both socially contested and
culturally context-specific. Some countries (for ex. UK) distinguish between
substances that are medically and legally sanctioned known as ‘Medicine', and
substances that are disapproved of in some way and known as ‘Drug'. By contrast
countries such as USA term all psychoactive substances regardless legal status
or medical sanction as DRUGS, as epitomised in the term ‘Drug Store' rather than
Pharmacy. Other countries do not have a word Drug and do not make a distinction
between socially sanctioned medicines and socially disapproved or illicit
drug[17]. As Mary Douglas (1978) expressed it, ‘a drug is a chemical which is in
the wrong place at the wrong time'. Derrida (1993, in Fraser and Moore, 2011;
10) there are no drugs in “natureâ€.... the concept of drugs is not a scientific
concept, but is rather instituted on the basis of moral or political
evaluations'.
There is also a debate between the terms ‘Drug' and ‘Substance'[18]. The 1992
World Health Organisation expert committee included both legal and illegal
psychoactive substances within its definition of the drug.
Conclusion
After going through National and International Statutes upon NDPS and Case laws,
it is concluded that there is no specific and clear definition for the word DRUG
anywhere. Since without knowing essential elements of a particular term we can't
make it fall within the law or legal action. Due to lack of specific definition
in every case come before court, first the courts have to decide, whether
substances in question of law are they drug or not? Once it is decided that,
they are drugs only then case will be decided by the competent court or
competent authority. Word Drug have very wide scope, it not only includes
medicine but also includes substances, machine, etc. Lack of Legal definition
for the term leads to vacuum in the law. Since my topic is in context to
narcotic it is very necessary to define word drug to make a case admissible
before court for concluding that whether a substance is a drug or not.
End-Notes
[1]1stYear LL.M., Dept of Criminal Law and Criminal Justice Administration, The
Tamil Nadu Dr.Ambedkar Law University, Chennai.
[2]1stYear LL.M., Dept of Criminal Law and Criminal Justice Administration, The
Tamil Nadu Dr.Ambedkar Law University, Chennai.
[3]https://www.etymonline.com/word/drug. Accessed on 18thApril 2018
[4]Ross Coomber, 2013, “Key Concept in Drug and Societyâ€, SAGE Publications.
[5]Article 47 of the Indian Constitution says that “ duty of the state to raise
the level of nutrition and the standard of living and to improve public health-
the state shall regard the raising of the level of nutrition and the standard of
living of its people and the improvement of public health as among its primary
duties and, in particular, the state shall endeavour to bring about prohibition
of the consumption except for medicinal purposes of intoxicating drinks and of
drugs which are injurious to healthâ€
[6](g) "manufactured drug" includes—
(i) all coca derivatives, medicinal hemp and opium derivatives; and
(ii) any other narcotic substance which the President of the Union may, by
notification in the Gazette made in pursuance of a recommendation under Article
10 of the Geneva Convention or in pursuance of any international convention
supplementing the Geneva Convention, declare to be a manufactured drug ;
but does not include any preparation which the President of the Union may. by
notification in the Gazette made in pursuance of a finding under Article 8 of
the Geneva Convention, declare not to be a manufactured drug ;
(h) "dangerous drug" includes coca leaf, hemp and opium, and all manufactured
drugs;
[7]Section 3(aaa) cosmetic “ means any article intended to be rubbed, poured,
sprinkled or sprayed on, or introduced into, or otherwise applied to the human
body or any part thereof for cleansing, beautifying, promoting attractiveness,
or altering the appearance, and includes any article intended for use as a
component of cosmetic;
[8]Section 3(b) drug “includes—
[(i)all medicines for internal or external use of human beings or animals and
all substances intended to be used for or in the diagnosis, treatment,
mitigation or prevention of any disease or disorder in human beings or animals,
including preparations applied on human body for the purpose of repelling
insects like mosquitoes;]
(ii) such substances (other than food) intended to affect the structure or any
function of the human body or intended to be used for the destruction of
[vermin] or insects which cause disease in human beings or animals, as may be
specified from time to time by the Central Government by notification in the
Official Gazette;] [(iii)all substances intended for use as components of a
drug including empty gelatine capsules; and
(iv)such devices intended for internal or external use in the diagnosis,
treatment, mitigation or prevention of disease or disorder in human beings or
animals, as may be specified from time to time by the Central Government by
notification in the Official Gazette, after consultation with the Board;]
[9]Chaman Lal Jagjivan Das Seth v. State of Maharashtra1963 Mah LJ 276, AIR
1963 SC 665
[10]Abdul Mohid v. State of U.P. 1977 Cr.LJ 1325(Alld. HC)
[11]Section 9 says that any Drug which is coloured, coated, powered or polished
or it appear of better therapeutic value, or not labelled in prescribed manner,
any statement or design makes false claims for the drug or false leading of any
particular.
[12]Section 9(A) says that drug which consists whole or any part filthy, putrid
or decomposed substance or, prepared, packed, or stored under insanitary
condition, containment of drug with unhealthy conditions, or if container is
composed of any poisonous or deleterious substance which may render the contents
injurious to health, used unprescribed colour, contain any harmful or toxic
substances which may injurious to health, mixing of any substances to reduce its
quality or strength,
[13]Section 9(B) says that drug which imported under a name which is belong to
another drug, if it imitates or substitute another drug in a manner likely to
deceive, and conspicuously marked so as to reveal its true character and its
lack of identity with such deceived drug, company is factious or does not exist
of which label drug is having, substituted with another drug, purported to be
the product of a manufacturer of whom it is not truly a product )
[14]The Narcotic Drugs And Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
[15]T. Paul Kuki v. State of West Bengal(1993) 3 Crimes 660 (Cal) (DB)
[16]The Narcotic Drug and Psychotropic Substances( Regulation of Controlled
Substances) Order, 2013
[17]Douglas, M. (1978) “Purity and Danger: An Analysis of Concept of Pollution
and Tabooâ€. Youth and Drug Policy, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
[18]United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (1997) “World Drug Reportâ€. Vienna:
UNODC.
How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi Mutual Consent Divorce is the Simplest Way to Obtain a D...
It is hoped that the Prohibition of Child Marriage (Amendment) Bill, 2021, which intends to inc...
One may very easily get absorbed in the lives of others as one scrolls through a Facebook news ...
The Inherent power under Section 482 in The Code Of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (37th Chapter of t...
The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) is a concept that proposes the unification of personal laws across...
Artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing various sectors of the economy, and the legal i...
Please Drop Your Comments